FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1990561891> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1990561891 endingPage "202" @default.
• W1990561891 startingPage "169" @default.
• W1990561891 abstract "1. The Issue Almost all interpreters of Scotus now agree in rejecting the old-fashioned charge that Scotus thought God would act in a completely arbitrary way in his dealings with creatures.2 As they point out, Scotus says in several places that God is ordinatissime volens —a most methodical lover, as one translator has it.3 Scotus also speaks of God as willing most reasonably, and in one place he even says that God made all things with right reason. Moreover, he devotes a whole question in the Ordinatio to arguing that there is justice in God. On the basis of such passages, interpreters conclude that Scotus's God, although he is of course perfectly free, always acts both reasonably and justly, never arbitrarily. In this paper I shall examine these interpretations and the texts on which [End Page 169] they are based. In every case, we shall find that interpreters have greatly overstated the constraints that God's rationality and justice impose on his willing. As a result, I shall have to admit that there is a good deal of truth in the charge that Scotus's God acts arbitrarily in some sense. But unlike those who have used the charge of arbitrariness to dismiss Scotus's views, I shall argue that the kind of arbitrariness Scotus recognizes in the divine will is nothing to worry about. Far from being an embarrassment, it is all of a piece with a most appealing picture of God and his relation to the created world. First, however, I must delimit the scope of this paper, since there are really two distinct issues that arise in considering the degree of arbitrariness that must be attributed to Scotus's God. The first issue is what we might call the question of God's legislative rationality. Here the question is whether God's rationality constrains what he wills regarding the moral law. The mainstream interpretation holds that it does, and that the picture of Scotus as a radical voluntarist concerning the moral law—as someone who holds that God simply gets to make up whatever wacky rules he might come up with off the top of his head—fails to appreciate the rationality that Scotus ascribes to the divine will. The second issue, which we might call the question of God's creative rationality, is more general. Here the issue is whether God's rationality constrains the sort of world he can create and influences his dealings with his creatures. Again, the mainstream interpretation holds that it does; specifically, it holds that God must make his creatures in a fitting way and confer on them the perfections appropriate to them, and so not just any possible order of creation is in fact feasible for God as one who wills in a most reasonable way. The two issues are not always kept separate in the secondary literature. Perhaps there is some justification for this, since many interpreters treat God's establishment of the moral law as a special case of his treatment of his creatures (specifically, of his human creatures), so that the question of God's legislative rationality turns out to be included in the question of God's creative rationality. But this assimilation of the two questions depends on a close association between the natural law and the exigencies of human nature, whereas Scotus takes great pains to repudiate any such association. Since I have discussed the question of God's legislative rationality at considerable length in another article, I here confine myself primarily to God's creative rationality.4 I shall take it as proved (for it is not in dispute) that Scotus's God cannot will contradictions. He cannot create square circles or married bachelors. And since Scotus is an essentialist, he takes God's inability to will contradictions to mean [End Page 170] also that God cannot create beings of..." @default.
• W1990561891 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1990561891 creator A5069408771 @default.
• W1990561891 date "2000-01-01" @default.
• W1990561891 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
• W1990561891 title "A Most Methodical Lover?: On Scotus's Arbitrary Creator" @default.
• W1990561891 cites W2008634930 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W2038572575 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W2102095727 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W2324200977 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W2518194977 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W562376136 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W585465852 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W611354861 @default.
• W1990561891 cites W634577459 @default.
• W1990561891 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/hph.2005.0086" @default.
• W1990561891 hasPublicationYear "2000" @default.
• W1990561891 type Work @default.
• W1990561891 sameAs 1990561891 @default.
• W1990561891 citedByCount "27" @default.
• W1990561891 countsByYear W19905618912012 @default.
• W1990561891 countsByYear W19905618912013 @default.
• W1990561891 countsByYear W19905618912018 @default.
• W1990561891 countsByYear W19905618912021 @default.
• W1990561891 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W1990561891 hasAuthorship W1990561891A5069408771 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C122783720 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C136815107 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C139621336 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C188082385 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C2776608160 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C2776716606 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C2777451423 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C62520636 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C86792732 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C111472728 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C121332964 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C122783720 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C136815107 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C138885662 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C139621336 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C15744967 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C166957645 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C17744445 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C188082385 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C199360897 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C199539241 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C27206212 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C2776608160 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C2776716606 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C2777451423 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C41008148 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C62520636 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C77805123 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C86792732 @default.
• W1990561891 hasConceptScore W1990561891C95457728 @default.
• W1990561891 hasIssue "2" @default.
• W1990561891 hasLocation W19905618911 @default.
• W1990561891 hasOpenAccess W1990561891 @default.
• W1990561891 hasPrimaryLocation W19905618911 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W160145377 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W2321756657 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W2369818852 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W2474519816 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W2528263579 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W2769816357 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W2978169634 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W2993159568 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W3033504850 @default.
• W1990561891 hasRelatedWork W168737679 @default.
• W1990561891 hasVolume "38" @default.
• W1990561891 isParatext "false" @default.
• W1990561891 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W1990561891 magId "1990561891" @default.
• W1990561891 workType "article" @default.