Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1539107242> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1539107242 abstract "While nearly everyone favors sustainability, few agree on what the term actually means. In the case of marine fisheries, what first appears simple – exploiting species at a level that does not diminish their productivity in the future – is confounded by the possible inclusion of social, cultural, and economic notions of sustainability, as well as the effects of fishing practices on the wider ecology (that is, on both non-target species and habitats) of the seas. These approaches are all important, but this paper will focus on measuring the biological sustainability of targeted species, which must precede (but certainly not preclude) all other measures of sustainability. While determining what is sustainable is tricky, it is not difficult to find examples of biologically unsustainable fisheries. From the dramatic collapse of the once prolific cod fisheries of New England and Eastern Canada to the decline of subsistence fisheries throughout the developing world, marine fisheries are a classic case where the sustainable development of a resource has been the exception rather than the rule. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO 2007), worldwide marine fish catches have declined over the last ten years and most marine capture fisheries are now either depleted or hovering at the brink of overexploitation. In the United States, the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS 2002) reports that almost one-third of U.S. fish stocks are overfished, or that 75% of U.S. commercial fish stocks are either overexploited or fully exploited. Some academics have suggested that the problem is even worse, estimating in the journal Science that since the advent of industrial fishing more than 90% of large predatory fish have been removed from the world’s oceans (Worm and Myers 2003). Subsequently, Nature published one extrapolation of current trends in loss of diversity and ecosystem function that predicted a global collapse of all commercial fisheries by 2048 (Worm et al 2006). This research succeeded admirably in raising eyebrows, as well as criticism. Fisheries scientist Ray Hilborn (2007a) depicts the 2048 prediction as “ridiculed by most fisheries scientists”, and describes similar studies, including the precipitous decline of large predatory fish, as “either outright wrong or serious distortions of reality” (citing, for example, Hampton et al 2005). In addition, pronouncements from agencies such as FAO that seem dire at first glance – such as listing the majority of fisheries as either fully or overexploited – belie the fact that for many countries, full exploitation is the stated goal of fisheries policy. The list also says nothing about whether overfished stocks are recovering or not. Finally, Hilborn (2003) notes that in the U.S. context, most fisheries classified as overfished are still producing significant catches, so that even if they were pessimistically producing only half of their potential yield, “U.S. production would [still] be at 84% of maximum” – which sounds very different than 75% overfished or fully exploited. The issue is not whether depletion is a widespread problem, but just how bad things have become, and what might be done to fix the problem. Part of this difference of opinion stems from the fact that fisheries can be managed for economic, biological, or social objectives. Not only are the criteria for success different in each of these cases, but also within similar fields, as is the case with fisheries scientists such as Hilborn and marine ecologists such as Myers and Worm. That social scientists are even less likely to agree on measures, let alone desired outcomes, only highlights the complexity of the issue. Measuring performance is crucial to understanding which fisheries are being successfully managed. This paper will focus on biological sustainability, as it lies at the heart of the sustainable development of marine resources. It will address the ways that institutional and political causes of depletion and the uncertain nature of fisheries science have undermined measures of biological Measuring the biological sustainability of marine fisheries: property rights, politics, and science Michael De Alessi* * Michael De Alessi, Department of Environmental Science, Policy, and Management at UC Berkeley, and a Senior Fellow at the Reason Foundation in Los Angeles. Email: dealessi=a=ix.netcom.com (replace =a= with @) 4 Measuring the biological sustainability of marine fisheries sustainability; explore ways that success may be better measured; and conclude with a proposal for a new approach to measuring biological sustainability." @default.
- W1539107242 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1539107242 creator A5068473895 @default.
- W1539107242 date "2008-06-23" @default.
- W1539107242 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W1539107242 title "Measuring the biological sustainability of marine fisheries: property rights, politics, and science" @default.
- W1539107242 cites W1559195278 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W1782148336 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W1972784130 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W1977881280 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W1997426161 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2006690779 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2012819751 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2022641937 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2033911592 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2048020255 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2069280266 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2075164726 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2075388586 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2088395296 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2091192361 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2104759740 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2111064727 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2132039247 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2140103666 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2156709416 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2159751120 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2171706715 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2175723801 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2179684740 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2180043963 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W2753514269 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W3088713371 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W3204932990 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W624555320 @default.
- W1539107242 cites W646429109 @default.
- W1539107242 hasPublicationYear "2008" @default.
- W1539107242 type Work @default.
- W1539107242 sameAs 1539107242 @default.
- W1539107242 citedByCount "3" @default.
- W1539107242 countsByYear W15391072422012 @default.
- W1539107242 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1539107242 hasAuthorship W1539107242A5068473895 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C113416529 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C118518473 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C135895429 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C152613627 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C156005406 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C175605778 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C202041845 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C205649164 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C24061886 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C2993248064 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C505870484 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C514101110 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C58479451 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C66204764 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C113416529 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C118518473 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C135895429 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C144133560 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C152613627 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C156005406 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C162324750 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C166957645 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C175605778 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C18903297 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C202041845 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C205649164 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C24061886 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C2993248064 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C505870484 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C514101110 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C58479451 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C66204764 @default.
- W1539107242 hasConceptScore W1539107242C86803240 @default.
- W1539107242 hasLocation W15391072421 @default.
- W1539107242 hasOpenAccess W1539107242 @default.
- W1539107242 hasPrimaryLocation W15391072421 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W1558311132 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W168258017 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W1872089455 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W1968184156 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W1988402232 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W1998508163 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2045711090 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2107164121 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2157894476 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2209081767 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2242470916 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2258876391 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2564437214 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W2592728153 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W264821732 @default.
- W1539107242 hasRelatedWork W3124766614 @default.