FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1978453646> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1978453646 endingPage "538" @default.
• W1978453646 startingPage "533" @default.
• W1978453646 abstract "Reviewed by: Tianchao de bengkui: Yapian zhanzheng zai yanjiu David Cheng Chang (bio) Mao Haijian 茅海建. Tianchao de bengkui: Yapian zhanzheng zai yanjiu 天朝的崩溃: 鸦片战争再研究 (The collapse of the Celestial Empire: A reanalysis of the Opium War). Beijing: Sanlian shudian, 2005. 600 pp. Paperback 32.00 RMB, isbn 7-108-02294-x. Benedetto Croce (1866–1952) famously stated that every true history is contemporary history, suggesting that the representation of history reflects the circumstances and attitudes of historians in their contemporary times.1 Chen Yinke (1890–1969), probably the most revered historian in twentieth-century China, advocated historical writing with well-informed sympathy, that is, a thorough understanding of the historical context.2 These two seemingly contrasting dicta by Croce and Chen encapsulate the dilemma confronting every historian: Can a historical narrative be historical and contemporary at the same time? Mao Haijian's Tianchao de bengkui: Yapian zhanzheng zai yanjiu suggests an affirmative answer. While another leading Chinese historian, Luo Zhitian, sees the inherent conflict between the historical and the contemporary in Mao's book, this reviewer finds that Mao's contemporary concerns do not detract from his historical scholarship.3 In this weighty work of more than 400,000 Chinese characters, empirical contexualization with well-informed sympathy underpins Mao's arguments, which are of both historical and contemporary significance. In unprecedented detail, Mao reconstructs the history of the First Opium War from 1839 to 1843. In his effort to use ideas of their time to explain historical actors' thoughts and actions (pp. 2–3), Mao begins the book by rehabilitating Qishan, who was vilified in both contemporary accounts and nationalist historiography as a treacherous official and traitor. He also debunks the mythology of Lin Zexu as the polar opposite of Qishan, an official of complete probity, competence, and vision. Armed with a large amount of archival and documentary evidence, mostly from the Number One Historical Archives in Beijing, the author demonstrates the speciousness of the simplistic and moralistic model of a two-line struggle between the patriotic line of Lin advocating resistance and the traitorous line of Qishan proposing capitulation (p. 22). Contrary to the traditional view that sees the policy division along the fault line of ethnicity, Mao points out that once the war was under way, in the war zones of Guangdong, Fujian, Zhejiang, and Jiangsu, irrespective of ethnicity, none of the officials with actual responsibility … still advocated 'jiao' (剿, literally meaning suppression, but here denoting uncompromising resistance), a uniformity in striking contrast to the fact none of the officials in nonwar zones suggested 'fu' (抚, appeasement) (p. 424). Mao consistently makes a distinction between two types of judgment, moral and political (i.e., practical), and his [End Page 533] focus is on the latter. Eschewing self-righteous, moral judgment, Mao's well-informed sympathy enables him to appreciate the actual political predicaments historical actors were facing. As a military historian by training, Mao's unrivaled expertise on the military aspect of the war shines throughout the book. In chapter 2, Mao analyzes the substantial gap between Chinese troops and the British, in terms of both technology and organization. Mao observes that the main function of the Qing army was for suppression of domestic unrest, not external warfare (p. 53). In striking resemblance to the Ming military described by Ray Huang, the Qing troop mobilization still relied on a medieval financial system supported by donations (juanshu 捐输), which often involved, in practice, coercion (p. 422).4 The most glaring deficiency was in technology. Chinese firearms were mostly imitations of Western imports in the Ming, lagging the British by more than two hundred years (p. 34). A series of maps outlining each battle demonstrates the gap in military tactics and strategy, as the British executed the same battle plan in various landing operations, and the Qing army was repeatedly rendered defenseless, with the exception of the Zhenjiang battle (p. 443). Mao highlights the bitter irony of Emperor Daoguang inquiring about world geography after China's defeat, while a fine world atlas made by Jesuit Ferdinand Verbiest (1623–1688) was left collecting dust in a palace warehouse (p. 430). In sharp contrast to Mao's reasoning, looking at the same or similar evidence, including the..." @default.
• W1978453646 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1978453646 creator A5090177521 @default.
• W1978453646 date "2008-01-01" @default.
• W1978453646 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
• W1978453646 title "<i>Tianchao de bengkui: Yapian zhanzheng zai yanjiu</i> (review)" @default.
• W1978453646 cites W1968008343 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W2053584261 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W2063885270 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W2104726951 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W2115369810 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W2143013215 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W2328530246 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W2798064442 @default.
• W1978453646 cites W3185935451 @default.
• W1978453646 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/cri.0.0208" @default.
• W1978453646 hasPublicationYear "2008" @default.
• W1978453646 type Work @default.
• W1978453646 sameAs 1978453646 @default.
• W1978453646 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W1978453646 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W1978453646 hasAuthorship W1978453646A5090177521 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C156804271 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C191935318 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C199033989 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C2778061430 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C2779115301 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C2779343474 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C74916050 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C124952713 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C142362112 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C144024400 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C156804271 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C15744967 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C166957645 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C17744445 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C191935318 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C199033989 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C199539241 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C2778061430 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C2779115301 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C2779343474 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C74916050 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C77805123 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C94625758 @default.
• W1978453646 hasConceptScore W1978453646C95457728 @default.
• W1978453646 hasIssue "4" @default.
• W1978453646 hasLocation W19784536461 @default.
• W1978453646 hasOpenAccess W1978453646 @default.
• W1978453646 hasPrimaryLocation W19784536461 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W2047378000 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W2076528457 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W2112457552 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W2392456815 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W2933608806 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W3049308248 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W3158183160 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W3203795623 @default.
• W1978453646 hasRelatedWork W602870081 @default.
• W1978453646 hasVolume "15" @default.
• W1978453646 isParatext "false" @default.
• W1978453646 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W1978453646 magId "1978453646" @default.
• W1978453646 workType "article" @default.