Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1554313275> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1554313275 startingPage "252" @default.
- W1554313275 abstract "In historical context, the worldwide abandonment of capital punishment marks an overwhelming repudiation of the death penalty as an atavistic barbarism.... It is an extreme and mindless act of savagery, practiced on an outcast few (Bowers, Pierce, and McDevitt, 1984: 67). -- NAACP Legal Defense Fund brief in Aikens v. California (1972) IT HAS BEEN NEARLY 30 YEARS SINCE NAACP LEGAL DEFENSE FUND ATTORNEYS argued, in the above brief, before the U.S. Supreme Court that the death penalty is a cruel and unusual punishment. Since that time, the United States [1] has maintained the death penalty, both in law and practice -- alone among Western industrial nations. [2] At the turn of the 21st century, the retention of capital punishment in American criminal justice remains a seeming anachronism in a nation that otherwise prides itself on democratic values and its place among civilized nations. Although others have noted this peculiarity of American criminal justice (Currie, 1985: 41; Kappeler, Blumberg, and Potter, 1996: 290- 291), few have offered explanations (Bowers et al., 1984: 131-167) [3] This essay is an attempt to fill that void, seeking to decipher what is distinctive about American society -- compared to other Western democracies with advanced economies -- and how that distinctiveness is related to crime control and, notably, the conti nued execution of criminal offenders. The Abandonment of Capital Punishment in the West The origin of the movement to abolish the death penalty is generally traced to Cesare Beccaria's writings [4] in the 18th century and to the broader influence of the European Enlightenment (Bowers et al., 1984; Melton, 1995; Bedau, 1997). Beccaria understood the modern arguments against the death penalty, including its ineffectiveness as a deterrent and the possibility of executing innocent persons. In calling for reform of the legal institutions of the old regime, Beccaria advocated a legal system based on principles of equal justice and deterrence, arguing that certainty and swiftness were more important than the severity of the punishment. In an analysis of the evolution of the death penalty and civilization, Reiman (1995: 175) argued that the abolition of the death penalty is part of the civilizing mission of modern states. Drawing upon Durkheim' s laws of penal evolution, he notes this civilizing trend as societies move from less to more advanced types and moderate their criminal punishments accordingly. Abolition is, thus, intertwined with the development of the modern state and the intellectual revolution known as the Enlightenment (Hazard, 1965). Before the American Revolution, all 13 colonies authorized public hanging. The founding of the United States during the Enlightenment did not change the legal status of the death penalty. Although the 8th Amendment proscribes cruel and unusual punishments, the prevailing legal view has been that capital punishment per se was not prohibited by the U.S. Constitution. Indeed, the constitutionality of the death penalty was not seriously challenged until the mid-1960s (Bedau, 1997:4,15). Beginning in the 19th century, public executions were gradually outlawed, initially in the Northeast and later in the South, and replaced by hangings within prison walls (Johnson, 1998). In addition, between 1890 and 1930, most states brought executions under centralized, state authority -- since many jurisdictions had allowed offenders to be executed by local authorities, in the county of offense (Bowers et al., 1984: 14). Moreover, throughout the 20th century, the method of execution changed from hanging, to electrocution and the gas chamber, and finally to lethal injection, the most prevalent method currently in use (Johnson, 1998). In spite of these legislative changes, few states abolished the death penalty -- only five states were abolitionist in 1900 and six in 1950, at mid-century (Bowers et al., 1984: 9). …" @default.
- W1554313275 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1554313275 creator A5055010867 @default.
- W1554313275 date "2000-06-22" @default.
- W1554313275 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W1554313275 title "American Exceptionalism and the Death Penalty" @default.
- W1554313275 cites W116030175 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1490834154 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1501601223 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1506395084 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1527673589 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1538125563 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1592607201 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1598799425 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1846028649 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W1989619168 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2002797359 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2019336747 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2027977521 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2038467956 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2059946352 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2060399289 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2072397956 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2075112129 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2106006362 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2131143319 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2319335958 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2319829420 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2334442161 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2612802267 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2753221422 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2795369121 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W2953199600 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W3125872634 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W331820976 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W367848333 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W437331315 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W569555237 @default.
- W1554313275 cites W592039696 @default.
- W1554313275 hasPublicationYear "2000" @default.
- W1554313275 type Work @default.
- W1554313275 sameAs 1554313275 @default.
- W1554313275 citedByCount "6" @default.
- W1554313275 countsByYear W15543132752014 @default.
- W1554313275 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1554313275 hasAuthorship W1554313275A5055010867 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C102587632 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C108608090 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C122302079 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C204918333 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C2778272461 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C2779321823 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C2779343474 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C2779816988 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C2780656516 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C73484699 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C102587632 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C108608090 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C122302079 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C144024400 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C166957645 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C17744445 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C199539241 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C204918333 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C2778272461 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C2779321823 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C2779343474 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C2779816988 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C2780656516 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C73484699 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C94625758 @default.
- W1554313275 hasConceptScore W1554313275C95457728 @default.
- W1554313275 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W1554313275 hasLocation W15543132751 @default.
- W1554313275 hasOpenAccess W1554313275 @default.
- W1554313275 hasPrimaryLocation W15543132751 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W130044015 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W1482077204 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W1490212339 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W1500187011 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W1825779919 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W191495958 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W1946644184 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W2028630721 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W2053228933 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W2170867713 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W2319335958 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W2327653842 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W277520683 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W2994818502 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W3123502049 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W342410416 @default.
- W1554313275 hasRelatedWork W653503331 @default.