Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1973671723> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1973671723 endingPage "409" @default.
- W1973671723 startingPage "397" @default.
- W1973671723 abstract "Abstract. The skill of proxy-based reconstructions of Northern hemisphere temperature is reassessed. Using an almost complete set of proxy and instrumental data of the past 130 years a multi-crossvalidation is conducted of a number of statistical methods, producing a distribution of verification skill scores. Among the methods are multiple regression, multiple inverse regression, total least squares, RegEM, all considered with and without variance matching. For all of them the scores show considerable variation, but previous estimates, such as a 50% reduction of error (RE), appear as outliers and more realistic estimates vary about 25%. It is shown that the overestimation of skill is possible in the presence of strong persistence (trends). In that case, the classical early or late calibration sets are not representative for the intended (instrumental, millennial) domain. As a consequence, RE scores are generally inflated, and the proxy predictions are easily outperformed by stochastic, a priori skill-less predictions. To obtain robust significance levels the multi-crossvalidation is repeated using stochastic predictors. Comparing the score distributions it turns out that the proxies perform significantly better for almost all methods. The scores of the stochastic predictors do not vanish, nonetheless, with an estimated 10% of spurious skill based on representative samples. I argue that this residual score is due to the limited sample size of 130 years, where the memory of the processes degrades the independence of calibration and validation sets. It is likely that proxy prediction scores are similarly inflated and have to be downgraded further, leading to a final overall skill that for the best methods lies around 20%. The consequences of the limited verification skill for millennial reconstructions is briefly discussed." @default.
- W1973671723 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1973671723 creator A5046714317 @default.
- W1973671723 date "2007-07-11" @default.
- W1973671723 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
- W1973671723 title "On the verification of climate reconstructions" @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1582709791 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1660201747 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1905165981 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1973457582 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1973694910 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1976927254 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1978887368 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1979579723 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1981251392 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1987484552 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W1994800218 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2003287879 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2003326514 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2007377949 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2010798320 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2014968686 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2024054778 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2025336675 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2027745714 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2033904036 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2043514774 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2045404766 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2049633694 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2054167751 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2059738590 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2063827883 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2066165799 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2070257026 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2070848742 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2074964089 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2079775628 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2085655266 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2099285484 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2100358124 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2105942117 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2117897510 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2122809335 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2131099349 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2131532072 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2139223514 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2142967805 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2142987884 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2174160981 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2180301600 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2488758846 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W2795891046 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W4243424978 @default.
- W1973671723 cites W4247351157 @default.
- W1973671723 doi "https://doi.org/10.5194/cp-3-397-2007" @default.
- W1973671723 hasPublicationYear "2007" @default.
- W1973671723 type Work @default.
- W1973671723 sameAs 1973671723 @default.
- W1973671723 citedByCount "28" @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232012 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232013 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232014 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232015 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232016 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232017 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232019 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232020 @default.
- W1973671723 countsByYear W19736717232021 @default.
- W1973671723 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1973671723 hasAuthorship W1973671723A5046714317 @default.
- W1973671723 hasBestOaLocation W19736717231 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C11413529 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C149782125 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C155512373 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C165838908 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C2780148112 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C75553542 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C79337645 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C83546350 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConcept C97256817 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C105795698 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C111472728 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C11413529 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C138885662 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C149782125 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C155512373 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C165838908 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C2780148112 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C33923547 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C75553542 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C79337645 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C83546350 @default.
- W1973671723 hasConceptScore W1973671723C97256817 @default.
- W1973671723 hasIssue "3" @default.