Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1579492775> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 69 of
69
with 100 items per page.
- W1579492775 abstract "The reference to foreign court judgments by the US Supreme Courts - particularly in cases involving the US Constitution - has sparked controversy. This controversy flared in Lawrence v. Texas, where Justice Scalia criticized Justice Kennedy for reference to judgments by the European Court of Human Rights in Justice Kennedy's majority opinion striking down the Texas sodomy statute. This article examines the issue from a different perspective: references to 'foreign' court judgments (including US Supreme Court opinions) by the Supreme Court of Ireland. The article examines the Irish Supreme Court's use of judgments from the European Court of Justice, the European Court of Human Rights and the US Supreme Court. The article argues that the Irish Supreme Court's attitude to reference to 'foreign' court judgments depends upon whether the Irish Court occupies a vertical or horizontal position with respect to the other court. Where the Irish Court's relationship is horizontal (meaning in essence that the other court cannot overrule or directly criticize the Irish Court), the Irish Court is less reluctant to refer to the foreign judgment. When the relationship is vertical (in the sense that the other court can criticize or overrule the Irish court), the Irish Court is more reluctant to refer to the foreign judgment. The article examines a number of Irish cases in support of this thesis. It concludes that because the relationship with the European Court of Human rights is vertical, the Irish Court is reluctant to refer to these cases in the Irish Court's opinion. On the other hand, because the relationship with the US Supreme Court is horizontal, the Irish Court shows less reluctance in citing US Supreme Court opinions." @default.
- W1579492775 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1579492775 creator A5040817529 @default.
- W1579492775 date "2004-01-01" @default.
- W1579492775 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W1579492775 title "The Search for Coherence in the Use of Foreign Court Judgements by the Supreme Court of Ireland" @default.
- W1579492775 hasPublicationYear "2004" @default.
- W1579492775 type Work @default.
- W1579492775 sameAs 1579492775 @default.
- W1579492775 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W1579492775 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
- W1579492775 hasAuthorship W1579492775A5040817529 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C103106408 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C110346835 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C136576888 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C2778272461 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C2780623531 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C46415393 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C47855350 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C50688660 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C61192294 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C66487177 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConcept C87501996 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C103106408 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C110346835 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C136576888 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C138885662 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C17744445 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C199539241 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C2778272461 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C2780623531 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C41895202 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C46415393 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C47855350 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C50688660 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C61192294 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C66487177 @default.
- W1579492775 hasConceptScore W1579492775C87501996 @default.
- W1579492775 hasLocation W15794927751 @default.
- W1579492775 hasOpenAccess W1579492775 @default.
- W1579492775 hasPrimaryLocation W15794927751 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W1516613341 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W208829756 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2477404067 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2480954296 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2523209500 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W256729096 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2772200179 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2785265448 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2903883208 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2920155932 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W2969481812 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W3090248872 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W3122336401 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W3122979037 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W3124707819 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W3183250550 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W3183924683 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W3188631466 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W580120730 @default.
- W1579492775 hasRelatedWork W900434702 @default.
- W1579492775 isParatext "false" @default.
- W1579492775 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W1579492775 magId "1579492775" @default.
- W1579492775 workType "article" @default.