Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1899646852> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1899646852 abstract "The origin of midplate and along-ridge melting anomalies is controversial. Hypotheses involve, at one extreme, concentrated hot mantle upwellings from the deepest mantle and, at the other extreme, shallow processes dominated by stress, plate tectonics, and fertility variations, along with an asthenosphere that is near the melting point. An updated hotspot list is presented and is tested against criteria relevant to both the deep thermal plume and the shallow (plate and asthenosphere) hypotheses. The unique polling approach of Courtillot et al. (2003) is applied to the plume hypothesis and to other hypotheses for melting anomalies. Although some “primary” (i.e., potentially deep-seated) hotspots (Iceland, Hawaii, Easter, Louisville, Afar, Re-union, and Tristan) score well using the chosen subjective plume criteria, they score poorly using criteria more appropriate to deep or thermal processes, such as magma temperature, heatflow, transition zone thickness, and high-resolution upper and lower mantle seismic tomographic results. In particular, Iceland, Easter, Afar, Tristan, and Yellowstone have not been confirmed by tomography. They are shallow features with well-defined plate tectonic explanations. For most melting anomalies (aka “hotspots”) the plume hypothesis scores poorly against competing hypotheses such as stress- and crack-controlled magmatism, mechanisms that are associated with plate tectonics. Based on the results, most “hotspots,” including proposed “primary” or plume-candidate hotspots, are unlikely to be caused by thermal plumes from deep thermal boundary layers. Melting anomalies, on- or off-ridge, appear to be a natural result of nonrigid plate tectonics, including recycling, and do not require an extraordinary explanation, such as narrow thermal instabilities that traverse the whole mantle. Thus plate tectonics, plate boundaries, global plate reorganization, normal magmatism, melting anomalies, volcanic chains, and mantle geochemistry can be unified into a single theory." @default.
- W1899646852 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1899646852 creator A5003095427 @default.
- W1899646852 date "2005-01-01" @default.
- W1899646852 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W1899646852 title "Scoring hotspots: The plume and plate paradigms" @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1480881588 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1524944227 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1548637938 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1552462689 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1563457350 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1568924786 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1575873842 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1964915599 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1971202506 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1975865189 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1980248175 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1981819665 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1982625561 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1984467270 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1990097425 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1990814837 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1991645292 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1999172905 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W1999270464 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2000630889 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2009824639 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2014380629 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2017043022 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2017422309 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2017953040 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2019486498 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2019611709 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2019625789 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2028153073 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2029404697 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2031573403 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2032461248 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2037917325 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2039674576 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2041470320 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2043654698 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2044753344 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2051136609 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2051329252 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2051983576 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2053992979 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2054181393 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2061691991 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2063324859 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2067370445 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2068976119 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2069302116 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2072203934 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2072442304 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2072668389 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2073681127 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2074906534 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2076041878 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2077116181 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2079602762 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2081839958 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2082575448 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2085338101 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2098490586 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2099199436 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2099669585 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2101453781 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2105439983 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2105731467 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2111057804 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2112596485 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2115532364 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2117665200 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2121073368 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2121089807 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2127196660 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2130662508 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2133493439 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2141443242 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2144434123 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2148276392 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2152020851 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2157357027 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2160392018 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2161385196 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2171471492 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2267527292 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2270163170 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2282052957 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W2414297645 @default.
- W1899646852 cites W3048317722 @default.
- W1899646852 doi "https://doi.org/10.1130/0-8137-2388-4.31" @default.
- W1899646852 hasPublicationYear "2005" @default.
- W1899646852 type Work @default.
- W1899646852 sameAs 1899646852 @default.
- W1899646852 citedByCount "45" @default.
- W1899646852 countsByYear W18996468522012 @default.
- W1899646852 countsByYear W18996468522013 @default.
- W1899646852 countsByYear W18996468522014 @default.