Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2000719274> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2000719274 endingPage "4272" @default.
- W2000719274 startingPage "4265" @default.
- W2000719274 abstract "Overlapping meta-analyses on the same topic are common and often report discordant results. An Endocrine Society (ES) meta-analysis reported that vitamin D with calcium reduced the risk of falls, whereas vitamin D monotherapy had no effect. Despite meta-analyzing an overlapping set of trials, we concluded that vitamin D with or without calcium had no effect on falls. The objective of the study was to determine the reasons for the different conclusions from the two meta-analyses. We extracted raw data from the 25 randomized controlled trials included in the ES meta-analysis, calculated the treatment effect for each trial, compared them with the published ES meta-analysis, and determined the reason for any differences. Of the 25 trials, there were differences in 14 results (56%) between the two meta-analyses. In the ES meta-analysis, data were used from a subset of falls or participants (four trials), from trial completers (three trials), or were imputed from fracture data (one trial). Other differences resulted from use of adjusted results from original papers (two trials), differences in incorporating data from multiarm and factorial studies (three trials), and inconsistent group numbers reported in original papers (two trials). In a reanalysis of the ES meta-analysis using unadjusted analyses and all randomized participants, there was a marginal effect of vitamin D with or without calcium on falls [relative risk (RR) 0.95, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.90–1.00], with the subgroup analysis showing no effect of vitamin D monotherapy (RR 1.00, 95% CI 0.92–1.08) or vitamin D with calcium vs the placebo/controls (RR 0.95, 95% CI 0.88–1.02), but a modest effect of vitamin D with calcium vs calcium (RR 0.84, 95% CI 0.76–0.92) was shown. Methodological differences in utilizing data from the same trials directly led to substantially different conclusions between meta-analyses about the efficacy of vitamin D supplements on falls. More detailed reporting of meta-analyses is necessary to allow readers to understand the discordant results from overlapping meta-analyses." @default.
- W2000719274 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2000719274 creator A5007875733 @default.
- W2000719274 creator A5018585638 @default.
- W2000719274 creator A5068597827 @default.
- W2000719274 date "2014-11-01" @default.
- W2000719274 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2000719274 title "Differences in Overlapping Meta-Analyses of Vitamin D Supplements and Falls" @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1505358055 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1518786313 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1531229431 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1549000600 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1598602811 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1960684477 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1974125594 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1992279725 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W1995487295 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2006471524 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2011340260 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2011411081 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2012448954 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2022144190 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2055286480 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2076134487 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2087838098 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2091105678 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2091494376 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2094142644 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2096150705 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2099617267 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2101076802 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2101237572 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2107705806 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2108066906 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2116841061 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2122398315 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2124047692 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2128317524 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2133653637 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2140918909 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2142186217 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2147385250 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2151216962 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2152000549 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2152545213 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2153059487 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2159754119 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2165372719 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2171086243 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2261803786 @default.
- W2000719274 cites W2314110838 @default.
- W2000719274 doi "https://doi.org/10.1210/jc.2014-2562" @default.
- W2000719274 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25093621" @default.
- W2000719274 hasPublicationYear "2014" @default.
- W2000719274 type Work @default.
- W2000719274 sameAs 2000719274 @default.
- W2000719274 citedByCount "41" @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742014 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742015 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742016 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742017 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742018 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742019 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742020 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742021 @default.
- W2000719274 countsByYear W20007192742023 @default.
- W2000719274 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2000719274 hasAuthorship W2000719274A5007875733 @default.
- W2000719274 hasAuthorship W2000719274A5018585638 @default.
- W2000719274 hasAuthorship W2000719274A5068597827 @default.
- W2000719274 hasBestOaLocation W20007192741 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C124490489 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C168563851 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C187960798 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C44249647 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C82789193 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConcept C95190672 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C124490489 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C126322002 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C168563851 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C187960798 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C44249647 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C71924100 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C82789193 @default.
- W2000719274 hasConceptScore W2000719274C95190672 @default.
- W2000719274 hasIssue "11" @default.
- W2000719274 hasLocation W20007192741 @default.
- W2000719274 hasLocation W20007192742 @default.
- W2000719274 hasOpenAccess W2000719274 @default.
- W2000719274 hasPrimaryLocation W20007192741 @default.
- W2000719274 hasRelatedWork W2096190005 @default.
- W2000719274 hasRelatedWork W2114346778 @default.
- W2000719274 hasRelatedWork W2531052508 @default.
- W2000719274 hasRelatedWork W2592774827 @default.
- W2000719274 hasRelatedWork W2626084264 @default.
- W2000719274 hasRelatedWork W2989235071 @default.