FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W155776977> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W155776977 abstract "In this thesis an attempt is made to strengthen and develop John Milbank’s account of gift and participation, by way of encounters with other thinkers on gift (Jean-Luc Marion, Dietrich von Hildebrand), participation (James K.A. Smith, Thomas Aquinas), and transcendence (Catherine Keller, Mayra Rivera Rivera). The logic of the work is given in two moves made in the course of this dialogue, moves which concern grounds of possibility. First, it is argued that making sense of gift and participation requires a thought of the communicable or “plurally possessed”. In respect to (i) gift, it is proposed that unless something remains really the same in the giver, even as it comes to abide in the recipient, such that it is actively present in both—without such communicative “doubling” of a self-identical principle (“Gift”), there can be no transcendence from one person to another, and therefore no event of gift. In respect to (ii) participation, it is shown that Milbank thinks the creature’s methexis in divine being in terms of processio—the same divine life, originally proper to God, is also given to creatures in some way. Thus it seems that the intelligibility of (Milbank’s) participation also depends on the idea of plural possession—that the latter is to be thought as the condition for both gift and methexis.The second move complements the first; here the possibility of plural possession is itself questioned. A distinction is made between two senses of “proper”, and thus between two ways of being a subject for something—metaphysically and dynamically/expressively. It is argued that the communicable is able to have plural expressive subjects, while remaining the Same (really one in its communicability) inasmuch as it has just one metaphysical subject. So in effect, the thesis suggests that taking account of this “propriological” distinction uniquely enables one to (a) provide the appropriate ontological basis for Milbank’s “asymmetrical reciprocity” in gift-exchange, (b) uncover the specific features of his ontology of participation, and thus (c) better evaluate Milbank’s thought.However, Milbank’s understanding of gift is still developing, and further research is needed on other aspects of his account of being and methexis. Also, more attention needs to be given to what the gratuity of gift might be, and how one might reconcile the (more Aristotelian) claim that creatures have created ontic forms, with the (more Platonic) claim that creatures have their being by bearing divine form as dynamical subjects." @default.
• W155776977 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W155776977 creator A5067026658 @default.
• W155776977 date "2011-11-01" @default.
• W155776977 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
• W155776977 title "Plurally possessed: Gift and participation in the Theo-ontology of John Milbank" @default.
• W155776977 cites W1485184078 @default.
• W155776977 cites W1512699829 @default.
• W155776977 cites W1551023056 @default.
• W155776977 cites W1574634637 @default.
• W155776977 cites W1591548333 @default.
• W155776977 cites W1976838231 @default.
• W155776977 cites W1977029119 @default.
• W155776977 cites W2037258241 @default.
• W155776977 cites W2171336906 @default.
• W155776977 cites W2582380365 @default.
• W155776977 cites W2973276575 @default.
• W155776977 cites W564802968 @default.
• W155776977 cites W575695259 @default.
• W155776977 cites W604036552 @default.
• W155776977 cites W619373495 @default.
• W155776977 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
• W155776977 type Work @default.
• W155776977 sameAs 155776977 @default.
• W155776977 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W155776977 crossrefType "dissertation" @default.
• W155776977 hasAuthorship W155776977A5067026658 @default.
• W155776977 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W155776977 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W155776977 hasConcept C182744844 @default.
• W155776977 hasConcept C2779835924 @default.
• W155776977 hasConcept C2780193096 @default.
• W155776977 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
• W155776977 hasConceptScore W155776977C111472728 @default.
• W155776977 hasConceptScore W155776977C138885662 @default.
• W155776977 hasConceptScore W155776977C182744844 @default.
• W155776977 hasConceptScore W155776977C2779835924 @default.
• W155776977 hasConceptScore W155776977C2780193096 @default.
• W155776977 hasConceptScore W155776977C41895202 @default.
• W155776977 hasLocation W1557769771 @default.
• W155776977 hasOpenAccess W155776977 @default.
• W155776977 hasPrimaryLocation W1557769771 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W151539883 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W1982073947 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W1994539840 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2076463135 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2076697463 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2085983579 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2134987258 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W21717969 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2299543776 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2488543001 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2502694602 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W256158129 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2603196326 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2772284550 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2783686024 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W3084135678 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W3183598263 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W618852230 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W77393569 @default.
• W155776977 hasRelatedWork W2774535124 @default.
• W155776977 isParatext "false" @default.
• W155776977 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W155776977 magId "155776977" @default.
• W155776977 workType "dissertation" @default.