Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1963948025> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1963948025 endingPage "18" @default.
- W1963948025 startingPage "1" @default.
- W1963948025 abstract "Alexander Monro Primus and the Moral Theatre of Anatomy Anita Guerrini (bio) Public anatomy was an important part of public culture in early modern Europe. Its impact can be seen in terms both of the theatricality of public demonstration and of its moral implications. Early modern anatomists endeavored to entertain, to enlighten, to bedazzle, and to offer moral edification, as well as to educate their audiences about the structure of the human body. In this period, public anatomical demonstration became what I call moral theatre, a demonstration touching on the interconnections between religion, ritual, and secular society. I define moral theatre in the context of anatomy as a public performance intended to induce in its audience such emotions as awe, fear, and compassion—emotions similar to those provoked by religious practices.1 While historians have discussed eighteenth-century natural philosophy lectures in terms of spectacle, particularly citing displays of electricity, the manipulation of life itself was even more dramatic than electrical experiments.2 Live animals were central to the experience of early modern anatomical demonstration. They could demonstrate functions that the human cadaver could not; but in addition, they vested anatomy with broader moral meaning. As with other sorts of natural philosophy, witnessing such events led to a greater appreciation of God's design, and animal experimentation also forced its audience to consider the meaning and purpose of life and death. Since animals acted as stand-ins for humans, the questions of their moral status and their experience of pain were implicit in the act of experimentation. To the multiple meanings of anatomy, animals added several complex and perhaps discomfiting lessons. These meanings, in addition, changed over time, and what was unproblematic to Vesalius in the sixteenth century was not necessarily so to eighteenth-century investigators and witnesses, who operated under different standards of behavior.3 The lectures of Alexander Monro primus (1697–1767), Professor of Anatomy at Edinburgh University in the first half of the eighteenth century, provide one [End Page 1] example of the practice of moral anatomy in this period. In his specific context, Monro employed diverse concepts and practices of his predecessors and contemporaries. These included styles of lecturing, the use of anatomical preparations, the use of spectacle as memento mori, and the changing use of animals. At the same time, the Glasgow philosopher Francis Hutcheson (1694–1746) discussed the question of compassion and proposed that witnessing acts of cruelty gave spectators an opportunity to experience compassion, and therefore that cruelty in certain circumstances was justified. Monro and Hutcheson, I suggest, in keeping with contemporary opinion, which included a growing acknowledgment of the value of sensibility, shared the view that the main purpose of public anatomy was to serve as a virtuous performance. In this essay, I hope to outline an ethnography of Monro's anatomy lectures, a thick description that will define these shared assumptions about public anatomy and its use of animals. This ethnography is necessarily based mainly on texts, rather than on direct observation.4 One assumption had to do with the purpose of anatomy itself. Monro customarily ended his lectures on the history of anatomy with a disquisition on its uses. First on the list was not medicine or surgery, but natural theology. Medicine was fifth on his list, following forensics, natural philosophy, and art.5 This list reveals much about early modern anatomy, which served far broader cultural purposes than simply to teach what the human body looked like. Medical knowledge was only one of many motivations for doing anatomy. In his lectures on the history of anatomy, with which he commenced his course, Monro elaborated: There is no condition of Life, or manner of Study almost but what may at least be improved by the knowledge of the Structure of Animals, and to others of them absolutely necessary in a few. . . . When a serious mind considers the innumerable incredibly fine threads on which the Movements of his whole Bodie depends . . . surely this Reflection must make him acknowledge his own littleness, and adore the unbounded Beneficence of his great Creator and most mercifull Preserver.6 Historians such as Andrea Carlino and Jonathan Sawday have recently looked at the cultural significance of..." @default.
- W1963948025 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1963948025 creator A5028986163 @default.
- W1963948025 date "2006-01-01" @default.
- W1963948025 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W1963948025 title "Alexander Monro Primus and the Moral Theatre of Anatomy" @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1481072000 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1509816133 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1539901237 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1549358115 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1590999749 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1596914413 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1607896740 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1678078719 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1708321837 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1924903918 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1969653296 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1972675438 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1973783449 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1980646184 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1986523341 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W1994253476 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2004588334 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2020498892 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2026730740 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2040429627 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2045773267 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2048433047 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2056478755 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2061026605 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2066388563 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2080096208 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2086848768 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2113472547 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2118882740 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2154257575 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2165331564 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2170773046 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2256840872 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2312942276 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2319275332 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2323471411 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2395806357 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W262025482 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2624326807 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2966123968 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2999306466 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W3160238087 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W564946989 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W573297771 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W579647217 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W586415678 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W617955772 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W627932449 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W649766170 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W655025144 @default.
- W1963948025 cites W2798652200 @default.
- W1963948025 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/ecy.2007.0018" @default.
- W1963948025 hasPublicationYear "2006" @default.
- W1963948025 type Work @default.
- W1963948025 sameAs 1963948025 @default.
- W1963948025 citedByCount "16" @default.
- W1963948025 countsByYear W19639480252012 @default.
- W1963948025 countsByYear W19639480252014 @default.
- W1963948025 countsByYear W19639480252015 @default.
- W1963948025 countsByYear W19639480252016 @default.
- W1963948025 countsByYear W19639480252017 @default.
- W1963948025 countsByYear W19639480252019 @default.
- W1963948025 countsByYear W19639480252021 @default.
- W1963948025 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1963948025 hasAuthorship W1963948025A5028986163 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C2776608160 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C2777432744 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C2779343474 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C2779742141 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C2780876879 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C107038049 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C111472728 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C138885662 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C142362112 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C15744967 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C166957645 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C17744445 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C199539241 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C2776608160 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C2777432744 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C2779343474 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C2779742141 @default.
- W1963948025 hasConceptScore W1963948025C2780876879 @default.