FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1893744404> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1893744404 abstract "Adolf Grunbaum and others have criticised Freudian Psychoanalysis (FPA) methodologically, because of the potential inferential liabilities of testing causal psychoanalytic claims in the interview sessions. Also, Grunbaum has prescribed scientific experimentation (especially prospective group-comparison studies) as the best means of overcoming these methodological deficiencies. I argue, firstly, that the opportunities for making reliable inferences (including some causal ones) in psychotherapeutic interviews are better than Grunbaum canvasses, though I do this for a theoretically weaker form of psychodynamic psychology than FPA (i.e. General Psychotherapeutic Counselling, or GPC). Secondly, 1 argue that there are substantial problems with and limitations of experimental methodology, both in itself and when applied to test the specific kinds of hypotheses psychotherapists are interested in. Grunbaum and others fail to draw adequate attention to the generic problems of experimentation. I argue that insofar as the acquisition of psychological knowledge is concerned, it is legitimate to distinguish two broad categories of inductive processes capable of providing it: (i) folk-psychological (or FP-) reasoning; and (ii) experimentation (including epidemiology). (By 'FP-reasoning' I mean the largely inherent capacity that human beings have for making inferences about the psychology of others or themselves, in folk-psychological terms.) I argue that FP-reasoning is in some respects inductively superior to experimentation. If this is correct, there ought to be no automatic methodological priority granted to experimentation in psychology and psychiatry. Various topics related to the above are developed. For example; (i) some problems of the practical application to the psychotherapeutic domain of a principle of causal relevance (provided by Grunbaum) are examined; (ii) a sketch for a model of testing for causal relevance in the special case of insults (provided by Grunbaum) is criticised, and an alternative model is proposed; (iii) some general problems of justifying FP knowledge-claims are discussed, and sceptical attitudes towards the acquisition of folk-psychological knowledge are criticised." @default.
• W1893744404 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1893744404 creator A5043577961 @default.
• W1893744404 date "2001-01-01" @default.
• W1893744404 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
• W1893744404 title "Psychiatry and scientific method : problems of validating causal hypotheses in psychotherapeutic contexts" @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1008373911 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1483319813 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1493816286 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1504825151 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1505197498 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1506651127 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1523619321 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1533044118 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1549884820 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1560174898 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1565693361 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1567127047 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1579308153 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1581321454 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1589804574 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1607940017 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1717383561 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1892182310 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W189521095 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1912442987 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1964633509 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1965596417 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1988211658 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1990778559 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1994163720 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W1996934409 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2016383938 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2018528947 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2031387572 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2047318098 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2048668993 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2050283732 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2056610536 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2064585333 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2071548174 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2079546849 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2094419105 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2112954210 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2117312017 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2126810997 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2148279862 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2160546073 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2164558494 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2166027036 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2168214142 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2317431596 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2320903127 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2322601654 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2331622228 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2343871747 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2606947299 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2936541554 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2988553364 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W2990581795 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W3003649061 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W580305261 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W604980482 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W616483852 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W636227266 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W641931011 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W984773107 @default.
• W1893744404 cites W3150953624 @default.
• W1893744404 hasPublicationYear "2001" @default.
• W1893744404 type Work @default.
• W1893744404 sameAs 1893744404 @default.
• W1893744404 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W1893744404 crossrefType "dissertation" @default.
• W1893744404 hasAuthorship W1893744404A5043577961 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C102655426 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C115086926 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C118552586 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C169900460 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C189946632 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C43450049 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConcept C542102704 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C102655426 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C111472728 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C115086926 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C118552586 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C138885662 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C15744967 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C169900460 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C189946632 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C43450049 @default.
• W1893744404 hasConceptScore W1893744404C542102704 @default.
• W1893744404 hasLocation W18937444041 @default.
• W1893744404 hasOpenAccess W1893744404 @default.
• W1893744404 hasPrimaryLocation W18937444041 @default.
• W1893744404 hasRelatedWork W11074430 @default.
• W1893744404 hasRelatedWork W157667384 @default.
• W1893744404 hasRelatedWork W177721732 @default.

• next