Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1967379013> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 100 of
100
with 100 items per page.
- W1967379013 endingPage "314" @default.
- W1967379013 startingPage "314" @default.
- W1967379013 abstract "Many journals give authors who submit papers the opportunity to suggest reviewers. Use of these reviewers varies by journal and little is known about the quality of the reviews they produce.To compare author- and editor-suggested reviewers to investigate differences in review quality and recommendations for publication.Observational study of original research papers sent for external review at 10 biomedical journals. Editors were instructed to make decisions about their choice of reviewers in their usual manner. Journal administrators then requested additional reviews from the author's list of suggestions according to a strict protocol.Review quality using the Review Quality Instrument and the proportion of reviewers recommending acceptance (including minor revision), revision, or rejection.There were 788 reviews for 329 manuscripts. Review quality (mean difference in Review Quality Instrument score, -0.05; P = .27) did not differ significantly between author- and editor-suggested reviewers. The author-suggested reviewers were more likely to recommend acceptance (odds ratio, 1.64; 95% confidence interval, 1.02-2.66) or revise (odds ratio, 2.66; 95% confidence interval, 1.43-4.97). This difference was larger in the open reviews of BMJ than among the blinded reviews of other journals for acceptance (P = .02). Where author- and editor-suggested reviewers differed in their recommendations, the final editorial decision to accept or reject a study was evenly balanced (50.9% of decisions consistent with the preferences of the author-suggested reviewers).Author- and editor-suggested reviewers did not differ in the quality of their reviews, but author-suggested reviewers tended to make more favorable recommendations for publication. Editors can be confident that reviewers suggested by authors will complete adequate reviews of manuscripts, but should be cautious about relying on their recommendations for publication." @default.
- W1967379013 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1967379013 creator A5008859012 @default.
- W1967379013 date "2006-01-18" @default.
- W1967379013 modified "2023-10-13" @default.
- W1967379013 title "Differences in Review Quality and Recommendations for Publication Between Peer Reviewers Suggested by Authors or by Editors" @default.
- W1967379013 cites W1803511984 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W1972376036 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2041212401 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2053031440 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2054100472 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2085271766 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2095301612 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2130453155 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2164777277 @default.
- W1967379013 cites W2401303173 @default.
- W1967379013 doi "https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.295.3.314" @default.
- W1967379013 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16418467" @default.
- W1967379013 hasPublicationYear "2006" @default.
- W1967379013 type Work @default.
- W1967379013 sameAs 1967379013 @default.
- W1967379013 citedByCount "128" @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132012 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132013 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132014 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132015 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132016 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132017 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132018 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132019 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132020 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132021 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132022 @default.
- W1967379013 countsByYear W19673790132023 @default.
- W1967379013 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1967379013 hasAuthorship W1967379013A5008859012 @default.
- W1967379013 hasBestOaLocation W19673790131 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C138368954 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C142724271 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C143095724 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C151956035 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C156957248 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C204787440 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C23131810 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C2779455604 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C2779473830 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C2779530757 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C2780385302 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C44249647 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C509550671 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C512399662 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C111472728 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C126322002 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C138368954 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C138885662 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C142724271 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C143095724 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C151956035 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C156957248 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C17744445 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C199539241 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C204787440 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C23131810 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C2779455604 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C2779473830 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C2779530757 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C2780385302 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C44249647 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C509550671 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C512399662 @default.
- W1967379013 hasConceptScore W1967379013C71924100 @default.
- W1967379013 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W1967379013 hasLocation W19673790131 @default.
- W1967379013 hasLocation W19673790132 @default.
- W1967379013 hasLocation W19673790133 @default.
- W1967379013 hasOpenAccess W1967379013 @default.
- W1967379013 hasPrimaryLocation W19673790131 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W2006376692 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W2011313051 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W2037611947 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W2106414694 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W2126610786 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W2142607390 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W2156190299 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W3139085109 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W4294578992 @default.
- W1967379013 hasRelatedWork W4361242331 @default.
- W1967379013 hasVolume "295" @default.
- W1967379013 isParatext "false" @default.
- W1967379013 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W1967379013 magId "1967379013" @default.
- W1967379013 workType "article" @default.