Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1964225174> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1964225174 endingPage "70" @default.
- W1964225174 startingPage "49" @default.
- W1964225174 abstract "Money or Mind? Cecilia, the Novel, and the Real Madness of Selfhood SUSAN C. GREENFIELD Aman, apparently depressed by his economically constrained and repetitive life, compulsively reads romances. He then dons his forefathers' rusty armor, devises a helmet out of cardboard, changes his own name and status (as well as that of his horse), and sets off on an adventure about the problem of material reality. Designated mad because he sees windmills as giants, sheep as soldiers, and prostitutes as ladies, Don Quixote is famous because he fathoms absent bodies in mundane objects—because the presence of romances makes him long for the nonexistent. If, as many have argued, Cervantes's work influenced eighteenth-century English writers and helped inaugurate the modern realist novel, then perhaps this is partly because the narrative exposes the very problem of reality. What is realistic about Don Quixote is the painful inadequacy of a world that cannot begin to accommodate the mind. Psychological survival ironically depends on the mad act of imagining the missing. Frances Burney's Cecilia (1782) makes several references to Don Quixote, and among the knight errant's many descendants, I would count the eponymous heroine who is briefly but decidedly insane toward the novel's end.1 Though Cecilia's madness marks her involuntary reaction to social victimization whereas Quixote thinks it beaut[iful] to go mad 49 50 / GREENFIELD without a cause,2 they share the calamity of absence and the fantasies it provokes. Don Quixote performs feats for his imagined lady Dulcinea, and Cecilia heroically raves to her missing husband: Oh beloved of my heart! ... I will snatch thee from destruction! (899). In both cases, madness signals the mind's detachment from the real world and the centrality of fantasy on the spectrum of thought. This essay considers the historical and psychoanalytic value of understanding the early modern English novel in general, and Frances Burney's Cecilia in particular, in terms of this paradigm. I am interested in how the novel problematizes the relationship between reality and the mind. And I am interested in how what is unreal or immaterial (like Don Quixote's giants or Cecilia's beloved husband) shapes the delusions that define the novel's thinking self. Reality is, of course, notoriously difficult to define. I use it only in the restricted sense as that which actually exist[s] and which is in implicit or explicit contrast with [the] imaginary or fictitious.3 To the countless debates about the novel's formal realism I would add that novels are themselves often concerned with what is not real or not materially certain. Even a text steeped in such physical detail as Robinson Crusoe devotes far more space to Crusoe's fear of the cannibals he does not see for fifteen years than it does to their eventual appearance; the seemingly endless pages of Clarissa consist of letters between distant people about characters who rarely meet and a rape that defies physical description; and Tristram Shandy spends a good third of his autobiography discussing the years before his existence and the birth that nearly killed him. As I will suggest more specifically about Cecilia, in each of these novels, thought exists in tension with material reality and is often enriched by what is missing. At the essay's end, I speculate about how modern theories of psychological subjectivity are premised on a distinction between the mind and reality and on the roles literal loss and existential absence play in selfdevelopment . In The Ego and the Id, for instance, Freud aligns the difference between what is real and what is psychical with that between the external . . . and the internal world.4 Stressing the dominance of fantasy, distorted memories and unrealizable desires, psychoanalysis implies that thought passes in a mind organized around the missing. Even the fetishism of an object marks the displacement or absence of the normal sexual one in Freud's early work and the substitute for the lost maternal phallus (that never really existed) in his essay on the subject.5 My purpose below is to sketch the early modern history of such unreality and the role the novel may have played in defining it as..." @default.
- W1964225174 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1964225174 creator A5079458803 @default.
- W1964225174 date "2004-01-01" @default.
- W1964225174 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W1964225174 title "Money or Mind?: <i>Cecilia</i>, the Novel, and the Real Madness of Selfhood" @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1491072638 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1491422308 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1498805584 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1550992701 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1591422284 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1605034662 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1614549126 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1679875037 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1967131545 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1968775617 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1968886046 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1969865814 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1980611441 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1983588904 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W1993109061 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2013881138 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2018455061 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2022624575 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2024668013 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2027365983 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2032427395 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2033773265 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2036150773 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2040428046 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2044328646 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2048770303 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2071591280 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2076333536 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2079245797 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2080957436 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2081891606 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2082378590 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2093574084 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2097789819 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2137137080 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2226127147 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2333492275 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2483681359 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W2801790053 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W3129068403 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W3134100178 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W3149925164 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W393992831 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W431105417 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W570203254 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W582895561 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W612692798 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W615425969 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W616406456 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W622449947 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W625049066 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W630155524 @default.
- W1964225174 cites W643470502 @default.
- W1964225174 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/sec.2010.0254" @default.
- W1964225174 hasPublicationYear "2004" @default.
- W1964225174 type Work @default.
- W1964225174 sameAs 1964225174 @default.
- W1964225174 citedByCount "5" @default.
- W1964225174 countsByYear W19642251742012 @default.
- W1964225174 countsByYear W19642251742013 @default.
- W1964225174 countsByYear W19642251742014 @default.
- W1964225174 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1964225174 hasAuthorship W1964225174A5079458803 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C11171543 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C1276947 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C199033989 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C2780362631 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C42133412 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C518914266 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C52119013 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C71140485 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C107038049 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C11171543 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C121332964 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C124952713 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C1276947 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C138885662 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C142362112 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C15744967 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C199033989 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C2780362631 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C42133412 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C518914266 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C52119013 @default.
- W1964225174 hasConceptScore W1964225174C71140485 @default.