Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1223297319> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1223297319 abstract "Over the last decade, EU–Russia gas relations have witnessed significant deterioration—the bilateral agenda has been narrowed down to ad hoc consultations, disputes over investment and long-term contract provisions have multiplied, and disagreements between the EU and Russia have significantly hindered the multilateral process of the Energy Charter Treaty (the ECT). This deterioration seems to be rather paradoxical in light of high gas interdependence between the EU and Russia and a rich history of well-established cooperation during the Cold War under profound ideological and strategic constraints. In addition, conflictual patterns in EU–Russia gas relations occurred in the beginning of the 2000s, during the period of high oil prices and growing global natural gas demand—the period when enhancement of cooperation would be a more expected outcome. Therefore, the core research question of the thesis addresses the puzzle: why, despite decades of cooperation during the Cold War between Western European countries and the USSR, have EU–Russia gas relations become conflictual since the 2000s? By answering this research question, the study seeks to contribute to the analysis of institutionalisation of energy relations and to reveal factors that lead to cooperative or conflictual outcomes. So far, IR research inquiries in the field have prioritised resource and normative determinisms in addressing the success or failure of energy cooperation, which assume a geopolitical-realist struggle for energy resources and a priori benevolence of free markets in line with the neoliberal economic agenda respectively. The broader geopolitical approach has explained energy conflicts by structural factors of unequal resource allocation across the world and attributed a direct impact of a state resource base (an energy-rich or energy-poor state) on states’ behaviour in the international arena. Another strand of the literature, ‘the market approach’, has also viewed problematic cooperation as a result of different interests of energy producers and consumers—but from a slightly different perspective. Limited institutionalisation of interactions has been explained by different models of gas markets producers and consumers choose. Thus, consumers favour a model of the competitive liberalised gas market (a market actor model), while producers would opt for a model of vertically-integrated monopoly and resource nationalism (a geopolitical actor model) in order to preserve control over resources. Pointing to a number of opposite cases, this study disregards the straightforward assumption that there is a direct link between a resource base and states’ strategies in the international arena. Bringing domestic conditions back to these debates, the study argues that increasing differences between the EU and Russia’s domestic institutional models of the gas market have been the main factor that has triggered conflictual patterns in EU–Russia gas relations since the 2000s. These domestic institutional changes have replaced attempts to build a strategic partnership with ad hoc consultations at the level of practical implementation, and have triggered broader deinstitutionalisation of multilateral gas governance in Europe. The three case studies analyse three instances of EU–Russia gas relations, tracing the crucial differences to determine the outcome—cooperation (a creation of a new or enhancement of an existing international institution), institutionalised conflict (disagreements regarding institutional settings of interactions, which are discussed and settled within the procedures of pre-existing or negotiated international institutions), or institutional conflict (expansion of disagreements beyond the pre-existing or negotiated framework of international institutions, which are no more accepted by the parties for conflict resolution) between the parties. The thesis contributes to ongoing debates about the impact of domestic institutions on actors’ policy strategies in the international arena, bringing insights from energy economics, energy law, and regulatory studies to IR. It argues that differences in domestic models under conditions of high interdependence might lead to politicisation of gas market issues and broader aspects of energy governance. The study also enriches debates about energy security, arguing that energy security depends also on a stable and predictable institutional framework for interactions, which inter alia requires compatibility of actors’ domestic models." @default.
- W1223297319 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1223297319 creator A5024188429 @default.
- W1223297319 date "2015-04-16" @default.
- W1223297319 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W1223297319 title "The Conflict-Cooperation Nexus. Politicisation, Security and Domestic Institutions in EU-Russia Energy Relations" @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1479915330 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1492501891 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1494051312 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1502798522 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W150706196 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1510874235 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1511110019 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1526154646 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1530085321 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1531204222 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1546856989 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1548006256 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1551501662 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1567440859 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1574911135 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1582253439 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1582548885 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1584458907 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1726446812 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1827624745 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1859643301 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1919749412 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W195641260 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1957011153 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1958735600 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1965349186 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1968194520 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1970635216 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1972169125 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1976597062 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1977760162 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1978918752 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1982249160 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1983224849 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1983338036 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1984891383 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1985544491 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1989275205 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1989889998 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1990893518 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1995235679 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1997727141 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1998496960 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1999316778 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W1999858737 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2006240199 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2006437172 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2012521719 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2013154987 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2013907134 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2016103821 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2022278376 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2027111931 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2027773074 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2036379615 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2040865155 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2041788929 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2043610318 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2044863427 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2053037581 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2054829614 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2055196572 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2059737091 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2060322138 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2067485047 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2070343248 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2072847517 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2075607904 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2076153090 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2076391975 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2083209138 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2085579946 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2090643970 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2092617612 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2095336772 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2099896980 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2101228039 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2108935876 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2115364763 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2119865379 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2120105854 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2129543639 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2136231915 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2137750561 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2139129976 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2143376933 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2143750282 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2144124647 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2144289211 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2151550206 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2153110976 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2155424107 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2156625419 @default.
- W1223297319 cites W2164095277 @default.