Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1997653223> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1997653223 endingPage "137" @default.
- W1997653223 startingPage "115" @default.
- W1997653223 abstract "On Lecturing and Being Beautiful:Zadie Smith, Elaine Scarry, and the Liberal Aesthetic Alexander Dick (bio) and Christina Lupton (bio) At the Heart of Zadie Smith’s Prize-Winning Novel, On Beauty,is a strong sense that the humanities today are in a state of crisis: the values of equality and relativism assumed in the principles of liberal education have been outpaced, on one hand, by the competitive forces of the market and, on the other, by new forms of protest and self-knowledge, both of which lie beyond academia’s traditional paradigms. Howard Belsey, the novel’s academic anti-hero, embodies this crisis. Stuck at an impasse with his anti-humanist book, Against Rembrandt, caricatured by his students as demonically opposed to any expression of enthusiasm for anything, failing to reproduce his hard-won middle-class secularism in either of his sons, opposed to Mozart, Forster, and all representational art, and suffering the consequences of his committee on positive discrimination having devolved into an extramarital affair, Howard’s agenda seems to lack all ethical horizons as he plummets into a state of skeptical despair: “‘What,’” he asks, pointing to a picture by Rembrandt, ready to undercut the feeling that any college freshman might have for great works of art and literature by suggesting the historical and cultural specificity of our [End Page 115] appreciation of beauty, “‘are we signing up to when we talk of the “beauty” of this “light”?’… ‘What are these images really concerned with?’” (252).1 The central irony of the novel is that Howard is already something of an aesthete, if not someone who can appreciate art in the classroom then certainly someone who senses it, imagines it, and confronts it everywhere else. Howard feels everything: the sadness of a funeral service, the ridiculous dancing of a glee club ruining u2’s “Pride (in the name of love),” the smell of alcohol, the touch of his children. Smith’s characterization of Howard’s fraught persona picks up on a widespread mood of concern over the perceived antipathy of academic liberals—particularly those making the cerebral, relativist arguments for which Howard sees himself a mouthpiece—to current ethical practices. Thus, Howard realizes that the responsibility and obligation that individuals should feel toward each other—the principle tenet of modern ethical liberalism—lies outside the bounds of the university as an institution, the so-called vanguard of liberal education. The affection people can and do have for each other, the novel suggests, emerges in spaces and moments of ecstatic fissure in the university’s bureaucratic edifice rather than in the institution proper. Elaine Scarry’s On Beauty and Being Just, from which Smith claims to have borrowed “a title, a chapter heading and a good deal of inspiration” (i), also chafes at the liberal arts’ tendency to refute the power of aesthetic experience. Disavowed by Marxist critics as a form of deflection from structural critique and by poststructuralist critics as a form of violence done to the object being viewed, the language of beauty, states Scarry, has fallen out of favour with the Howards of the world: although “the humanities are made up of beautiful poems, stories, paintings, sketches, sculpture, [End Page 116] film, essays, debates, and it is this that every day draws us to them,” she argues, “conversations about the beauty of these objects has been banished, so that we coinhabit the space of these objects … yet speak about their beauty only in whispers” (57). The underlying aims of On Beauty and Being Just are first to unveil and then to counteract the institutional prohibitions that deprive intellectuals of an enriching language of beauty and render works of art and literature powerless as a moral resource in university life (58).2 Protesting this situation, Scarry introduces beauty, which she sees as an “alliance” between individual responses to aesthetic objects and larger instances of “truth” or “justice,” as a corrective to the rationalism of the humanities and a supplement to the discourse of postmodern liberalism. The assumption behind Scarry’s and Smith’s arguments is that beauty, and all that it implies as the focus of a moral disposition and a practical engagement with life..." @default.
- W1997653223 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1997653223 creator A5004200582 @default.
- W1997653223 creator A5006400035 @default.
- W1997653223 date "2013-01-01" @default.
- W1997653223 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W1997653223 title "On Lecturing and Being Beautiful: Zadie Smith, Elaine Scarry, and the Liberal Aesthetic" @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1499600894 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1501056908 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1522785651 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1526836172 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1527925586 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1543069743 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1560661889 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1565465892 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1603676621 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1604614717 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1775511237 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W1999846801 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2020534194 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2048260797 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2058439416 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2061878195 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2065342460 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2081811212 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2086430572 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2091192220 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2333252024 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2340410768 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W2529771621 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W3016007247 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W305823309 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W562319743 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W569070112 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W573117187 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W611877707 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W629680026 @default.
- W1997653223 cites W653943049 @default.
- W1997653223 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/esc.2013.0032" @default.
- W1997653223 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
- W1997653223 type Work @default.
- W1997653223 sameAs 1997653223 @default.
- W1997653223 citedByCount "3" @default.
- W1997653223 countsByYear W19976532232017 @default.
- W1997653223 countsByYear W19976532232019 @default.
- W1997653223 countsByYear W19976532232020 @default.
- W1997653223 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1997653223 hasAuthorship W1997653223A5004200582 @default.
- W1997653223 hasAuthorship W1997653223A5006400035 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C11413529 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C120912362 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C153606108 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C2777336010 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C2779975665 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C2780422510 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C2780620123 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C2781354396 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C37413474 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C48103436 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C51364203 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConcept C53538382 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C107038049 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C11413529 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C120912362 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C124952713 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C138885662 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C142362112 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C144024400 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C153606108 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C17744445 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C199539241 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C27206212 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C2777336010 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C2779975665 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C2780422510 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C2780620123 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C2781354396 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C37413474 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C41008148 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C48103436 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C51364203 @default.
- W1997653223 hasConceptScore W1997653223C53538382 @default.
- W1997653223 hasIssue "2-3" @default.
- W1997653223 hasLocation W19976532231 @default.
- W1997653223 hasOpenAccess W1997653223 @default.
- W1997653223 hasPrimaryLocation W19976532231 @default.
- W1997653223 hasRelatedWork W2027793087 @default.
- W1997653223 hasRelatedWork W2331219815 @default.
- W1997653223 hasRelatedWork W2349353468 @default.