Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1924861726> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1924861726 endingPage "389" @default.
- W1924861726 startingPage "380" @default.
- W1924861726 abstract "Although direct replications are ideal for randomized studies, areas of psychological science that lack randomized studies should incorporate Rosenbaum’s (2001) distinction between trivial and nontrivial replications, relabeled herein as exact and critical replications. If exact replications merely repeat systematic biases, they cannot enhance cumulative progress in psychological science. In contrast, critical replications distinguish between competing explanations by using crucial tests to clarify the underlying causal influences. We illustrate this potential with examples from research on corrective actions by professionals (e.g., psychotherapy, Ritalin) and parents (e.g., spanking, homework assistance), where critical replications are needed to overcome the inherent selection bias due to corrective actions being triggered by children’s symptoms. Purported causal effects must first prove to be replicable after plausible confounds such as selection bias are eliminated. Subsequent critical replications can then compare plausible alternative explanations of the average unbiased causal effect and of individual differences in those effects. We conclude that this type of systematic sequencing of critical replications has more potential for making the kinds of discriminations typical of cumulative progress in science than do exact replications alone, especially in areas where randomized studies are unavailable." @default.
- W1924861726 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1924861726 creator A5002957035 @default.
- W1924861726 creator A5025878884 @default.
- W1924861726 creator A5081196925 @default.
- W1924861726 date "2015-05-01" @default.
- W1924861726 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W1924861726 title "Many Replications Do Not Causal Inferences Make" @default.
- W1924861726 cites W1719152548 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W1892145362 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W1966008796 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W1966767842 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W1971682771 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W1976569783 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W1983413501 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2007301387 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2014781793 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2017226203 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2024086275 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2029099852 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2033849203 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2037725716 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2043954475 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2055947283 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2060808946 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2062153802 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2065444835 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2070503314 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2075365528 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2075585362 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2077240377 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2083574489 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2090853328 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2091547221 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2091970336 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2094595478 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2105684750 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2112548797 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2117592572 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2125639870 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2126141278 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2139621222 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2139689782 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2139885671 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2140034517 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2151230224 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2158887664 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2163594521 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2165176433 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2166768042 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2167083402 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2171297120 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2171662137 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2485982367 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2577227262 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W2800705832 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W4244390455 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W4296981344 @default.
- W1924861726 cites W4378077891 @default.
- W1924861726 doi "https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691614567904" @default.
- W1924861726 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25987516" @default.
- W1924861726 hasPublicationYear "2015" @default.
- W1924861726 type Work @default.
- W1924861726 sameAs 1924861726 @default.
- W1924861726 citedByCount "16" @default.
- W1924861726 countsByYear W19248617262015 @default.
- W1924861726 countsByYear W19248617262016 @default.
- W1924861726 countsByYear W19248617262017 @default.
- W1924861726 countsByYear W19248617262018 @default.
- W1924861726 countsByYear W19248617262020 @default.
- W1924861726 countsByYear W19248617262021 @default.
- W1924861726 countsByYear W19248617262023 @default.
- W1924861726 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1924861726 hasAuthorship W1924861726A5002957035 @default.
- W1924861726 hasAuthorship W1924861726A5025878884 @default.
- W1924861726 hasAuthorship W1924861726A5081196925 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C149782125 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C155108698 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C158600405 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C2776502983 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConcept C81917197 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C105795698 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C149782125 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C154945302 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C155108698 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C15744967 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C158600405 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C180747234 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C2776502983 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C33923547 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C41008148 @default.
- W1924861726 hasConceptScore W1924861726C81917197 @default.