Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1969846686> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1969846686 endingPage "261" @default.
- W1969846686 startingPage "238" @default.
- W1969846686 abstract "Domain Minimization in English Verb-Particle Constructions Barbara Lohse, John A. Hawkins, and Thomas Wasow The placement of the particle before or after an object in the English verb-particle construction is influenced by a variety of factors. We argue that many of them can be subsumed under a single simple principle, motivated by considerations of processing efficiency: to the extent that the domains of syntactic and semantic dependencies can be minimized, processing is facilitated. We use a more precise formulation of this idea to make several predictions about the distribution of particles based on the size of the object NP and the semantic dependencies among the verb, the particle, and the object. Corpus studies confirm the predictions, providing evidence for the principle of domain minimization.* 1. Introduction English verb-particle phrases display a basic syntactic alternation: verb and particle can occur either joined, as in 1a, or split, as in 1b. (1) a. She vp [looked up np [the number]] b. She vp [looked np [the number] up]1 Numerous factors have been proposed to account for the distribution of joined vs. split orders in English performance. Most of these factors fall into one of three groups: syntactic factors like the length of the NP (e.g. Chen 1986, Hawkins 1994), semantic factors like the degree of idiomaticity (e.g. Fraser 1976, Chen 1986), and discourse factors like givenness (e.g. Chen 1986) or focus (e.g. Dehé 2002). These studies often focus on just one factor at the expense of others. If they consider multiple factors, it is unclear how they interact. What is also lacking in this research literature is a satisfactory explanation for the distribution. In his recent corpus study of particle placement, Gries (2003) demonstrated the need for a multifactorial approach. He initially considers all twenty-five factors that have ever been proposed and eliminates those that prove to be statistically insignificant. He then shows how the remaining factors can be subsumed under the processing hypothesis; that is, they all relate to differences in processing cost for different orderings. In order to do this, however, he has to appeal to a variety of theoretical frameworks and to processing principles that range from the proposed processing cost associated with identifying and activating referents in discourse (e.g. Givón 1992, Lambrecht 1994) to that associated with various constituent orders (e.g. Hawkins 1994). We take a different approach here. We integrate several of the factors that have traditionally been proposed to affect ordering preferences into a single and simple principle of processing efficiency and complexity. We argue that the ordering preferences that can be observed for verb-particle phrases in performance data are strongly linked to the overall size of the processing domains for the various syntactic and semantic relations that are involved in these constructions. Applying the theoretical framework [End Page 238] presented in Hawkins 2001, 2003, and 2004, we focus on two types of basic relations: combinatorial and dependency relations. A relation of combination is defined in 2. (2) Combination Two categories A and B are in a relation of combination iff they occur within the same syntactic mother phrase or maximal projection (phrasal combination), or if they occur within the same lexical cooccurrence frame (lexical combination). The phrasal combinations of a language are determined by its phrase-structure rules: a verb combines with a direct object NP within the same VP, the subject combines with the VP within S (or IP), and so on. Subjects, objects, and other complements are also in a relation of lexical combination with the verb and are listed in its lexical entry; adjunct phrases are not so listed. The definition for dependency given in Hawkins 2001, 2003, and 2004 is summarized in 3. (3) Dependency Two categories A and B are in a relation of dependency iff the parsing of B requires access to A for the assignment of syntactic or semantic properties to B with respect to which B is zero-specified or ambiguously or polysemously specified. For example, the subject NP in The key opened the door to the wine cellar is zero-specified with regard to its theta-role and the parser needs to..." @default.
- W1969846686 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1969846686 creator A5025841152 @default.
- W1969846686 creator A5026246654 @default.
- W1969846686 creator A5034028222 @default.
- W1969846686 date "2004-01-01" @default.
- W1969846686 modified "2023-10-11" @default.
- W1969846686 title "Domain Minimization in English Verb-Particle Constructions" @default.
- W1969846686 cites W1208721423 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W1526308488 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W1568769158 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W1601575719 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W1984821970 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W1992671331 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W1998768713 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2009177935 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2020912616 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2033134016 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2038927348 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2045957079 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2062837929 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2075299172 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2084569459 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2089683596 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2094001298 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2101779848 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2117823388 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2149857433 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2169598659 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2170716495 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2494618702 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2780625621 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W2796493717 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W427907761 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W567654451 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W586453726 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W627084713 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W628595516 @default.
- W1969846686 cites W84065352 @default.
- W1969846686 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/lan.2004.0089" @default.
- W1969846686 hasPublicationYear "2004" @default.
- W1969846686 type Work @default.
- W1969846686 sameAs 1969846686 @default.
- W1969846686 citedByCount "120" @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862012 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862013 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862014 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862015 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862016 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862017 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862018 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862019 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862020 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862021 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862022 @default.
- W1969846686 countsByYear W19698466862023 @default.
- W1969846686 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1969846686 hasAuthorship W1969846686A5025841152 @default.
- W1969846686 hasAuthorship W1969846686A5026246654 @default.
- W1969846686 hasAuthorship W1969846686A5034028222 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C120665830 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C134306372 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C136197465 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C192209626 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C198942812 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C204321447 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C26826806 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C2776397901 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C2781238097 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C36503486 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConcept C60048249 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C120665830 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C121332964 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C134306372 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C136197465 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C138885662 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C154945302 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C192209626 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C198942812 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C204321447 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C26826806 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C2776397901 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C2781238097 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C33923547 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C36503486 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C41008148 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C41895202 @default.
- W1969846686 hasConceptScore W1969846686C60048249 @default.
- W1969846686 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W1969846686 hasLocation W19698466861 @default.
- W1969846686 hasOpenAccess W1969846686 @default.
- W1969846686 hasPrimaryLocation W19698466861 @default.