Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1586168741> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1586168741 abstract "The rule used by the United States Figure Skating Association and the International Skating Union, hereafter the ISU Rule, to aggregate individual rankings of the skaters by the judges into a final ranking, is an interesting example of a social welfare function. This rule is examined thoroughly in this paper from the perspective of the modern theory of social choice. The ISU Rule is based on four different criteria, the first being median ranks of the skaters. Although the median rank criterion is a majority principle, it is completely at odd with another majority principle introduced in this paper and called the Extended Condorcet Criterion. It may be translated as follows: If a competitor is ranked consistently ahead of another competitor by an absolute majority of judges, he should be ahead in the final ranking. Consistency here refers to the absence of a cycle in the majority relation involving these two skaters. There are actually many cycles in the data of four Olympic Games that were examined. The Kemeny rule may be used to break these cycles. This is not only consistent with the Extended Condorcet Criterion but the latter also proves useful in finding Kemeny orders over large sets of alternatives, by allowing decomposition of these orders. The ISU, the Kemeny, the Borda rankings and the ranking according to the raw marks are then compared on 24 olympic competitions. The four rankings disagree in many instances. Finally it is shown that the ISU Rule may be very sensitive to small errors on the part of the judges and that it does not escape the numerous theorems on manipulation. Some considerations are also offered as to whether the ISU Rule is more or less prone to manipulation than others." @default.
- W1586168741 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1586168741 creator A5079721172 @default.
- W1586168741 date "1998-01-01" @default.
- W1586168741 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W1586168741 title "Figure Skating and the Theory of Social Choice" @default.
- W1586168741 cites W1521226446 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W1586124026 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W1966731480 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W1982315324 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2000851114 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2026026998 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2036910311 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2043434012 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2043715088 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2079027140 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2085850898 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2089788538 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2114990184 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2129678216 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2136888943 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2140897975 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2158900439 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2315464424 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2318031348 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2318211085 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2326964644 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W2334474477 @default.
- W1586168741 cites W602980269 @default.
- W1586168741 hasPublicationYear "1998" @default.
- W1586168741 type Work @default.
- W1586168741 sameAs 1586168741 @default.
- W1586168741 citedByCount "7" @default.
- W1586168741 countsByYear W15861687412020 @default.
- W1586168741 countsByYear W15861687412021 @default.
- W1586168741 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
- W1586168741 hasAuthorship W1586168741A5079721172 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C114614502 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C118615104 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C124101348 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C14036430 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C140940377 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C144237770 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C153668964 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C164226766 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C189352744 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C189430467 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C25343380 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C2776436953 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C520049643 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C78458016 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C114614502 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C118615104 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C124101348 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C14036430 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C140940377 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C144237770 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C153668964 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C154945302 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C164226766 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C17744445 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C189352744 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C189430467 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C199539241 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C25343380 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C2776436953 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C33923547 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C41008148 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C520049643 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C78458016 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C86803240 @default.
- W1586168741 hasConceptScore W1586168741C94625758 @default.
- W1586168741 hasLocation W15861687411 @default.
- W1586168741 hasOpenAccess W1586168741 @default.
- W1586168741 hasPrimaryLocation W15861687411 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W1484124139 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W1491265116 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W1505589146 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W1602618244 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W1966492795 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W1977274523 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2026944621 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2036910311 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2045770937 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2051834357 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2127882486 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2140897975 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2197861567 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2318031348 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W2908284574 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W3105717255 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W3122549756 @default.
- W1586168741 hasRelatedWork W3124875787 @default.