Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1986122989> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1986122989 endingPage "219" @default.
- W1986122989 startingPage "206" @default.
- W1986122989 abstract "Fossil evidence documenting the evolutionary transition from theropod dinosaurs to birds indicates unambiguously that the digits of the wing of birds are digits 1, 2, and 3. However, some embryological evidence suggests that these digits are 2, 3, and 4. This apparent lack of correspondence has been described as the greatest challenge to the widely accepted theropod–bird link (Zhou 2004. Naturwissenschaften 91:455–471). Here we review the pertinent literature regarding the debate on the origin of birds and wing digital identity and the evidence in favor of a 1, 2, 3 identity of the wing digits. Recent molecular evidence shows that the expression of Hoxd12 and Hoxd13 in the developing wing supports the theropod–bird link. In the chicken foot and in the mouse hand and foot, digit 1 is the only digit to combine the expression of Hoxd13 with the absence of expression of Hoxd12. The same is observed in the anterior digit of the wing, suggesting it is a digit 1, as expected for a theropod. Nevertheless, Galis et al. (2005. J Exp Zool (Mol Dev Evol) in press), argue that Hoxd12 and Hoxd13 expression patterns in mutant limbs do not allow distinguishing the most anterior digit in the bird wing from digit 2. They also argue that constraints to the evolution of limb development support the 2, 3, 4 identity of the wing digits. However, the case put forward by Galis et al. is biased and flawed with regard to interpretation of mutant limbs, developmental mechanisms, stages observed, and the description of the evolutionary variation of limb development. Importantly, Galis et al. do not present evidence from wild-type limbs that counters the conclusions of Vargas and Fallon (2005. J Exp Zool (Mol Dev Evol) 304B(1):85–89), and fail to provide molecular evidence to specifically support the hypothesis that the wing digits are 2, 3, and 4. The expression of Hoxd12 and Hoxd13 in the developing wing is consistent with the hypothesis that birds are living dinosaurs; this view can lead to a greater understanding of the actual limits to the evolutionary variation of limb development. J. Exp. Zool. (Mol. Dev. Evol.) 304B:206–219, 2005. © 2005 Wiley-Liss, Inc." @default.
- W1986122989 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1986122989 creator A5041446425 @default.
- W1986122989 creator A5080341511 @default.
- W1986122989 date "2005-01-01" @default.
- W1986122989 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W1986122989 title "The digits of the wing of birds are 1, 2, and 3. a review" @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1524136793 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1597858723 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1598417390 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1650502593 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1680955625 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1828499021 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1922697055 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1968416067 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1969109779 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1971167969 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1974320804 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1980566989 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1984363765 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1985491163 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1991031030 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1993351732 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1996234453 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2000283176 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2000286878 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2001023727 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2007696960 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2007869884 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2008451474 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2010357207 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2015085548 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2015518796 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2017526981 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2026259070 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2031112533 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2032768366 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2037195789 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2038517485 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2045102890 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2045158381 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2048000085 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2055792519 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2059200013 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2061846294 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2074170468 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2074557542 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2079459114 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2080180914 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2081502626 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2085311557 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2088726195 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2089073475 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2090516910 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2090677329 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2092488833 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2098101599 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2098394909 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2105505995 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2109856143 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2121610275 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2121894190 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2124800909 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2134166455 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2143326274 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2144762224 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2145144631 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2147887495 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2158859599 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2158919523 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2160418892 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2160564440 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2160922775 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2161558436 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2163838718 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2173535981 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2173867321 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2174019749 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2314697219 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2332826352 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2340120708 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W4231375646 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W4237590069 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W4255129871 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W1974313880 @default.
- W1986122989 cites W2912639839 @default.
- W1986122989 doi "https://doi.org/10.1002/jez.b.21051" @default.
- W1986122989 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15880771" @default.
- W1986122989 hasPublicationYear "2005" @default.
- W1986122989 type Work @default.
- W1986122989 sameAs 1986122989 @default.
- W1986122989 citedByCount "46" @default.
- W1986122989 countsByYear W19861229892012 @default.
- W1986122989 countsByYear W19861229892013 @default.
- W1986122989 countsByYear W19861229892014 @default.
- W1986122989 countsByYear W19861229892015 @default.
- W1986122989 countsByYear W19861229892016 @default.
- W1986122989 countsByYear W19861229892017 @default.