Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1509015655> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1509015655 abstract "This interim report describes an alternative approach for evaluating the efficacy of using mercury (Hg) offsets to improve water quality. Hg-offset programs may allow dischargers facing higher-pollution control costs to meet their regulatory obligations by making more cost effective pollutant-reduction decisions. Efficient Hg management requires methods to translate that science and economics into a regulatory decision framework.This report documents the work in progress by the U.S. Geological Survey’s Western Geographic Science Center in collaboration with Stanford University toward developing this decision framework to help managers, regulators, and other stakeholders decide whether offsets can cost effectively meet the Hg total maximum daily load (TMDL) requirements in the Sacramento River watershed. Two key approaches being considered are: (1) a probabilistic approach that explicitly incorporates scientific uncertainty, cost information, and value judgments; and (2) a quantitative approach that captures uncertainty in testing the feasibility of Hg offsets.Current fate and transport-process models commonly attempt to predict chemical transformations and transport pathways deterministically. However, the physical, chemical, and biologic processes controlling the fate and transport of Hg in aquatic environments are complex and poorly understood. Deterministic models of Hg environmental behavior contain large uncertainties, reflecting this lack of understanding. The uncertainty in these underlying physical processes may produce similarly large uncertainties in the decisionmaking process. However, decisions about control strategies are still being made despite the large uncertainties in current Hg loadings, the relations between total Hg (HgT) loading and methylmercury (MeHg) formation, and the relations between control efforts and Hg content in fish.The research presented here focuses on an alternative analytical approach to the current use of safety factors and deterministic methods for Hg TMDL decision support, one that is fully compatible with an adaptive management approach. This alternative approach uses empirical data and informed judgment to provide a scientific and technical basis for helping National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit holders make management decisions. An Hg-offset system would be an option if a wastewater-treatment plant could not achieve NPDES permit requirements for HgT reduction.We develop a probabilistic decision-analytical model consisting of three submodels for HgT loading, MeHg, and cost mitigation within a Bayesian network that integrates information of varying rigor and detail into a simple model of a complex system. Hg processes are identified and quantified by using a combination of historical data, statistical models, and expert judgment. Such an integrated approach to uncertainty analysis allows easy updating of prediction and inference when observations of model variables are made. We demonstrate our approach with data from the Cache Creek watershed (a subbasin of the Sacramento River watershed).The empirical models used to generate the needed probability distributions are based on the same empirical models currently being used by the Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Cache Creek Hg TMDL working group. The significant difference is that input uncertainty and error are explicitly included in the model and propagated throughout its algorithms. This work demonstrates how to integrate uncertainty into the complex and highly uncertain Hg TMDL decisionmaking process. The various sources of uncertainty are propagated as decision risk that allows decisionmakers to simultaneously consider uncertainties in remediation/implementation costs while attempting to meet environmental/ecologic targets.We must note that this research is on going. As more data are collected, the HgT and cost-mitigation submodels are updated and the uncertainties may be reduced. Subsequently, the value of using a probabilistic framework for estimating and explicitly stating these uncertainties within a decisionmaking process can be estimated when new data are collected.Future work includes the design and implementation of a Bayesian network decision support system (BN-DSS) to produce mitigation scenarios for offset-project evaluation in the Cache Creek watershed. The decisionmaker, a wastewater-treatment plant, is expected to evaluate potential Hg-offset programs in terms of changes in HgT load changes, MeHg-production potential, project cost, and other suitability criteria. Subsequently, scenarios can be analyzed by performing sensitivity analyses and ranking environmental and economic uncertainties in terms of the decisionmaker’s preferences and risk choices. Such an analysis allows decisionmakers and stakeholders to explore various scenarios and predict the consequences of different stated preferences over outcomes." @default.
- W1509015655 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1509015655 creator A5041036987 @default.
- W1509015655 date "2004-01-01" @default.
- W1509015655 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W1509015655 title "Incorporating uncertainty into mercury-offset decisions with a probabilistic network for National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit holders: An interim report" @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1486587513 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1494159714 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1510605594 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1524137319 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1533618852 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1541229261 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1574396325 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1606458208 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1755360231 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W185293185 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W193993766 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1970105892 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1983197632 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1986808060 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W1991118187 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2006154742 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2008224475 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2008400633 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2018954148 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2022261649 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2034700025 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2037039518 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2039450318 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2049042829 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2051123304 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2065699488 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2068427841 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2068684223 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2086034391 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2086943598 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2087912496 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2105849304 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2110929766 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2113677269 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2114307208 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2114548855 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2114983456 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2115547774 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2143339976 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2166420173 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2326911894 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2586266486 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2605916941 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2796121453 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2913758949 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2994542080 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W3023562672 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W3121523752 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W429476170 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W638961544 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W972956786 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W161933469 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2030444281 @default.
- W1509015655 cites W2791141118 @default.
- W1509015655 doi "https://doi.org/10.3133/ofr20041408" @default.
- W1509015655 hasPublicationYear "2004" @default.
- W1509015655 type Work @default.
- W1509015655 sameAs 1509015655 @default.
- W1509015655 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W1509015655 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1509015655 hasAuthorship W1509015655A5041036987 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C107826830 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C112930515 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C127413603 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C134560507 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C2776957806 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C39432304 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C42475967 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C49937458 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C107826830 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C112930515 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C127413603 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C134560507 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C144133560 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C154945302 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C162324750 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C166957645 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C2776957806 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C39432304 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C41008148 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C42475967 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C49937458 @default.
- W1509015655 hasConceptScore W1509015655C95457728 @default.
- W1509015655 hasLocation W15090156551 @default.
- W1509015655 hasOpenAccess W1509015655 @default.
- W1509015655 hasPrimaryLocation W15090156551 @default.
- W1509015655 hasRelatedWork W158165400 @default.
- W1509015655 hasRelatedWork W1755878761 @default.