FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1502079832> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1502079832 abstract "The thesis is that Aristotle's theory of justice, particularly Particular Justice, is only properlyexplicable in terms of proportion theory. In the innumerable assessments of the theory that havebeen made nods have been given in the direction of analogy, but nods only. Almost always these have been accompanied by complaints about Aristotle's persistently dragging in 'mathematical' figures, references, and explanations. What these complaints have overlooked is that the theory issoaked in the language of proportionality because his conception of Particular Justice is inherently(and in a sense only) about greater and less. Hence it is about equality; and hence about the modes of equality. I have, therefore, begun by looking at the nature of ratio and proportion; at the models of proportion known by Aristotle's time; and especially at the then new Eudoxian theory of proportions. Aristotle combines these with his own heuristic development of generic structure. His use of generic structure in the life-sciences has become better understood than hitherto, but not so much its combination with analogy. In the areas of justice and exchange the combination has hardly been appreciated at all.From the 17th century onwards, both the structure of the theory, and the nature of the forms of justice within the structure, have been almost universally misrepresented. The result has been (he belief among all commentators that the structure of the theory is unsatisfactory. The dissatisfaction stems from suppositions that Aristotle presents (in at least some sense) 'Corrective Justice’. These (mis)perceptions then result in claims for a third species or genus of justice, or that the given speciesare not firmly drawn, or that, whether there are two or three species, the issues are inadequately conceived. Against all these modern interpretations I defend Aquinas's presentation of the theory (of Particular justice, not his understanding of justice in general). The detailed analysis of the text I offer—giving due weight to the models of proportion which Aristotle uses (and declares) throughout—refutes, I believe, all the charges of inconsistency, confusion, and incompleteness, that have often been levelled against it.Aristotle works through his model of justice step-by-step; the last part of the model, the doctrine of exchanges, is treated by the last part of the thesis. This doctrine has been maligned even more, perhaps, than the earlier proposals of the species of justice. What, so far as I can tell, has never been grasped is that in chapter 5 Aristotle applies the Eudoxian theory of proportions in detail.Although he might not have been writing 'economics', the structure he gives is the deepest model of economic interactions that has yet been proposed. What are commonly dismissed as obvious, baffling, or unfortunate references to cobblers, variables, and beds are illustrations of the Eudoxian general theory of magnitude applied to the interactions which bind the participants into a community.As the issues touched on are inevitably wide-ranging I have attempted to write the narrative discussing only the central themes, but I have supplied footnotes (sometimes very extensive) elaborating many of the allied issues." @default.
• W1502079832 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1502079832 creator A5031585111 @default.
• W1502079832 date "1998-09-01" @default.
• W1502079832 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
• W1502079832 title "The role of analogy in Aristotle's theory of Particular Justice" @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1486506973 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1507368561 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1539191867 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1539263457 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1583908024 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1608653537 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W187544266 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1967029969 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1971924284 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1976731089 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1980524797 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1993091619 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W1999287368 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2005125140 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2008940368 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2012923302 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2016826192 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2023492486 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2028511520 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2042111225 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2056627086 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2056851739 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2059575104 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2060747148 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2061798179 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2063346535 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2065428977 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2068535508 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2069945183 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2072117812 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2074231110 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2077040474 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2078289099 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2087943418 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2090245630 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2123527580 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2141447094 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2312336034 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2322426130 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2326472295 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2327310820 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2332375892 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2612675639 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2772965923 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W278194467 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2795887424 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2800686025 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2987854245 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W2989605555 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W3129488679 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W3140604523 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W3145559215 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W3151032902 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W593547815 @default.
• W1502079832 cites W98361419 @default.
• W1502079832 hasPublicationYear "1998" @default.
• W1502079832 type Work @default.
• W1502079832 sameAs 1502079832 @default.
• W1502079832 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W1502079832 crossrefType "dissertation" @default.
• W1502079832 hasAuthorship W1502079832A5031585111 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConcept C139621336 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConcept C521332185 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConceptScore W1502079832C111472728 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConceptScore W1502079832C138885662 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConceptScore W1502079832C139621336 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConceptScore W1502079832C17744445 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConceptScore W1502079832C199539241 @default.
• W1502079832 hasConceptScore W1502079832C521332185 @default.
• W1502079832 hasLocation W15020798321 @default.
• W1502079832 hasOpenAccess W1502079832 @default.
• W1502079832 hasPrimaryLocation W15020798321 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W1967907475 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W1979044567 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W1986699756 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2005394447 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2017141018 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2034784836 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2142497591 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2199355952 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2264936517 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2312812810 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2313155838 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2313943134 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2314150618 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2315345751 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2319924019 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2329401673 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2404846254 @default.
• W1502079832 hasRelatedWork W2464222749 @default.

• next