Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1611769750> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1611769750 endingPage "226" @default.
- W1611769750 startingPage "197" @default.
- W1611769750 abstract "We explore when experimental subjects think aggregation across persons—deciding that some parties should be worse off, so that others might gain more, compared to an alternative option—is permissible through subjects' responses to trolley problem vignettes. Two classic vignettes are: (1) whether to divert a runaway trolley on to a spur track, killing one, to save multiple potential victims on a main track, and (2) whether to push an overweight person off a bridge to block the trolley from hitting the potential victims. Subjects typically judge diverting in the first problem permissible and pushing in the second problem impermissible. We first show that respondents reject T aurek's claim that the number of victims is irrelevant. Our central novel finding is that the intuition to distinguish the two cases is weaker than the extensive literature emphasizing its significance has implied. Responses to the two problems often converge to a significant extent on the position that aggregation is impermissible because the intuition to divert is both more weakly held and more subject to revision than the intuition against pushing. We show this convergence when the problems are presented together. Moreover, while the strictures against pushing are typically seen as mandatory (and hold even when following the strictures disadvantages kin or more identified parties), the obligation to divert is rarely unqualifiedly mandatory, and even its permissibility is sensitive to potential harm to kin and identifiable people." @default.
- W1611769750 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1611769750 creator A5080726516 @default.
- W1611769750 creator A5085224552 @default.
- W1611769750 date "2014-04-11" @default.
- W1611769750 modified "2023-10-03" @default.
- W1611769750 title "Playing with Trolleys: Intuitions About the Permissibility of Aggregation" @default.
- W1611769750 cites W1551985987 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W1576321316 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W1974278423 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W1975380744 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W1987570108 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W1989745653 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W1992213805 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2014297083 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2015963122 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2018735707 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2029028464 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2035641532 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2036379509 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2043015160 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2047188722 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2082974516 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2089012547 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2091910054 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2096877169 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2119659537 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2127699214 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2129064092 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2129900561 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2133707153 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2137038272 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2141233322 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2142827688 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2148456701 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2168401869 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2299514449 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2331183040 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2410974606 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2797387575 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W2797784986 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W3121133311 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W3121188848 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W3122562872 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W3123575175 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W3123961515 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W3125217621 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W3125674225 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W4237095875 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W4243419638 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W4248501412 @default.
- W1611769750 cites W4253452862 @default.
- W1611769750 doi "https://doi.org/10.1111/jels.12039" @default.
- W1611769750 hasPublicationYear "2014" @default.
- W1611769750 type Work @default.
- W1611769750 sameAs 1611769750 @default.
- W1611769750 citedByCount "6" @default.
- W1611769750 countsByYear W16117697502014 @default.
- W1611769750 countsByYear W16117697502016 @default.
- W1611769750 countsByYear W16117697502017 @default.
- W1611769750 countsByYear W16117697502018 @default.
- W1611769750 countsByYear W16117697502021 @default.
- W1611769750 countsByYear W16117697502022 @default.
- W1611769750 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1611769750 hasAuthorship W1611769750A5080726516 @default.
- W1611769750 hasAuthorship W1611769750A5085224552 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C132010649 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C188147891 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C190253527 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C2777363581 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C2778447849 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C132010649 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C15744967 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C162324750 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C17744445 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C188147891 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C190253527 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C199539241 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C2777363581 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C2778447849 @default.
- W1611769750 hasConceptScore W1611769750C77805123 @default.
- W1611769750 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W1611769750 hasLocation W16117697501 @default.
- W1611769750 hasOpenAccess W1611769750 @default.
- W1611769750 hasPrimaryLocation W16117697501 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W1966203372 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W1973423536 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W2019984933 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W2030292294 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W2117012792 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W2505458207 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W1611769750 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.