Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W1999691936> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 65 of
65
with 100 items per page.
- W1999691936 endingPage "114" @default.
- W1999691936 startingPage "111" @default.
- W1999691936 abstract "HE ASSERTION that regional anesthesia is superior to general anesthesia for carotid endarterectomy (CEA) was first made in this journal by Dr John Youngberg in a Pro/Con debate appearing in October 1987.1.2 At that time, little outcome data were available to support any conclusion on anesthetic technique. Accordingly, Dr Youngberg based his argument on the potential benefit of regional anesthesia for CEA. His paper stressed the theoretical advantage of monitoring an awake patient for new neurologic deficits compared with the inaccuracies of cerebral monitoring in an anesthetized patient. In an awake patient, intra-arterial shunts are placed when indicated by patient assessment. Therefore, shunt use (and the associated risks of dissection, thrombus formation, or atheromatous embolism and resulting neurologic deficits) could be reduced in patients with regional anesthesia. Further, neurologic and myocardial outcomes could be improved by avoiding the deleterious effects of general anesthesia on cerebral and myocardial blood flows. Finally, he speculated that regional anesthesia would allow quicker postoperative recovery, and sholxer intensive care unit and hospital lengths of stay. Despite these persuasive arguments, Dr Youngherg cited only one study that directly compared outcome in patients having regio~Lal versus general anesthesia, 3 and, therefore, his conclusions remained only speculation. Since the publication of that first Pro/Con debate, several authors have published outcome data comparing regional with general anesthesia for CEA, prompting this return to the issue. Specifically, a Medline search of the literature reveals 13 papers that compare outcome in a total of 7,619 patients having either regional or general anesthesia for CEA (Table 1). The data are now available with which to reevaluate Dr Youngberg's assertion that regional anesthesia is superior to general anesthesia for CEA. For these purposes, primary outcome will be defined as the incidence of postoperative transient ischemic attack (TIA), stroke, myocardial infarction (MI), and death. Secondary outcomes will include the incidence of shunt placement, hospital and intensive care unit lengths of stay, hospital charges, postoperative hemodynamic stability, and use of vasoactive agents. In addition, information on the reliability of central nervous system monitoring during general anesthesia, and the incidence of failed regional anesthesia will be reviewed. These outcome data clearly show that regional anesthesia improves primary and secondary outcomes, that regional anesthesia permits superior neurologic monitoring, and that the incidence of failed blocks is low. Table 1 presents primary outcome in 13 studies 3-15 tiaat specifically evaluate regional versus general anesthesia for CEA. Two of these studies report data from prospective trials, s,13 whereas the remainder are retrospective reviews. Three of these studies 11,12,15 show a significant improvement in primary outcome with regional anesthesia and deserve special comment. Allen et al v report on 679 consecutive CEAs in 584 patients. MI occurred in nine patients in the general anesthesia greup (2.5%) and in two patients in the regional anesthesia greup (0.6%), p = 0.07. Cardiopulmonary complications occurred in 30 operations (8.3%) performed under general anesthesia, and in only 13 (4.1%) operations with cervical block, p = 0.03. Becquemin et a112 retrospectively studied a series of 385 CEAs and found 10 MIs documented by electrocardiogram or cardiac enzyme changes in the general anesthesia group, and no MIs in the regional anesthesia group, p < 0.05. Five of these 10 MIs were fatal. They concluded that regional anesthesia by cervical" @default.
- W1999691936 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W1999691936 creator A5058539596 @default.
- W1999691936 date "1998-02-01" @default.
- W1999691936 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W1999691936 title "Pro: Regional anesthesia is the best technique for carotid endarterectomy" @default.
- W1999691936 cites W1963485293 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W1972294908 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2018457901 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2023802941 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2028157842 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2054130774 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2066895264 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2068913606 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2076369396 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2078506324 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2081703316 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2093660515 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2150839914 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2312296877 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2410713046 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2462946007 @default.
- W1999691936 cites W2464943392 @default.
- W1999691936 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/s1053-0770(98)90065-9" @default.
- W1999691936 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9509367" @default.
- W1999691936 hasPublicationYear "1998" @default.
- W1999691936 type Work @default.
- W1999691936 sameAs 1999691936 @default.
- W1999691936 citedByCount "11" @default.
- W1999691936 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W1999691936 hasAuthorship W1999691936A5058539596 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConcept C164705383 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConcept C2781068581 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConcept C2987047532 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConcept C3017725471 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConcept C42219234 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConceptScore W1999691936C164705383 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConceptScore W1999691936C2781068581 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConceptScore W1999691936C2987047532 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConceptScore W1999691936C3017725471 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConceptScore W1999691936C42219234 @default.
- W1999691936 hasConceptScore W1999691936C71924100 @default.
- W1999691936 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W1999691936 hasLocation W19996919361 @default.
- W1999691936 hasLocation W19996919362 @default.
- W1999691936 hasOpenAccess W1999691936 @default.
- W1999691936 hasPrimaryLocation W19996919361 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2049567231 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2072934113 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2082090830 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2289073042 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2313261818 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2350451929 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2397646436 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2512121828 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W2947515170 @default.
- W1999691936 hasRelatedWork W4235832914 @default.
- W1999691936 hasVolume "12" @default.
- W1999691936 isParatext "false" @default.
- W1999691936 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W1999691936 magId "1999691936" @default.
- W1999691936 workType "article" @default.