Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W140674910> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W140674910 abstract "The state of the notion critical in theory and research is open to a yawning discussion.The political challenges that critical scholars have taken up are usually accompanied bymethodological frameworks that have been appropriated to fit the nature of their criticalenterprise. The “critical” of the 1980s, 1990s or 2000s, particularly in educational research andtheory has allowed distinct heavens for educational scholars in line with their different sociopoliticalpositionalities, usually in tangent with social theory and epistemology. This dissertationproject problematizes contemporary portrayals of the “critical” in regards to the question ofreferentiality and bordering and the associations between critique and critical, while examiningconstructions of the critical in the field of educational research through working its variousaspects such as mechanisms and functions of critical, alignments of critical, epistemic vs.empirical criticals, and homologic productions of difference within the critical scholarship. Thishas been done through analysis of research data conducted through systematic content analysisof education and educational research journals, as well as data from interviews with “critical”scholars at various US universities.Content analysis and interview data indicate that the problematic of defining the “critical”contemporarily have to do with the same feature that set the critical initiative into motion at thehands of the Frankfurt School members in the first place. That the members of Frankfurt Schoolenvisioned a rupture with the past (the Enlightenment) as well as with the future (the finality ofthe liberal bourgeois order) suggests a domain that thought itself as oppositional, hence political,to the existing order and its relations of power. Therefore, the critical as one of the buildingblocks of critical research theory and practice is employed for specific tasks relativelyindependent from each other, suggesting that attachments/attributions to the notion of criticalsuch as normative claims, political commitments, and value orientations carried the discussionover the realm of the identity problematic within the academy. Drawing on Bourdieu’s fieldtheory, as well as on patterns abstracted from content analysis throughout this dissertation, I alsoargued that the critical enterprise is not a static theoretical construct that is applicable acrossdifferent research studies. Nor is it limited to the realm of the theoretical; for its usage inempirical studies and the contextual and conceptual variations that its instances, from Germanidealism to French structuralism, etc., underline the need to adopt both theoretical and empiricaltools in order to explore the current manifestations of the critical enterprise. Moreover, thepolitical dimension of research construction and practice is inherent to the various aspects of thesocial, academic, and personal and is re-enforced through power relations within the field." @default.
- W140674910 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W140674910 creator A5071640600 @default.
- W140674910 date "2010-01-01" @default.
- W140674910 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W140674910 title "Critical qualitative research in education: Notes from the field" @default.
- W140674910 cites W1227355589 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1489396115 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1493632016 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1500549500 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1515986151 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1522588346 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1532256706 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1533200881 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1533937721 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1537640319 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1538843321 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1542915655 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1543353770 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1557459633 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1561770992 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1577785489 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1581605711 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1606217168 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1620408265 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1752129191 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1765434025 @default.
- W140674910 cites W181724819 @default.
- W140674910 cites W186296790 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1963733868 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1965188956 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1970936211 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1972252690 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1973893364 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1979731710 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1980006721 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1982623435 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1985716515 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1987109970 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1988244460 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1993927859 @default.
- W140674910 cites W1996282372 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2000548691 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2001243020 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2001498083 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2005061283 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2008415962 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2009963402 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2013057499 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2015802956 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2016780159 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2021551171 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2022637639 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2033877223 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2033952602 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2034825337 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2038600245 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2041299612 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2046214633 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2053501256 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2054988447 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2061363830 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2065241683 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2066277595 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2069288071 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2072086796 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2083902634 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2095311334 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2095481674 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2099052491 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2107132026 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2117509190 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2126175524 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2130729292 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2133766284 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2135137410 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2141523927 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2147168459 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2163204168 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2166724175 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2174401582 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2319031388 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2320796591 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2337392896 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2397580802 @default.
- W140674910 cites W239773369 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2496163105 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2501254025 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2622829880 @default.
- W140674910 cites W269058144 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2748025866 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2799527434 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2892747141 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2896771278 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2920977327 @default.
- W140674910 cites W2955507426 @default.
- W140674910 cites W31957317 @default.
- W140674910 cites W388150628 @default.
- W140674910 cites W393321683 @default.
- W140674910 cites W571916422 @default.