Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2003197739> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2003197739 endingPage "1813" @default.
- W2003197739 startingPage "1795" @default.
- W2003197739 abstract "To conduct a systematic review of behavioral assessment scales for disorders of consciousness (DOC); provide evidence-based recommendations for clinical use based on their content validity, reliability, diagnostic validity, and ability to predict functional outcomes; and provide research recommendations on DOC scale development and validation.Articles published through March 31, 2009, using MEDLINE, CINAHL, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, Biomedical Reference Collection, and PsycINFO. Thirteen primary terms that defined DOC were paired with 30 secondary terms that defined aspects of measurement. Scale names, abbreviations, and authors were also used as search terms. Task force members identified additional articles by using personal knowledge and examination of references in reviewed articles.Primary criteria included the following: (1) provided reliability, diagnostic validity, and/or prognostic validity data; (2) examined a cohort, case control, or case series sample of persons with DOC who were age older than or equal to 18 years; and (3) assessed in an acute care or rehabilitation setting. Articles were excluded if peer review was not conducted, original data were not reported, or an English language article was not available. The initial search yielded 580 articles. After paired rater review of study abstracts, guideline development was based on 37 articles representing 13 DOC scales.Rater pairs classified studies addressing diagnostic and prognostic validity by using the American Academy of Neurology 4-tier level of evidence scheme, and reliability by using a task force-developed 3-tier evidence scheme. An independent quality review of ratings was conducted, and corrections were made.The Coma Recovery Scale-Revised (CRS-R), Sensory Stimulation Assessment Measure (SSAM), Wessex Head Injury Matrix (WHIM), Western Neuro Sensory Stimulation Profile (WNSSP), Sensory Modality Assessment Technique (SMART), Disorders of Consciousness Scale (DOCS), and Coma/Near-Coma Scale (CNC) have acceptable standardized administration and scoring procedures. The CRS-R has excellent content validity and is the only scale to address all Aspen Workgroup criteria. The SMART, SSAM, WHIM, and WNSSP demonstrate good content validity, containing items that could distinguish persons who are in a vegetative state, are in a minimally conscious state (MCS), or have emerged from MCS. The Full Outline of UnResponsiveness Score (FOUR), WNSSP, CRS-R, Comprehensive Levels of Consciousness Scale (CLOCS), and Innsbruck Coma Scale (INNS) showed substantial evidence of internal consistency. The FOUR and the CRS-R showed substantial evidence of good interrater reliability. Evidence of diagnostic validity and prognostic validity in brain injury survivor samples had very high levels of potential bias because of methodologic issues such as lack of rater masking.The CRS-R may be used to assess DOC with minor reservations, and the SMART, WNSSP, SSAM, WHIM, and DOCS may be used to assess DOC with moderate reservations. The CNC may be used to assess DOC with major reservations. The FOUR, INNS, Glasgow-Liege Coma Scale, Swedish Reaction Level Scale-1985, Loewenstein Communication Scale, and CLOCS are not recommended at this time for bedside behavioral assessment of DOC because of a lack of content validity, lack of standardization, and/or unproven reliability." @default.
- W2003197739 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5000101453 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5014562130 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5015090281 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5022924453 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5026410911 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5027894534 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5036053753 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5037296979 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5038335088 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5044356531 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5047730341 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5063241310 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5089345721 @default.
- W2003197739 creator A5091377322 @default.
- W2003197739 date "2010-12-01" @default.
- W2003197739 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
- W2003197739 title "Assessment Scales for Disorders of Consciousness: Evidence-Based Recommendations for Clinical Practice and Research" @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1560435594 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1590905129 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1601163476 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1603121691 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1797833172 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1829168467 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1964282242 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1967057944 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1969559411 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1969967807 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1971807217 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1972814887 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1974727223 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1975174857 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1984605046 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1985850872 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1994996671 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W1996864068 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2000994978 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2004051647 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2006039188 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2007105657 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2009787980 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2010283424 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2010582783 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2019782088 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2020863690 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2021347722 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2021927512 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2023299366 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2024755457 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2025326351 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2026739223 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2027727791 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2029289556 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2031819531 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2032629570 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2033013000 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2033349308 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2033535857 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2034096845 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2034720874 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2034945853 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2035498426 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2039674124 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2040386562 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2040684630 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2041961695 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2042732125 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2044458982 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2046270782 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2048335775 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2051784700 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2052001868 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2054510160 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2056969393 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2059667061 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2059877223 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2060460252 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2060898106 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2064437704 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2066305196 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2070806188 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2079257641 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2079424889 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2083481830 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2083523346 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2084750764 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2086079690 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2087021581 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2090073975 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2094287021 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2096056306 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2098157949 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2100032382 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2100288957 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2105445855 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2105493619 @default.
- W2003197739 cites W2111037192 @default.