Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W141669897> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W141669897 endingPage "482" @default.
- W141669897 startingPage "457" @default.
- W141669897 abstract "Judgment aggregation is the subject of a growing body of work in economics, political science, philosophy and related disciplines. Although the literature on judgment aggregation has been inuenced by earlier work in social choice theory, the recent interest in the problem was sparked by the so-called doctrinal paradoxin law and economics (Kornhauser and Sager 1986). Suppose a three-member court has to reach a verdict in a breach-of-contract case. According to legal doctrine, the defendant is liable (the conclusion, here denoted c) if and only if he or she did a particular action and had a contractual obligation not to do it (the two premises, here denoted a and b). The doctrinal paradox consists in the fact that majority voting on the premises may support a di¤erent verdict from majority voting on the conclusion. As illustrated in Table 1, suppose the rst judge holds both premises to be true; the second holds the rst premise, but not the second, to be true; and the third holds the second premise, but not the rst, to be true. Then a majority of judges holds each premise to be true, which seems to support a liable verdict, and yet a majority of judges holds the conclusion to be false. Although the rst discussions of this problem focused on the distinction between premise-basedand conclusion-basedmethods of decision-making, the doctrinal paradox illustrates a more general point, which Pettit (2001) has called the discursive dilemma: Majority voting on multiple, interconnected propositions may lead to an inconsistent set of collective judgments. In the court example, majorities accept a, b, [c if and only if (a and b)], and the negation of c, an inconsistent set of propositions in the standard sense of logic (see also Brennan 2001). Naturally, the observation that majority voting may fail to produce consistent collective judgments raises several questions. In particular, how general is the problem? Is" @default.
- W141669897 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W141669897 creator A5070694496 @default.
- W141669897 creator A5080754318 @default.
- W141669897 date "2009-01-15" @default.
- W141669897 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W141669897 title "Judgment aggregation: a survey" @default.
- W141669897 cites W1965445794 @default.
- W141669897 cites W1976690484 @default.
- W141669897 cites W1985230145 @default.
- W141669897 cites W1993313925 @default.
- W141669897 cites W1995836712 @default.
- W141669897 cites W1996971007 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2007189251 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2017495431 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2019568097 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2021989258 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2035161128 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2058696778 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2059915693 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2060612256 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2095555853 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2095567645 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2095676952 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2102741893 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2103909532 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2113597321 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2121203835 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2122533453 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2127172185 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2128217551 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2138621916 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2142550658 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2151642490 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2152001004 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2158010798 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2162359459 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2165733306 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2305931698 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2318031348 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2588173753 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2794172440 @default.
- W141669897 cites W2800660311 @default.
- W141669897 cites W3021853878 @default.
- W141669897 cites W3125225778 @default.
- W141669897 cites W3125297744 @default.
- W141669897 cites W3141728133 @default.
- W141669897 cites W41086226 @default.
- W141669897 cites W1823114533 @default.
- W141669897 hasPublicationYear "2009" @default.
- W141669897 type Work @default.
- W141669897 sameAs 141669897 @default.
- W141669897 citedByCount "100" @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972012 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972013 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972014 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972015 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972016 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972017 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972018 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972019 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972020 @default.
- W141669897 countsByYear W1416698972021 @default.
- W141669897 crossrefType "book-chapter" @default.
- W141669897 hasAuthorship W141669897A5070694496 @default.
- W141669897 hasAuthorship W141669897A5080754318 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C144237770 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C153668964 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C161191863 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C189352744 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C190253527 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C2776211767 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C2776213154 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C2777855551 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C2778023277 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C2778447849 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C2778496695 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C520049643 @default.
- W141669897 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C111472728 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C138885662 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C144024400 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C144237770 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C153668964 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C161191863 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C162324750 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C17744445 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C189352744 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C190253527 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C199539241 @default.
- W141669897 hasConceptScore W141669897C2776211767 @default.