FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1042895384> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1042895384 abstract "We appreciate the authors’ comment on our work and agree that much “ink has been spilt” in paleoanthropology in discussing the linguistic abilities of Neandertals and their ancestors. We would not confine the “spilt ink” to just paleoanthropologists. After all, these authors are not paleoanthropologists and only 11 of their 52 citations (~21%) are written by paleoanthropologists. There is a lot of “spilt ink” and felled trees, ---the collective responsibility of decades of speculation on language origins by paleoanthropologists, paleoneurologists, anatomists, linguists, psychologists, animal ethologists, natural philosophers and popularists. We recognize determining language capacity in fossils is risky business, but contend our argument that Neandertals (and, at least, their European ancestors) likely had linguistic skills similar to modern humans is not far-fetched. Our position is not solely based on the ~90% frequency of right-handedness in Neandertals, but a confluence of internally consistent evidence from different disciplines. First off, we retract the one time we used “complex language skills,” – this slipped by our editing. In fact, we do not know what “complex language” or “complex language skills” mean since any language is complex. We only argue that Neandertals and their European forebears had linguistic competence similar to ours. There is not space to cover all our objections to their view, so we focus on mainly those related to their unfamiliarity with the paleoanthropological literature. They cite Bax & Ungar (1999) as evidence that the labial striations in the Vindija teeth may not be related to handedness. In the four samples Bax and Ungar analyzed, scratches did not correspond to the Neandertal pattern. But, Lozano et al. (2009, pp. 373-4) argued the scratches described by Bax and Ungar are not morphologically comparable to the fossil examples and are likely the result of dietary habits, unrelated to scratches left by lithic tools. Spanish researchers have done experimental archaeology with living rightand left-handers and different lithics (Bermudez de Castro, Bromage & Fernandez-Jalvo, 1988; Lozano et al., 2004; Lozano et al., 2009) and conclude that the scratches left by modern experiments exactly match the fossil marks. Finally, Bax and Ungar (1999, p. 197) conclude:" @default.
• W1042895384 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1042895384 creator A5005627821 @default.
• W1042895384 creator A5020783420 @default.
• W1042895384 creator A5022518970 @default.
• W1042895384 creator A5078996942 @default.
• W1042895384 creator A5086273950 @default.
• W1042895384 date "2012-01-01" @default.
• W1042895384 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
• W1042895384 title "Replay to Benítez-Burraco & Longa: when is enough, enough?" @default.
• W1042895384 cites W10313498 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1484803090 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1529655887 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1563153440 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1691529229 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1964474357 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1966053139 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1968194149 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1968714081 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1973679540 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1979194325 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1979337334 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W1989108360 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2004075356 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2016342908 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2020706664 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2037945685 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2038510581 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2042215994 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2042971945 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2045993289 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2046377345 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2047463156 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2059111103 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2073805229 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2086973755 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2101778559 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2102806079 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2123428234 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2129427301 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2134696918 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2140461400 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2150461804 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2150942859 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2152035025 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2158574777 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2223457913 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W2331899649 @default.
• W1042895384 cites W566920042 @default.
• W1042895384 doi "https://doi.org/10.4436/jass.90003" @default.
• W1042895384 hasPublicationYear "2012" @default.
• W1042895384 type Work @default.
• W1042895384 sameAs 1042895384 @default.
• W1042895384 citedByCount "1" @default.
• W1042895384 countsByYear W10428953842020 @default.
• W1042895384 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W1042895384 hasAuthorship W1042895384A5005627821 @default.
• W1042895384 hasAuthorship W1042895384A5020783420 @default.
• W1042895384 hasAuthorship W1042895384A5022518970 @default.
• W1042895384 hasAuthorship W1042895384A5078996942 @default.
• W1042895384 hasAuthorship W1042895384A5086273950 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConcept C136815107 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConcept C197698901 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConceptScore W1042895384C111472728 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConceptScore W1042895384C136815107 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConceptScore W1042895384C138885662 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConceptScore W1042895384C166957645 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConceptScore W1042895384C197698901 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConceptScore W1042895384C41895202 @default.
• W1042895384 hasConceptScore W1042895384C95457728 @default.
• W1042895384 hasLocation W10428953841 @default.
• W1042895384 hasOpenAccess W1042895384 @default.
• W1042895384 hasPrimaryLocation W10428953841 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W109876131 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W14338560 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W1667373774 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W1985952512 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2000675250 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2002938097 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2080040754 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2088351374 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2120789758 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2158044692 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2186927439 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2315367919 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2318745358 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2325338539 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W243754919 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2460715782 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2473328580 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W261706720 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W827556018 @default.
• W1042895384 hasRelatedWork W2141405698 @default.
• W1042895384 isParatext "false" @default.
• W1042895384 isRetracted "false" @default.

• next