FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1489225963> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1489225963 abstract "United States v. Klein, decided during Reconstruction, was the first Supreme Court case to invalidate a statutory restriction on federal courts’ jurisdiction. It is the only one to do so by finding a violation of Article III of the Constitution. Klein has been cited in thirty-three United States Supreme Court opinions, and roughly five hundred times each by lower federal courts and law journal articles. Recent commentators have read Klein both too broadly and narrowly. Its central holding is that Congress may not grant federal courts jurisdiction to decide a set of cases on the merits while depriving them of jurisdiction to apply specified parts of the Constitution in reaching their decisions. Read through the proper interpretive lenses, Klein has a great deal more to say than this, indeed a great deal more than I thought or expressed in 1981 in the earliest comprehensive article on the case. By means of the law of judgments and preclusion, Klein is best explained as entailed by Congress’s lack of power to simultaneously court-strip the state as well as the federal courts of thw powe to enforce constitutional rights. Despite my earlier doubts and some new Klein scholarship that would read it more narrowly, Klein can best be read as more broadly prohibiting statutory interference with federal courts’ processes of fact-finding and their methods of both constitutional and statutory interpretation. These attractive readings of Klein call into question one federal post-conviction habeas corpus statute and, possibly, parts of the War on Terror, that restrict the courts’ use of foreign and international law, including the Geneva Conventions. Some recent scholarship seems to read Klein too narrowly as placing no restrictions on Congress’s power to control how federal courts interpret statutes. Other recent scholarship reads it too broadly. The latter takes its prohibitions far beyond protection of federal courts’ decision processes, seeing in Klein, a holding that prohibits otherwise constitutional legislation on grounds that it would deceive the public. This attributed holding seems an unfortunate one. It would task courts with the job of requiring reasonable truth in legislation. That is a job that neither the Court at the time of Klein, nor the current Supreme Court, would relish or would be likely to find required of it by the Constitution. Beyond these issues, this Article explores the connections between Klein’s central holding against treating federal courts as puppets and the perennial debate about court-stripping; specifically, Congress’s power simply to exclude classes of constitutional claims from federal court enforcement." @default.
• W1489225963 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1489225963 creator A5019616609 @default.
• W1489225963 date "2012-01-01" @default.
• W1489225963 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
• W1489225963 title "United States v. Klein, Then and Now" @default.
• W1489225963 hasPublicationYear "2012" @default.
• W1489225963 type Work @default.
• W1489225963 sameAs 1489225963 @default.
• W1489225963 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W1489225963 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
• W1489225963 hasAuthorship W1489225963A5019616609 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C126053111 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C158129432 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C17319257 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C2776154427 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C2776449231 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C2776949292 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C2777006572 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C2777351106 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C2778272461 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C2779204856 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C38671928 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C533735693 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C87501996 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C126053111 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C158129432 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C17319257 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C17744445 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C199539241 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C2776154427 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C2776449231 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C2776949292 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C2777006572 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C2777351106 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C2778272461 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C2779204856 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C38671928 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C533735693 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C87501996 @default.
• W1489225963 hasConceptScore W1489225963C94625758 @default.
• W1489225963 hasLocation W14892259631 @default.
• W1489225963 hasOpenAccess W1489225963 @default.
• W1489225963 hasPrimaryLocation W14892259631 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W1552268399 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W1590684528 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W2053844479 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W2179647680 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W233465426 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W233716482 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W253492520 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W281723904 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3121313475 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3121446480 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3122281400 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3123750909 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3124998576 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W319781988 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3204515790 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W324562210 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W347026414 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W217293300 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3122227882 @default.
• W1489225963 hasRelatedWork W3125656750 @default.
• W1489225963 isParatext "false" @default.
• W1489225963 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W1489225963 magId "1489225963" @default.
• W1489225963 workType "article" @default.