FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1975933692> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1975933692 endingPage "266" @default.
• W1975933692 startingPage "231" @default.
• W1975933692 abstract "Large datasets are required to solve difficult phylogenetic problems that are deep in the Tree of Life. Currently, two divergent systematic methods are commonly applied to such datasets: the traditional supermatrix approach (= concatenation) and shortcut coalescence (= coalescence methods wherein gene trees and the species tree are not co-estimated). When applied to ancient clades, these contrasting frameworks often produce congruent results, but in recent phylogenetic analyses of Placentalia (placental mammals), this is not the case. A recent series of papers has alternatively disputed and defended the utility of shortcut coalescence methods at deep phylogenetic scales. Here, we examine this exchange in the context of published phylogenomic data from Mammalia; in particular we explore two critical issues - the delimitation of data partitions (genes) in coalescence analysis and hidden support that emerges with the combination of such partitions in phylogenetic studies. Hidden support - increased support for a clade in combined analysis of all data partitions relative to the support evident in separate analyses of the various data partitions, is a hallmark of the supermatrix approach and a primary rationale for concatenating all characters into a single matrix. In the most extreme cases of hidden support, relationships that are contradicted by all gene trees are supported when all of the genes are analyzed together. A valid fear is that shortcut coalescence methods might bypass or distort character support that is hidden in individual loci because small gene fragments are analyzed in isolation. Given the extensive systematic database for Mammalia, the assumptions and applicability of shortcut coalescence methods can be assessed with rigor to complement a small but growing body of simulation work that has directly compared these methods to concatenation. We document several remarkable cases of hidden support in both supermatrix and coalescence paradigms and argue that in most instances, the emergent support in the shortcut coalescence analyses is an artifact. By referencing rigorous molecular clock studies of Mammalia, we suggest that inaccurate gene trees that imply unrealistically deep coalescences debilitate shortcut coalescence analyses of the placental dataset. We document contradictory coalescence results for Placentalia, and outline a critical conundrum that challenges the general utility of shortcut coalescence methods at deep phylogenetic scales. In particular, the basic unit of analysis in coalescence analysis, the coalescence-gene, is expected to shrink in size as more taxa are analyzed, but as the amount of data for reconstruction of a gene tree ratchets downward, the number of nodes in the gene tree that need to be resolved ratchets upward. Some advocates of shortcut coalescence methods have attempted to address problems with inaccurate gene trees by concatenating multiple coalescence-genes to yield gene trees that better match the species tree. However, this hybrid concatenation/coalescence approach, concatalescence, contradicts the most basic biological rationale for performing a coalescence analysis in the first place. We discuss this reality in the context of recent simulation work that also suggests inaccurate reconstruction of gene trees is more problematic for shortcut coalescence methods than deep coalescence of independently segregating loci is for concatenation methods." @default.
• W1975933692 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1975933692 creator A5068525678 @default.
• W1975933692 creator A5080265470 @default.
• W1975933692 date "2014-11-01" @default.
• W1975933692 modified "2023-10-12" @default.
• W1975933692 title "Phylogenetic analysis at deep timescales: Unreliable gene trees, bypassed hidden support, and the coalescence/concatalescence conundrum" @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1550929454 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1656398202 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W185482193 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1897839277 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1965103508 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1965612692 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1966324007 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1971273325 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1977169047 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1977564243 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1978199447 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1982032672 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1987521743 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1988170736 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1989350663 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1992714434 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1993386195 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W1999559720 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2001418464 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2002778303 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2005152258 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2005238069 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2007270568 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2012220164 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2013162427 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2015288660 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2015710052 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2017051353 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2018217055 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2020339453 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2024439539 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2029352542 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2030962485 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2036507321 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2036812417 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2037654474 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2042696830 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2045024026 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2050495432 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2051705573 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2054652527 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2055298722 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2057328811 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2063345613 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2063733088 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2063916037 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2065871208 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2068102276 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2068936345 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2070046933 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2070740026 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2072802546 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2074077385 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2077474185 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2082519741 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2082703775 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2084761838 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2085597679 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2085686457 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2087912468 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2094561830 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2096403581 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2096641211 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2096689134 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2097273111 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2097412226 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2097588807 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2097647731 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2098255296 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2098747033 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2099459260 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2100983857 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2101135145 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2101629524 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2101671848 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2101732512 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2101797035 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2102424972 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2103752075 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2104742183 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2105541048 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2106704226 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2107508473 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2107608009 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2108087670 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2108116104 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2109258478 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2110074742 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2111211467 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2112947508 @default.
• W1975933692 cites W2114227052 @default.

• next