Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1974009102> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1974009102 endingPage "111" @default.
- W1974009102 startingPage "84" @default.
- W1974009102 abstract "The objectives of this study are: (a) elaboration of a history and philosophy of science (HPS) framework based on a reconstruction of the development of the periodic table; (b) formulation of seven criteria based on the framework; and (c) evaluation of 57 freshman college-level general chemistry textbooks with respect to the presentation of the periodic table. The historical reconstruction of the periodic table showed that the periodicity of the elements could be construed as an inductive generalization or as a function of the atomic theory. There is considerable controversy with respect to the nature of Mendeleev's contribution, and various alternatives are discussed: ordered domain; empirical law; and a theory with limited explanatory power. Accommodation of the elements according to their physicochemical properties is considered to be the major contribution of the periodic table by all textbooks, followed by contrapredictions of previously unknown elements (30 textbooks), and novel predictions (corrections of atomic mass) of known elements (10 textbooks). The relative importance of accommodation and prediction within an HPS framework is generally ignored. Few textbooks have attempted to explore the possible cause of periodicity in the table and very few textbooks have explored the nature of Mendeleev's contribution. The development of the periodic table as a sequence of heuristic principles in the form of a convincing argument has been ignored. The textbook approach of emphasizing that the development of the periodic table was an inductive generalization, and that Mendeleev had no model or theory, does not facilitate the spirit of critical inquiry that led the scientists to grapple with alternative interpretations, conflicts, and controversies. It is concluded that the development of the periodic table went through a continual critical appraisal (conflict and controversy), in which scientists presented various tentative theoretical ideas to understand the observed phenomena. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 42: 84–111, 2005" @default.
- W1974009102 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1974009102 creator A5010776478 @default.
- W1974009102 creator A5012321205 @default.
- W1974009102 creator A5062868242 @default.
- W1974009102 date "2004-11-30" @default.
- W1974009102 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W1974009102 title "A reconstruction of development of the periodic table based on history and philosophy of science and its implications for general chemistry textbooks" @default.
- W1974009102 cites W130330151 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1674589764 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1944763145 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1969058847 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1982969119 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1990384282 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1990530750 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1991378245 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W1992576274 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2001018921 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2012429170 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2023649078 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2024923261 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2027060190 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2028868063 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2031123844 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2043273443 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2046838237 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2056956555 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2066772879 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2079619515 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2087226813 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2088985136 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2089372224 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2093790580 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2094118543 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2234710693 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2336044779 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W256019955 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W4245353148 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W4250850567 @default.
- W1974009102 cites W2053964490 @default.
- W1974009102 doi "https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.20044" @default.
- W1974009102 hasPublicationYear "2004" @default.
- W1974009102 type Work @default.
- W1974009102 sameAs 1974009102 @default.
- W1974009102 citedByCount "48" @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022012 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022013 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022014 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022015 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022016 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022017 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022018 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022019 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022020 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022021 @default.
- W1974009102 countsByYear W19740091022023 @default.
- W1974009102 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1974009102 hasAuthorship W1974009102A5010776478 @default.
- W1974009102 hasAuthorship W1974009102A5012321205 @default.
- W1974009102 hasAuthorship W1974009102A5062868242 @default.
- W1974009102 hasBestOaLocation W19740091022 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C124101348 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C124149750 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C126838900 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C145420912 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C173801870 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C177148314 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C178790620 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C2777601897 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C2778219744 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C33332235 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C45235069 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConcept C98184364 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C111472728 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C121332964 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C124101348 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C124149750 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C126838900 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C138885662 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C145420912 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C173801870 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C177148314 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C178790620 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C185592680 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C2777601897 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C2778219744 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C33332235 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C33923547 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C41008148 @default.
- W1974009102 hasConceptScore W1974009102C45235069 @default.