FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1993825744> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W1993825744 endingPage "339" @default.
• W1993825744 startingPage "305" @default.
• W1993825744 abstract "We compare two approaches to designing and analyzing monitoring studies to assess chronic, local environmental impacts. Intervention Analysis (IA) compares Before and After time series at an Impact site; a special case is Before–After, Control–Impact (BACI), using comparison sites as covariates to reduce extraneous variance and serial correlation. IVRS (impact vs. reference sites) compares Impact and Control sites with respect to Before–After change, treating the sites as experimental units. The IVRS estimate of an “effect” is the same as that of the simplest BACI (though not of others), but IVRS estimates error variance by variation among sites, while IA and BACI estimate it by variation over time. These approaches differ in goals, design, and models of the role of chance in determining the data. In IA and BACI, the goal is to determine change at the specific Impact site, so no Controls are needed. IA does not have controls and BACI's are not experimental controls, but covariates, deliberately chosen to be correlated with the Impact site. The goal given for IVRS is to compare hypothetical Impact and Control “populations,” so the Controls are essential and are randomly chosen, perhaps with restrictions to make them independent of each other and (presumably) of Impact. IA and BACI inferences are model based: uncertainty arises from sampling error and natural temporal processes causing variation in the variable of concern (e.g., a species' abundance); these processes are modeled as the results of repeatable chance setups. IVRS inferences are design based: uncertainty arises from variation among sites, as well as the other two sources, and is modeled by the assumed random selection of Impact and Control sites, like the drawing of equiprobable numbers from a hat. We outline the formal analyses, showing that IVRS is simpler, and BACI more complex, than usually supposed. We then describe the principles and assumptions of IA and BACI, defining an “effect” as the difference between what happened after the impact and what would have happened without it, and stressing the need to justify chance models as reasonable representations of human uncertainty. We respond to comments on BACI, some of which arise from misunderstanding of these principles. IVRS's design-based justification is almost always invalid in real assessments: the Impact site is not chosen randomly. We show that “as if random” selection by “Nature” is untenable and that an approximation to this, while a possibly useful guide, cannot be used for inference. We argue that, without literal random assignment of treatments to sites, IVRS can only be model based. Its design and analyses will then be different, using and allowing for correlation between sites. It is likely to have low power and requires strong assumptions that are difficult to check, so should be used only when IA or BACI cannot be used, e.g., when there are no Before data." @default.
• W1993825744 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W1993825744 creator A5010948572 @default.
• W1993825744 creator A5068042314 @default.
• W1993825744 date "2001-05-01" @default.
• W1993825744 modified "2023-10-03" @default.
• W1993825744 title "TEMPORAL AND SPATIAL VARIATION IN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT" @default.
• W1993825744 cites W1488022545 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W1977149102 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W1978420442 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W1983225354 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W1991729247 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W1991972749 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W1994672023 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2000674269 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2006648072 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2020874071 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2022420754 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2030278532 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2039597390 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2051660465 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2051937879 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2052513269 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2054362344 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2060050130 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2067737232 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2068206297 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2073600789 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2074692765 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2085102724 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2101666134 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2115312517 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2118015129 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2118195428 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2126549349 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2132917208 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2140361353 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2142850572 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2317782077 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2317866228 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W2325683274 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4212782674 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4236239802 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4239858503 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4245029435 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4247399381 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4247938048 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4250183726 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4250365663 @default.
• W1993825744 cites W4256255930 @default.
• W1993825744 doi "https://doi.org/10.1890/0012-9615(2001)071[0305:tasvie]2.0.co;2" @default.
• W1993825744 hasPublicationYear "2001" @default.
• W1993825744 type Work @default.
• W1993825744 sameAs 1993825744 @default.
• W1993825744 citedByCount "280" @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442012 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442013 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442014 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442015 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442016 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442017 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442018 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442019 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442020 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442021 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442022 @default.
• W1993825744 countsByYear W19938257442023 @default.
• W1993825744 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W1993825744 hasAuthorship W1993825744A5010948572 @default.
• W1993825744 hasAuthorship W1993825744A5068042314 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C106131492 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C119043178 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C121955636 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C134306372 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C140779682 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C149782125 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C182365436 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C196083921 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C2778334786 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C31972630 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C39432304 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C44870925 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C77077793 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C105795698 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C106131492 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C119043178 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C121332964 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C121955636 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C134306372 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C140779682 @default.
• W1993825744 hasConceptScore W1993825744C144133560 @default.

• next