Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1653771092> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1653771092 abstract "Background Low‐back pain (LBP) is a common condition seen in primary care. A principal aim during a clinical examination is to identify patients with a higher likelihood of underlying serious pathology, such as vertebral fracture, who may require additional investigation and specific treatment. All 'evidence‐based' clinical practice guidelines recommend the use of red flags to screen for serious causes of back pain. However, it remains unclear if the diagnostic accuracy of red flags is sufficient to support this recommendation. Objectives To assess the diagnostic accuracy of red flags obtained in a clinical history or physical examination to screen for vertebral fracture in patients presenting with LBP. Search methods Electronic databases were searched for primary studies between the earliest date and 7 March 2012. Forward and backward citation searching of eligible studies was also conducted. Selection criteria Studies were considered if they compared the results of any aspect of the history or test conducted in the physical examination of patients presenting for LBP or examination of the lumbar spine, with a reference standard (diagnostic imaging). The selection criteria were independently applied by two review authors. Data collection and analysis Three review authors independently conducted 'Risk of bias' assessment and data extraction. Risk of bias was assessed using the 11‐item QUADAS tool. Characteristics of studies, patients, index tests and reference standards were extracted. Where available, raw data were used to calculate sensitivity and specificity with 95% confidence intervals (CI). Due to the heterogeneity of studies and tests, statistical pooling was not appropriate and the analysis for the review was descriptive only. Likelihood ratios for each test were calculated and used as an indication of clinical usefulness. Main results Eight studies set in primary (four), secondary (one) and tertiary care (accident and emergency = three) were included in the review. Overall, the risk of bias of studies was moderate with high risk of selection and verification bias the predominant flaws. Reporting of index and reference tests was poor. The prevalence of vertebral fracture in accident and emergency settings ranged from 6.5% to 11% and in primary care from 0.7% to 4.5%. There were 29 groups of index tests investigated however, only two featured in more than two studies. Descriptive analyses revealed that three red flags in primary care were potentially useful with meaningful positive likelihood ratios (LR+) but mostly imprecise estimates (significant trauma, older age, corticosteroid use; LR+ point estimate ranging 3.42 to 12.85, 3.69 to 9.39, 3.97 to 48.50 respectively). One red flag in tertiary care appeared informative (contusion/abrasion; LR+ 31.09, 95% CI 18.25 to 52.96). The results of combined tests appeared more informative than individual red flags with LR+ estimates generally greater in magnitude and precision. Authors' conclusions The available evidence does not support the use of many red flags to specifically screen for vertebral fracture in patients presenting for LBP. Based on evidence from single studies, few individual red flags appear informative as most have poor diagnostic accuracy as indicated by imprecise estimates of likelihood ratios. When combinations of red flags were used the performance appeared to improve. From the limited evidence, the findings give rise to a weak recommendation that a combination of a small subset of red flags may be useful to screen for vertebral fracture. It should also be noted that many red flags have high false positive rates; and if acted upon uncritically there would be consequences for the cost of management and outcomes of patients with LBP. Further research should focus on appropriate sets of red flags and adequate reporting of both index and reference tests." @default.
- W1653771092 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1653771092 creator A5007827945 @default.
- W1653771092 creator A5012328768 @default.
- W1653771092 creator A5018135109 @default.
- W1653771092 creator A5033321113 @default.
- W1653771092 creator A5074865575 @default.
- W1653771092 creator A5081567183 @default.
- W1653771092 creator A5090490801 @default.
- W1653771092 date "2013-01-31" @default.
- W1653771092 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
- W1653771092 title "Red flags to screen for vertebral fracture in patients presenting with low-back pain" @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1447782668 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1967164400 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1969986095 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1971348077 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1979848519 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1979909592 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1984827188 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1985726213 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1987997525 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1989679355 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W1990256078 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2017306616 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2017320295 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2019129605 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2021722916 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2039456166 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2041155522 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2047822344 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2054434947 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2075275980 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2076757054 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2079725375 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2081084254 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2081233233 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2085295169 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2086087894 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2092659696 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2093218964 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2096440032 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2097525623 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2102684949 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2106975935 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2110132004 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2110396808 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2116760759 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2124239698 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2130890130 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2132063285 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2145117623 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2147493587 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2149887909 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2151209660 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2151414671 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2166240555 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2169048239 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2281216748 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W2783587409 @default.
- W1653771092 cites W4235118694 @default.
- W1653771092 doi "https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.cd008643.pub2" @default.
- W1653771092 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23440831" @default.
- W1653771092 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
- W1653771092 type Work @default.
- W1653771092 sameAs 1653771092 @default.
- W1653771092 citedByCount "61" @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922013 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922014 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922015 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922016 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922017 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922018 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922019 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922020 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922021 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922022 @default.
- W1653771092 countsByYear W16537710922023 @default.
- W1653771092 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1653771092 hasAuthorship W1653771092A5007827945 @default.
- W1653771092 hasAuthorship W1653771092A5012328768 @default.
- W1653771092 hasAuthorship W1653771092A5018135109 @default.
- W1653771092 hasAuthorship W1653771092A5033321113 @default.
- W1653771092 hasAuthorship W1653771092A5074865575 @default.
- W1653771092 hasAuthorship W1653771092A5081567183 @default.
- W1653771092 hasAuthorship W1653771092A5090490801 @default.
- W1653771092 hasBestOaLocation W16537710922 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C126838900 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C142724271 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C1862650 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C204787440 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C2776501849 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C2777466982 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C2779473830 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C2780907711 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C44249647 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C527108885 @default.
- W1653771092 hasConcept C71924100 @default.