Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1755596960> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1755596960 endingPage "492" @default.
- W1755596960 startingPage "471" @default.
- W1755596960 abstract "Scholarship and the Modernist Public: Zora Neale Hurston and the Limitations of Art and Disciplinary Anthropology Daniel Harney (bio) In perhaps the most famous scene in Zora Neale Hurston’s ethnography Mules and Men (1935), the character “Zora” stops conducting her research and flees a Florida sawmill camp when a violent fight breaks out in a bar whose clientele is an unsavory mix of outlaws and prostitutes. Zora is forced to abandon her detached participant-observer stance when Lucy, a local woman, suddenly attacks her with a knife, thinking she is attempting to steal her man; another woman named Big Sweet intercedes at the last moment, allowing her to escape. The scene makes palpable the scholar’s vulnerability and confusion, as she finds herself unable to make sense of, or remain apart from, the cultural practices in the field: “Curses, oaths, cries and the whole place was in motion. Blood was on the floor. I fell out of the door over a man lying on the steps, who either fell himself trying to run or got knocked down. I don’t know. I was in the car in a second and in high just too quick.”1 Although this moment of epistemological breakdown is circumscribed by Hurston’s own authoritative voice, which, in turn, is framed by a foreword written by the father of professional cultural anthropology in America, Franz Boas, it raises important questions about the limits of professional inquiry and the relationship between professionals and the public.2 In a letter to Boas, who had still to decide whether he would add his imprimatur to Mules and Men, Hurston blamed its unscholarly and unorthodox literary scenes on her publisher Bertram Lippincott, who was, she explained, insisting she deliver “a very readable book that the average reader can understand.”3 [End Page 471] Although this was true, it also conveniently aligned with her own project that sought to put scholars and the general public into conversation with one another and to critique the growing specialization of scholarship that she believed resulted in work that was dismissive of folk knowledge. In Hurston’s second ethnography, Tell My Horse: Voodoo and Life in Haiti and Jamaica (1938), the sense of chaos and uncertainty so carefully contained by authoritative judgment in Mules and Men subsumes all claims of professional knowledge. Hurston researched the book during 1936 and 1937 while in Jamaica and Haiti on a Guggenheim Fellowship that allowed her to complete fieldwork disrupted several years earlier when the Rosenwald Foundation rescinded its offer to fund her doctoral studies in anthropology at Columbia University. Although now free to explore her literary interests without the constraints of disciplinary anthropology, ethnography and literature would be forever intertwined in her mind.4 From her earliest encounters with scientific methodologies at Columbia as an undergraduate, she had ambitions to incorporate literary techniques into her anthropological scholarship so that she could reach a popular audience. Thus she explained on her Guggenheim application that she hoped “to collect for scientific scrutiny all phases of Negro folk-life and to personally produce or create fiction . . . that shall give a true picture of Negro life . . . at the same time that it entertains.”5 Although Tell My Horse was hardly the success that she had hoped it to be, it succeeds, like Mules and Men, in modeling a self-reflexivity with respect to ethnography that considers the ethics of professional knowledge gathering and suggests that a broader public must participate in knowledge production.6 At its best, Tell My Horse argues that we misunderstand professional power if we focus our gaze solely on first-world professionals from elite institutions like Columbia. The text grants professional power to both marginalized nations and the marginalized sex by ethically representing organic intellectuals who are specialists in their own right. Hurston’s representations of professionals are ethical inasmuch as they are partial; that is, she respects the complexity of professional knowledge within the Jamaican and Haitian folk communities she visits by acknowledging that they cannot be explained exhaustively in her text. Given two weeks to study with the female “specialists who prepare young girls for love,” for instance, she tells us she would “learn what..." @default.
- W1755596960 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1755596960 creator A5025488857 @default.
- W1755596960 date "2015-01-01" @default.
- W1755596960 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W1755596960 title "Scholarship and the Modernist Public: Zora Neale Hurston and the Limitations of Art and Disciplinary Anthropology" @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1494401352 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1557389294 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1566650660 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1577535350 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1583270692 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1834796585 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1965115443 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1965626403 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1966952579 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1993418579 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W1996359216 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2004035287 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2012075551 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2019429426 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2028170938 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2070197418 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W20721869 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2081963145 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2152534083 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2267790969 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2277969036 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2315029654 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2334855818 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2491149969 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2505731210 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2799106557 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2801708344 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W2999345215 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W3033078819 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W360101648 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W384337664 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W564267753 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W570647661 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W579578670 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W580324174 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W592152542 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W593195900 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W605735140 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W622303716 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W630154495 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W631639557 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W642415010 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W643920521 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W648514538 @default.
- W1755596960 cites W99386919 @default.
- W1755596960 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/mod.2015.0055" @default.
- W1755596960 hasPublicationYear "2015" @default.
- W1755596960 type Work @default.
- W1755596960 sameAs 1755596960 @default.
- W1755596960 citedByCount "2" @default.
- W1755596960 countsByYear W17555969602016 @default.
- W1755596960 countsByYear W17555969602019 @default.
- W1755596960 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1755596960 hasAuthorship W1755596960A5025488857 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C109167261 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C151730666 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C179454799 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C19165224 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C2778061430 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C36289849 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C8795937 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C107038049 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C109167261 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C124952713 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C142362112 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C144024400 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C151730666 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C17744445 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C179454799 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C19165224 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C199539241 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C2778061430 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C36289849 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C86803240 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C8795937 @default.
- W1755596960 hasConceptScore W1755596960C95457728 @default.
- W1755596960 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W1755596960 hasLocation W17555969601 @default.
- W1755596960 hasOpenAccess W1755596960 @default.
- W1755596960 hasPrimaryLocation W17555969601 @default.
- W1755596960 hasRelatedWork W1948017202 @default.
- W1755596960 hasRelatedWork W1975204426 @default.
- W1755596960 hasRelatedWork W2162452319 @default.
- W1755596960 hasRelatedWork W2171036068 @default.