Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W140563134> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W140563134 abstract "This starting point for this project was the question of how to understand the epistemic status of mathematized imaging technologies such as positron emission tomography (PET) and confocal microscopy. These sorts of instruments play an increasingly important role in virtually all areas of biology and medicine. Some of these technologies have been widely celebrated as having revolutionized various fields of studies while others have been the target of substantial criticism. Thus, it is essential that we be able to assess these sorts of technologies as methods of producing evidence. They differ from one another in many respects, but one feature they all have in common is the use of multiple layers of statistical and mathematical processing that are essential to data production. This feature alone means that they do not fit neatly into any standard empiricist account of evidence. Yet this failure to be accommodated by philosophical accounts of good evidence does not indicate a general inadequacy on their part since, by many measures, they very often produce very high quality evidence. In order to understand how they can do so, we must look more closely at old philosophical questions concerning the role of experience and observation in acquiring knowledge about the external world. Doing so leads us to a new, grounded version of empiricism.After distinguishing between a weaker and a stronger, anthropomorphic version of empiricism, I argue that most contemporary accounts of observation are what I call benchmark strategies that, implicitly or explicitly, rely on the stronger version according to which human sense experience holds a place of unique privilege. They attempt to extend the bounds of observation - and the epistemic privilege accorded to it - by establishing some type of relevant similarity to the benchmark of human perception. These accounts fail because they are unable to establish an epistemically motivated account of what relevant similarity consists of. The last best chance for any benchmark approach, and, indeed, for anthropomorphic empiricism, is to supplement a benchmark strategy with a grounding strategy. Toward this end, I examine the Grounded Benchmark Criterion which defines relevant similarity to human perception to be defined in terms of the reliability-making features of human perception. This account, too, must fail due to our inability to specify these features given the current state of understanding of the human visual system. However, this failure reveals that it is reliability alone that is epistemically relevant, not any other sort of similarity to human perception.Current accounts of reliability suffer from a number of difficulties, so I develop a novel account of reliability that is based on the concept of granularity. My account of reliability in terms of a granularity match both provides the means to refine the weaker version of empiricism and allows us to establish when and why imaging technologies are reliable. Finally, I use this account of granularity is examining the importance of the fact that the output of imaging technologies usually is images." @default.
- W140563134 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W140563134 creator A5013096855 @default.
- W140563134 date "2005-10-04" @default.
- W140563134 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W140563134 title "Empiricism and the Epistemic Status of Imaging Technologies" @default.
- W140563134 cites W134031442 @default.
- W140563134 cites W135872970 @default.
- W140563134 cites W146401182 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1493940197 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1494063298 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1501035797 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1505582986 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1511080108 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1521787526 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1524143658 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1529764976 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1537197851 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1554228597 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1570047706 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1571008965 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1574318835 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1576782956 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1586420997 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1587654115 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1592652287 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1643398388 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1650310283 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1655654231 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1749379549 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1751175273 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1791834434 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1804395613 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1902253552 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1908526098 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1964015820 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1965908643 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1968982218 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1969211283 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1969529608 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1973502934 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1978064597 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1979446637 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1979559114 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1980960123 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1984512236 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1986014504 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1986979777 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1988387424 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1988873933 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1988930558 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1990016986 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1993091629 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1994757764 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1996934409 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1997459925 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1997626261 @default.
- W140563134 cites W1997816453 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2000217017 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2002993931 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2003705449 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2003724127 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2005684097 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2007153649 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2008058189 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2008252835 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2009179626 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2010931698 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2011594609 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2011926036 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2017660912 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2019161608 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2019720837 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2023887962 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2024748458 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2024986101 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2025847278 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2026655477 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2028927785 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2030031014 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2030297824 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2030863706 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2034036293 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2034441520 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2036084760 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2038401657 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2038453214 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2040132209 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2041716195 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2043450412 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2044428372 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2045192497 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2045548575 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2047556230 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2048122125 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2048331923 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2049506340 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2049648156 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2049696674 @default.
- W140563134 cites W2051850664 @default.