Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1963865237> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1963865237 endingPage "844" @default.
- W1963865237 startingPage "828" @default.
- W1963865237 abstract "SummaryThe number of published meta-analyses in plant ecology has increased greatly over the last two decades. Meta-analysis has made a significant contribution to the field, allowing review of evidence for various ecological hypotheses and theories, estimation of effects of major environmental drivers (climate change, habitat fragmentation, invasive species, air pollution), assessment of management and conservation strategies, and comparison of effects across different temporal and spatial scales, taxa and ecosystems, as well as research gap identification.We identified 322 meta-analyses published in the field of plant ecology between 1996 and 2013 in 95 different journals and assessed their methodological and reporting quality according to standard criteria. Despite significant recent developments in the methodology of meta-analysis, the quality of published meta-analyses was uneven and showed little improvement over time.We found many cases of imprecise and inaccurate usage of the term ‘meta-analysis’ in plant ecology, particularly confusion between meta-analysis and vote counting and incorrect application of statistical techniques designed for primary studies to meta-analytical data, without recognition of the violation of statistical assumptions of the analyses.Methodological issues for meta-analyses in plant ecology include incomplete reporting of search strategy used to retrieve primary studies, failure to test for possible publication bias and to conduct sensitivity analysis to test the robustness of the results, as well as lack of availability of the data set used for the analyses.The use of meta-analysis is particularly common in community ecology, ecophysiology and ecosystem ecology, but meta-analyses in ecophysiology are more likely not to meet standard quality criteria than papers in other subdisciplines. Fewer meta-analyses have been conducted in plant population ecology.Synthesis. Over the past two decades, plant ecologists have embraced meta-analysis as a statistical tool to combine results across studies, and much has been learned as a result. However, as the popularity and usage of meta-analysis in the field of plant ecology has grown, establishment of quality standards, as has been done in other disciplines, becomes increasingly important. In order to improve the quality of future meta-analyses in plant ecology, we suggest adoption of a checklist of quality criteria for meta-analysis for use by research synthesists, peer reviewers and journal editors." @default.
- W1963865237 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1963865237 creator A5047783794 @default.
- W1963865237 creator A5076855632 @default.
- W1963865237 date "2014-06-23" @default.
- W1963865237 modified "2023-10-11" @default.
- W1963865237 title "Uses and misuses of meta-analysis in plant ecology" @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1518546884 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1584738294 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1587215677 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1590137713 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1661795662 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1854985852 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1905487223 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1967857296 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1972276215 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1972765990 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1973903335 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1980805132 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1981942195 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1982070737 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1983821394 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1984064633 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1989873521 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1990370234 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W1994164767 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2008585671 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2010017587 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2010838145 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2011992630 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2014247448 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2018740409 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2019272257 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2024359685 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2029832435 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2033045294 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2033585778 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2035925266 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2036311486 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2045807907 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2049772416 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2049774065 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2050512179 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2050729455 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2053997328 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2055389306 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2055738603 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2055757491 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2057636528 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2058738343 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2062305894 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2066451700 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2067820920 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2072813766 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2073274235 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2074388388 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2074584626 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2077310659 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2077879456 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2085407614 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2085574406 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2088172054 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2096295128 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2098841709 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2101224191 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2103733154 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2105584985 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2106255106 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2109423007 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2112125262 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2113079967 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2114594449 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2115900199 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2116964561 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2117091952 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2117112707 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2119912003 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2120457905 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2122258728 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2122304259 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2123200887 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2125929259 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2127477079 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2128149255 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2128154130 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2133293716 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2134692459 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2134882973 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2137021357 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2137186371 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2139168999 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2140328638 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2144509061 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2149087410 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2149427681 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2149597339 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2149991176 @default.
- W1963865237 cites W2154691554 @default.