FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1841885757> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1841885757 endingPage "287" @default.
• W1841885757 startingPage "268" @default.
• W1841885757 abstract "Sometimes, kinds of cases which do in fact fall under the antecedent of a conditional norm are reckoned recalcitrant. I.e., although they fall under the antecedent of the norm we do not wish to allow the consequence to follow. In such cases, we sometimes say that we are abandoning, or discarding, the norm. We concede, that is, that the alleged norm was wrong (or, if you wish, that it was no norm at all). At other times, however, it is claimed that the norm is a defeasible one. Granted, the case at hand is one of those in which the norm is defeated; but this, it is implied, does not amount to a wholesale abandonment of the norm itself. Being defeasible, the norm somehow survives the impact of such recalcitrant cases. Though somehow revised, amended, qualified, the norm, it is assumed, remains in place: it is still the same norm.I call this ‘the identity assumption’. The identity assumption is, I submit, part and parcel of the notion that some norms are defeasible ones. In this paper, I challenge the identity assumption. I challenge it by reviewing, and rejecting, one of the main ways in which it can be substantiated, namely, a specificationist strategy for dealing with norm conflicts and inappropriate normative verdicts (sections 2 and 3). This leads me to taking a stand in the generalism vs. particularism debate (section 4). Rejection of the identity assumption leads, when conjoined to an awareness of the phenomena underlying defeasibility claims, to a version of particularism. Does this particularist stance necessarily involve the rejection of any normative generalization? The answer to this question, I argue, turns on whether some sense can be made of the notion of a kind of case being ‘normal’ (section 6). Here, a second version of the identity assumption may perhaps be endorsed, thus reviving the defeasibilist project. At the heart of defeasibility claims, so understood, is the idea that norms may be shot through with true, as opposed to merely prima facie, exceptions (section 5)." @default.
• W1841885757 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1841885757 creator A5031764910 @default.
• W1841885757 date "2012-09-06" @default.
• W1841885757 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
• W1841885757 title "True Exceptions: Defeasibility and Particularism*" @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1486129916 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1507803172 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1512021950 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1514637386 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1522408599 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1536601494 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1567642824 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1575146746 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W184031709 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W18560141 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W1997926766 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2021042840 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2035902442 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2036215671 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2037206657 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2038705124 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2044675382 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2045434720 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W204633308 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2083190868 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2105271676 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2122165510 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2132604535 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2136968220 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2152527718 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2167644634 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2263934847 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2316944106 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2556643168 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2739097447 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2907682242 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W3020870639 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W3149301325 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W3877328 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W75570685 @default.
• W1841885757 cites W2425396554 @default.
• W1841885757 doi "https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199661640.003.0017" @default.
• W1841885757 hasPublicationYear "2012" @default.
• W1841885757 type Work @default.
• W1841885757 sameAs 1841885757 @default.
• W1841885757 citedByCount "7" @default.
• W1841885757 countsByYear W18418857572012 @default.
• W1841885757 countsByYear W18418857572013 @default.
• W1841885757 countsByYear W18418857572017 @default.
• W1841885757 countsByYear W18418857572018 @default.
• W1841885757 countsByYear W18418857572020 @default.
• W1841885757 crossrefType "book-chapter" @default.
• W1841885757 hasAuthorship W1841885757A5031764910 @default.
• W1841885757 hasBestOaLocation W18418857572 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConcept C140843580 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConceptScore W1841885757C111472728 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConceptScore W1841885757C138885662 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConceptScore W1841885757C140843580 @default.
• W1841885757 hasConceptScore W1841885757C41008148 @default.
• W1841885757 hasLocation W18418857571 @default.
• W1841885757 hasLocation W18418857572 @default.
• W1841885757 hasOpenAccess W1841885757 @default.
• W1841885757 hasPrimaryLocation W18418857571 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W1507803172 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W2044675382 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W2380969826 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W2481680351 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W2503281669 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W2810795263 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W3121702352 @default.
• W1841885757 hasRelatedWork W41073072 @default.
• W1841885757 isParatext "false" @default.
• W1841885757 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W1841885757 magId "1841885757" @default.
• W1841885757 workType "book-chapter" @default.