Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1999080664> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W1999080664 endingPage "86" @default.
- W1999080664 startingPage "57" @default.
- W1999080664 abstract "This article addresses how collaborative geospatial/geovisual decision support systems (C-GDSS) can achieve greater measures of spatial justice within an institutional, democratic framework for public goods allocation. Current public participation geographic information systems (PPGIS) and participatory geographic information science (P-GIS) literature identifies issues of scale and consensus as problematic for such systems. C-GDSS deployments aimed at achieving spatial justice through small-scale, consensual processes fail when scaled to large processes involving heterogeneous groups where consensus is not realistically achievable. For this case study, we identify a significant deficit in the quality of public involvement in transportation infrastructure (TI) planning and design in the United States. We call this the Arnstein Gap. This exists in part because professionals lack confidence that they can integrate community cultural values, despite C-GDSS use, and have come to fear public engagement. To close the Arnstein Gap using C-GDSS we reconsider relationships among landscape, justice, and difference. The nature of power in the U.S. democratic polity and TI's role is examined and a geographical justice framework is derived from Rawls's (1971) Rawls, J. 1971. A theory of justice, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar] theory of justice. We argue that within the normative framework of Jeffersonian democracy in the United States, spatial justice cannot be attained through an epistemology of distributional justice. Instead, it can more feasibly be attained by increasing procedural justice and access to justice. From these principles we develop a more suitable methodology for reflexive, large-scale group deployment of such systems termed structured public involvement (SPI). SPI holds that large-scale, nonconsensual collaborative TI planning is not oxymoronic, nor is it morally or practically inferior to other options. Methodological consideration is given to how geospatial and geovisual technologies can be used in TI design to elicit and respect cultural preferences. SPI consists of a reflexive public involvement framework that situates these technologies as dialogic media in participatory, nonconsensual collaborative planning and design. Two SPI case studies are discussed. AMIS is a participatory multicriteria/GIS corridor evaluation methodology and CAVE is a fuzzy-logic-based visual evaluation methodology. Anonymous real-time public process evaluation data demonstrate SPI's high performance. We discuss impediments, such as project sponsor's preferred Arnstein level, public participation patterns, professional resistance, and other considerations. This work has implications for collaborative public goods decision making using geovisual/geospatial methods in participatory democracies." @default.
- W1999080664 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1999080664 creator A5042006835 @default.
- W1999080664 creator A5074732015 @default.
- W1999080664 date "2010-01-01" @default.
- W1999080664 modified "2023-09-30" @default.
- W1999080664 title "Toward Structured Public Involvement: Justice, Geography and Collaborative Geospatial/Geovisual Decision Support Systems" @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1485095842 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1577962188 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1719701148 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1756785794 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1767786076 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1833117778 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1964100125 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1964979205 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1965775494 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1966039074 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1967544806 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1970325491 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1970393924 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1970452874 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1970478488 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1974327233 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1975035631 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1976818923 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1979351569 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1981220315 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1981777681 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1982704009 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1982966076 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1983464495 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1984579269 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1986006255 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1987034952 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1987111701 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1987349636 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1988742426 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1989092808 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1992895673 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1995182354 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1996160081 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1998396070 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1998542034 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1998692279 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W1999557340 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2001979755 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2003425117 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2004852654 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2004974379 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2005418369 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2007754499 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2008251417 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2009971455 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2011499868 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2011777474 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2012736362 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2013531215 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2014615217 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2014924924 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2014995170 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2020532252 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2022053189 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2022214292 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2023454152 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2024165650 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2025048865 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2025324071 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2028719515 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2031036777 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2031082906 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2033063496 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2034059333 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2037537949 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2039120844 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2040410064 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2041097041 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2041744004 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2041981887 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2043515479 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2044749593 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2048475892 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2051206667 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2054499925 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2056239848 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2056369899 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2060338173 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2063513884 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2064827593 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2065288796 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2065763670 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2065868009 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2066101088 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2067104774 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2069602989 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2072075148 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2072202455 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2075512689 @default.
- W1999080664 cites W2077440707 @default.