Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1972376036> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 93 of
93
with 100 items per page.
- W1972376036 endingPage "234" @default.
- W1972376036 startingPage "234" @default.
- W1972376036 abstract "Little research has been conducted into the quality of peer review and, in particular, the effects of blinding peer reviewers to authors' identities or masking peer reviewers' identities.To determine whether concealing authors' identities from reviewers (blinding) and/or revealing the reviewer's identity to a coreviewer (unmasking) affects the quality of reviews, the time taken to carry out reviews, and the recommendation regarding publication.Randomized trial of 527 consecutive manuscripts submitted to BMJ, which were randomized and each sent to 2 peer reviewers.Manuscripts were randomized as to whether the reviewers were unmasked, masked, or uninformed that a study was taking place. Two reviewers for each manuscript were randomized to receive either a blinded or an unblinded version.Mean total quality score, time taken to carry out the review, and recommendation regarding publication.Of the 527 manuscripts entered into the study, 467 (89%) were successfully randomized and followed up. The mean total quality score was 2.87. There was little or no difference in review quality between the masked and unmasked groups (scores of 2.82 and 2.96, respectively) and between the blinded and unblinded groups (scores of 2.87 and 2.90, respectively). There was no apparent Hawthorne effect. There was also no significant difference between groups in the recommendations regarding publication or time taken to review.Blinding and unmasking made no editorially significant difference to review quality, reviewers' recommendations, or time taken to review. Other considerations should guide decisions as to the form of peer review adopted by a journal, and improvements in the quality of peer review should be sought via other means." @default.
- W1972376036 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1972376036 creator A5012222147 @default.
- W1972376036 creator A5059869631 @default.
- W1972376036 creator A5060735505 @default.
- W1972376036 creator A5073875655 @default.
- W1972376036 creator A5082129367 @default.
- W1972376036 date "1998-07-15" @default.
- W1972376036 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W1972376036 title "Effect of Blinding and Unmasking on the Quality of Peer Review" @default.
- W1972376036 cites W1969366890 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W1987965558 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W1988185602 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W2033775591 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W2053630409 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W2067691995 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W2080416069 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W2085271766 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W2093790420 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W2130453155 @default.
- W1972376036 cites W3099410479 @default.
- W1972376036 doi "https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.280.3.234" @default.
- W1972376036 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9676666" @default.
- W1972376036 hasPublicationYear "1998" @default.
- W1972376036 type Work @default.
- W1972376036 sameAs 1972376036 @default.
- W1972376036 citedByCount "251" @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362012 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362013 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362014 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362015 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362016 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362017 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362018 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362019 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362020 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362021 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362022 @default.
- W1972376036 countsByYear W19723760362023 @default.
- W1972376036 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1972376036 hasAuthorship W1972376036A5012222147 @default.
- W1972376036 hasAuthorship W1972376036A5059869631 @default.
- W1972376036 hasAuthorship W1972376036A5060735505 @default.
- W1972376036 hasAuthorship W1972376036A5073875655 @default.
- W1972376036 hasAuthorship W1972376036A5082129367 @default.
- W1972376036 hasBestOaLocation W19723760361 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C141071460 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C168563851 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C2771230 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C2778653282 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C2779473830 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C2779530757 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C512399662 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C111472728 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C138885662 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C141071460 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C168563851 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C17744445 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C199539241 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C2771230 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C2778653282 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C2779473830 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C2779530757 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C512399662 @default.
- W1972376036 hasConceptScore W1972376036C71924100 @default.
- W1972376036 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W1972376036 hasLocation W19723760361 @default.
- W1972376036 hasLocation W19723760362 @default.
- W1972376036 hasLocation W19723760363 @default.
- W1972376036 hasOpenAccess W1972376036 @default.
- W1972376036 hasPrimaryLocation W19723760361 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W1967108219 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W1967744186 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W2243333816 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W2243916122 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W2469138222 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W2980378453 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W2997412159 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W3207429845 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W4300765427 @default.
- W1972376036 hasRelatedWork W4377151426 @default.
- W1972376036 hasVolume "280" @default.
- W1972376036 isParatext "false" @default.
- W1972376036 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W1972376036 magId "1972376036" @default.
- W1972376036 workType "article" @default.