Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1523684795> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1523684795 abstract "<p>Legitimated and thereby dominant knowledges of youth violence that aim to explain its causes and develop ways of responding are primarily informed by a positivist scientifically-based mainstream psychology. The purpose of this thesis is to offer ways of (re)thinking youth violence outside of an objectivist paradigm. By examining the significant contextual issues and numerous complexities involved for young men who have been violent, this research critically analyses normative notions of youth violence. The theoretical and methodological foundation for this research employed a critical psychology framework along with a discourse analysis approach informed by poststructural concepts derived, primarily, from Michel Foucault. This research foundation has enabled the dominant constructions of youth violence that are reflected and (re)produced by mainstream psychology to be disrupted and hence the modernist assumptions in the positivist scientific basis of mainstream psychology are questioned. The participants in this study were seven young New Zealand men, aged between 14 and 17, who were incarcerated for violent offences. A poststructural discourse analysis of interviews with these young men critically examined the ways they spoke about their violence, their explanations for it as well as their ideas about intervention. My analysis shows that dominant constructions of youth violence that are (re)produced in mainstream psychology theories as taken-for-granted truths, can position violent young men as 'abnormal', 'deviant' and 'dangerous'. However, participants resisted these pathologising and demonising positions. Instead, they embraced the rational position of 'man'. Dominant discourses around traditional masculinity were identified as being of paramount importance to these young men and showed that successfully performing the subject position of 'man' took precedence for them. Being violent acted as a means for participants to achieve 'being a man'. Against this, therapeutic intervention designed to prevent future violence was viewed as irrelevant to these young men. In addition, the 'therapeutic subject' position made available within discourses of intervention did not enable young men to perform 'man' correctly. Contradictions are highlighted in this thesis, showing the multiple subjectivities of the participants, along with various effects of the differing discourses. This was most pronounced in the differences revealed in participants' talk of their general violence compared to their sexual violence. Since general violence was constructed as a way of 'getting it right as a man', participants spoke in considerable detail about their activities. However, participants were reluctant to talk about their sexual violence and silences predominated. As an alternative, they took up an 'unknowing' position about why they were sexually violent. Sexual violence was constructed as irrational and therefore unknowable. In contrast to not wanting intervention for their general violence, participants talked of a willingness to engage with therapeutic intervention. They positioned intervention experts as being able to make rational sense of their sexual violence and spoke of expectations that this would stop them from being sexually violent again. The limitations of traditional approaches to youth violence have been highlighted in this research. Such approaches are unable to attend to the contextual issues presented here or the complexities of multiple subjectivities. The construction of violence as a way to perform 'man' contests discourses of 'abnormality' that positions young men who have been violent as 'disordered' and 'deviant'. Future theorising about youth violence and subsequent intervention approaches require attending to the significance that normative notions of 'manhood' have in the (re)production of violence.</p>" @default.
- W1523684795 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1523684795 creator A5028040072 @default.
- W1523684795 date "2021-11-03" @default.
- W1523684795 modified "2023-09-30" @default.
- W1523684795 title "(Re)Thinking Young Men's Violence: a Discursive Critique of Dominant Constructions" @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1483822235 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1488749369 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1493636223 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1502794874 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1510426010 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1513091327 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1517588147 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1522656681 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1531591506 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1541193111 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1542883903 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1546933300 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1548391709 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1557513195 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1562208008 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1564452660 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1566416957 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1595523058 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1597750586 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1600984297 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1601477150 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1621250728 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1621373383 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1669315010 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1690152760 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1696156061 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1714863543 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1732651185 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1741321747 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1745520714 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1746720991 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1771129195 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1797488128 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1814207704 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W18883598 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1892512372 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1914201648 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W193515035 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1936633569 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1957045679 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1967541354 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1968109675 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1969742292 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1971506015 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1972941130 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1973716747 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1980175779 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1982752739 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1983105037 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1984897976 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1985302000 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1987197894 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1988045331 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1992329812 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W1996049514 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W199711878 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2000922708 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2008265598 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2015134954 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2016531165 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2017185347 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2019673313 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2024946470 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2026294830 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2033952602 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2046872396 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2047588198 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2050534102 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2051274678 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2061979702 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2063476230 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2065682878 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2068895614 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2069588607 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2077629564 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2085175561 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2086421802 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2087140979 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2094929387 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2095481674 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2096164212 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2099593116 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2101083789 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2105680651 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2108516408 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2113682721 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2115343912 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2119166430 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2120158885 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2124212437 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2126989368 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2132177612 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2132614011 @default.
- W1523684795 cites W2132738192 @default.