Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1566344994> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1566344994 abstract "Taking as its starting point persistent debates about the appropriate balance between rights and discretion in the design and delivery of welfare policies, this thesis seeks to illuminate the contribution ‘rights-based approaches’ can make in responding to homelessness. It aims to bring conceptual clarity and empirical evidence to bear on the growing European and wider international focus on ‘rights-based approaches to homelessness’. Integrating classic debates in moral philosophy regarding the nature and status of rights with contemporary ideas about rights in social policy, the thesis distinguishes between various understandings of ‘rights’. Whereas deontological perspectives see rights as moral statements about human beings, consequentialist perspectives direct attention to the efficacy of legal or ‘black letter’ rights as a policy tool for achieving better outcomes for those in housing need. Focusing on legal rights to housing for homeless households, the thesis asks whether policy approaches founded on such rights deliver what we expect them to in practice. Specifically, it considers the impact of rights-based compared with non-rights based approaches, across four dimensions: meeting housing needs; juridification; minimising the stigma of homelessness; and empowering homeless households. A qualitative comparative study of homelessness policy in Scotland and Ireland forms the empirical core of the thesis. Scotland has attracted international recognition, having developed a strong legal safety net for homeless households, which in effect gives the vast majority of homeless households an individually enforceable legal right to settled housing. In Ireland, homelessness policy has also become a focal point for reform, but a rights-based approach has been rejected in favour of a ‘social partnership’ model, relying on a ‘problem solving approach’ among key stakeholders to build consensus and ‘ratchet up’ standards. The study involved interviews with key national stakeholders in both jurisdictions, and two local case studies in Edinburgh and Dublin, through which the perspectives and experiences of service providers, key local stakeholders and single homeless men were explored. The findings of the study add empirical weight to the current orthodoxy that rights-based approaches offer progressive solutions to the needs of homeless households. The research points to two key mechanisms through which legal rights help secure positive outcomes for single homeless men. First, legal rights minimise provider discretion, ensuring a focus on meeting the needs of homeless single men and crowing out competing policy objectives. A wider set of goals – including considerations of desert, ‘housing readiness’, social mix and community reactions – influence service provision in Dublin. This led to inertia in the Irish system, stemming flow through temporary accommodation. The comparative success of the Scottish approach in meeting the needs of homeless people, however, has implications for the capacity of other (non-homeless) groups in housing need to access social housing. It is argued, based on the empirical findings of the research, and within a normative framework of value pluralism and ‘tragic-realism’, that the Scottish approach strikes a ‘less worse’ balance between competing objectives than Ireland’s social partnership approach. Support for the Scottish model remains closely tied, however, to the capacity of the statutory system to not entirely crowd out the needs of other non-homeless households. Scotland’s approach remains vulnerable to the criticism that it sharpens perverse incentives for people to manufacture homelessness in order to gain priority in the allocation of social housing. Such a perverse incentive is, however, inherent to any approach to homelessness that prioritises homeless people in social housing allocations, and is present - albeit substantially dulled - in Ireland. This ‘moral hazard’ then, needs to be understood in the context of the choice stakeholders face between homelessness policies that prioritise need and create moral hazard, and approaches that do neither. Legal rights-based approaches also help secure better outcomes for homeless men through a second mechanism, namely their psycho-social impacts and their effect on discourses on homelessness. The framework of legal rights in Scotland helps construct those who are homeless as ‘entitled rights-holders’, supporting structural understandings of the causes of homelessness. In Ireland, homeless men were instead cast as ‘grateful supplicants’ and explanations of homelessness tended to emphasize personal responsibility and individual pathology. On this basis, it is argued that legal rights both minimise stigma and ‘empower’ homeless people, encouraging a more demanding and assertive set of attitudes, dispositions and expectations among homeless men that help maintain standards of service. According to this analysis, the capacity of legal rights to secure better outcomes does not rely primarily on the pursuit of legal challenges, but on the more subtle impacts of a rights-based policy framework. Integrating the key normative and empirical findings of the research, the thesis concludes by making three substantive ethical arguments concerning the design of homelessness policy. First, it is argued that in the case of homelessness, legitimate considerations about desert and deservingness in the allocation of social resources ought to be suspended. This argument rests on the empirical insight that Ireland’s ‘desert-sensitive’ approach appears to foster a set of dispositions among homeless men that stifle their progress out of homelessness, and on a normative perspective that seeks to suspend desert in the allocation of social goods that are deemed to be necessities for a ‘well-lived life’. Second, and by extension, it is argued that discretion in the delivery of homelessness policies ought to be minimised. In Ireland, providers’ over-riding discretion - and resulting attempt to balance various objectives, including ‘desert-sensitivity’ - places substantial hurdles in the path of homeless men seeking to access settled housing. The boundaries legal rights cast around provider discretion ‘empower’ homeless men in their interactions with providers, helping maintain a more purely needs-focused response to homelessness. Third and finally, it is argued that homelessness policies that bolster a sense of entitlement among those who are homeless – and recognition among others that this sense of entitlement is legitimate - are desirable. Such a sense of entitlement appears to form part of a wider ‘virtuous circle’ achieved by Scotland’s rights-based approach, which helps maintain pressure for – and achieve - positive outcomes for homeless men." @default.
- W1566344994 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1566344994 creator A5083946773 @default.
- W1566344994 date "2013-03-28" @default.
- W1566344994 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W1566344994 title "The Impact of Legal Rights to Housing for Homeless People: A Normative Comparison of Scotland and Ireland" @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1486462414 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1523864473 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1531064885 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1536810218 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W154564913 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1554579587 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W155615699 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1556808111 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1565693361 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1586535603 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1592020417 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1592318557 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1597750586 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1673770112 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1741321747 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1828392703 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1840385485 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1961990590 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1965249785 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1970106651 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1970217760 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1977507107 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1979614818 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1979767538 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1981834403 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1982485011 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1983336714 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1983818965 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1988557981 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1989385349 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1991000718 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1993371684 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1994073105 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1994412010 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1997318620 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1997621231 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W1997969396 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2000898370 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W200337669 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2005334194 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2008399078 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2015024431 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2015098902 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2015688983 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2016025722 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2021074471 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2022573376 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2022768097 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2023172581 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2030382401 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2030924037 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2031271916 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2031453187 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2031581352 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2031843840 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2033734286 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2035964187 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2036066218 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2038515224 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2040358417 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2042670995 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2047468743 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2057586220 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2059035303 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2061442940 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2064475555 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2066771054 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2072185872 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2076167041 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2079016399 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2081220435 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2085568817 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2089339136 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2090437523 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2090720795 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2091171666 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2092776538 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2093540619 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2094458401 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2097894223 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2098805080 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2102114528 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2103713658 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2103986755 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2108679103 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2109343913 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2109763359 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2110710470 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2110934020 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2110965954 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2111020675 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2116130101 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2122165510 @default.
- W1566344994 cites W2122922084 @default.