Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1977133028> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1977133028 abstract "Reviewing dictionaries is part of the ongoing work in lexicography, and several lexicographers have discussed the process and guidelines for reviews published in academic journals. However, few have addressed the evaluation of the outside matter and, if so, only in a cursory way. This article examines the evaluation of the outside matter in reviews published in Lexikos with a view to proposing some general prin-ciples for reviewing outer texts in printed and electronic dictionaries. The study shows that reviewers define the review object differently, some excluding the outside matter altogether, and that the way in which the outside matter is assessed differs within and between reviews. It is proposed that the separate sections of dic-tionaries should not only be examined independently but that their relationship to each other should also be evaluated so as to represent faithfully the lexicographic elements, i.e. wordlist, front, middle and back matter, their organisation and presentation, as well as three underlying elements: the function(s), data types and structures of the dictionary. Focus on all these elements may result in dictionary reviews that are academi-cally sound because they treat the dictionary as a true research object.Keywords: BACK MATTER, DICTIONARY REVIEWS, EXTRA-LEXICOGRAPHIC SEC-TIONS, FRONT MATTER, LEXICOGRAPHIC INFORMATION COSTS, LEXICOGRAPHIC SECTIONS, MIDDLE MATTER, OUTSIDE MATTER, OVERRIDING OBJECTIVE, PREFACES, SCHOLARLY WRITINGS, SUBJECT-FIELD SECTIONS, SUBSTANCE OVER FORM, USER GUIDES, WORDLISTSOpsomming: Die evaluering van die buitewerk in woordeboekresensies. Die resensering van woordeboeke is deel van die deurlopende werk in die leksikografie, en ver-skeie leksikograwe het die metode en riglyne vir resensies wat in akademiese tydskrifte gepubli-seer is, bespreek. Min het egter die evaluering van die buitewerk in resensies aangeroer, en, indien wel, slegs op 'n terloopse manier. Hierdie artikel ondersoek die evaluering van die buitewerk in resensies wat in Lexikos gepubliseer is, met die doel om 'n aantal algemene beginsels voor te stel vir die resensering van buitetekste in gedrukte en elektroniese woordeboeke. Die studie toon dat resensente die resensieobjek verskillend definieer, met sommige wat die buitewerk heeltemal uitsluit, en dat die manier waarop buitewerk beoordeel word, verskil binne en tussen resensies. Daar word voorgestel dat die aparte afdelings van woordeboeke nie alleen onafhanklik ondersoek behoort te word nie, maar dat hulle verhouding tot mekaar ook beoordeel behoort te word om die leksikografiese elemente getrou te verteenwoordig, d.w.s. woordelys, voor-, middel- en agterwerk, hul rangskikking en aanbieding, sowel as drie onderliggende elemente: die funksie(s), datatipes en strukture van die woordeboek. Fokus op al hierdie elemente kan lei tot woordeboekresensies wat akademies grondig is omdat hulle die woordeboek as 'n werklike navorsingsobjek behandel.Sleutelwoorde: AGTERWERK, WOORDEBOEKRESENSIES, BUITELEKSIKOGRAFIESE AFDELINGS, VOORWERK, LEKSIKOGRAFIESE INLIGTINGSKOSTE, LEKSIKOGRAFIESE AFDE-LINGS, MIDDELWERK, BUITEWERK, OORHEERSENDE DOELSTELLING, VOORWOORDE, WETENSKAPLIKE SKRYFWERK, ONDERWERPSVELDAFDELINGS, INHOUD BO VORM, GE-BRUIKERSGIDSE, WOORDELYSTE" @default.
- W1977133028 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1977133028 creator A5057727024 @default.
- W1977133028 date "2011-10-20" @default.
- W1977133028 modified "2023-10-03" @default.
- W1977133028 title "The Evaluation of the Outside Matter in Dictionary Reviews" @default.
- W1977133028 cites W1512686224 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W1963778515 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W1977983478 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W1983506348 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W1990624901 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2000271292 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2018597518 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2019709976 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2024635225 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2025962527 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2039519300 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2064651545 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2072679942 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2093307230 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2093533529 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2133407470 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2234159913 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2266021552 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2267051765 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2278042421 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2283096161 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2284105142 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2483089267 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2565621301 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2566154613 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2594841797 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2740532984 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W27493132 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2754798217 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2755604234 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2767494864 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2803691650 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W2972782849 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W315066992 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W341472101 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W379963220 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W571548458 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W596129315 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W602013316 @default.
- W1977133028 cites W608711127 @default.
- W1977133028 doi "https://doi.org/10.5788/19-0-436" @default.
- W1977133028 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
- W1977133028 type Work @default.
- W1977133028 sameAs 1977133028 @default.
- W1977133028 citedByCount "3" @default.
- W1977133028 countsByYear W19771330282013 @default.
- W1977133028 countsByYear W19771330282014 @default.
- W1977133028 countsByYear W19771330282017 @default.
- W1977133028 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1977133028 hasAuthorship W1977133028A5057727024 @default.
- W1977133028 hasBestOaLocation W19771330281 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C114614502 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C159254197 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C19417346 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C2781238097 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C2992860105 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C47177190 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConcept C80976798 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C114614502 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C138885662 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C144024400 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C154945302 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C159254197 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C19417346 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C2781238097 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C2992860105 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C33923547 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C41008148 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C41895202 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C47177190 @default.
- W1977133028 hasConceptScore W1977133028C80976798 @default.
- W1977133028 hasIssue "0" @default.
- W1977133028 hasLocation W19771330281 @default.
- W1977133028 hasOpenAccess W1977133028 @default.
- W1977133028 hasPrimaryLocation W19771330281 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W122014902 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W1964299012 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W1972410540 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W1972985847 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2000378671 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2101980252 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2133407470 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2147732046 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2160287230 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2167295896 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2260488045 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2263229835 @default.
- W1977133028 hasRelatedWork W2271646144 @default.