Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2003383146> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2003383146 endingPage "443" @default.
- W2003383146 startingPage "425" @default.
- W2003383146 abstract "Competing Technologies, National(ist) Narratives, and Universal Claims:Toward a Global History of Space Exploration Asif A. Siddiqi (bio) David Nye has succinctly noted that the meaning of a tool is inseparable from the stories that surround it.1 What are the meanings of space technology, particularly for historians? How do these meanings differ in disparate national contexts? Is it possible to conceive of a universal narrative of the history of space exploration? The fiftieth anniversary of the Society for the History of Technology—and the almost simultaneous fiftieth anniversary of Sputnik—provided an obvious occasion to revisit these questions. In the fifty years since the launch of Sputnik on 4 October 1957, more than 6,000 functioning satellites have been launched into Earth orbit and beyond—some to the farthest reaches of our solar system. By its physical nature, space exploration has a resonance beyond national borders—at a fundamental level, it is a project that transcends national claims and appeals to the global, perhaps even to the universal. Yet our understanding of the half-century of space travel is still firmly rooted in the framework of the national imagination. Until now, barring very few exceptions, only nation-states have been able to mobilize the resources necessary for regular access to space. For most laypersons, the perceived apotheosis of space exploration remains the heady days after Sputnik, when the United States and the Soviet Union competed to trump the other in a series of progressively more complex feats in space. The cold-war space race retains its mystique, either [End Page 425] as a benchmark that subsequent accomplishments could never equal, or as an anomaly whose particular conditions could never be repeated. It has, in fact, become impossible to think of space exploration without allusion to the halcyon days of the 1960s and equally inconceivable for historians to interpret the act of space travel without the space race hovering over the very language that we use. My goal in this essay is to offer some thoughts on the way in which the relationship between national identity and space exploration has affected our discipline's approach to the history of spaceflight—in fact, has been fundamental to it. This discussion is intended to be a starting point to revisit both the history and the historiography of space exploration and suggest some new avenues of investigation that move beyond formulations rooted in the cold-war space race. I will begin by illuminating the ways in which multiple and contradictory narratives—engendered by national claims—have been a staple of space history in both the United States and Russia, the two foremost spacefaring nations. The citizens of both nations remember space exploration quite differently, yet they appeal to the same kind of universal import. In addition, the maturation of other national space programs—those of China, Japan, and India, for example—will require us to approach space history with new lenses as more and more new narratives join the old cold-war-centered approach to space history. Second, by using the particular case of the burgeoning Indian space program and its postcolonial context, I will draw attention to avenues opened up by de-privileging borders in the history of space exploration, i.e., clearing the path to a potentially global history of space exploration. This line of thinking may raise a set of provocative questions concerning the motivations which lead nations to explore space, and why, in doing so, they take certain pathways that are not explicable by deterministic approaches. National Narratives Ask historians of technology from the United States to name the most important event in the history of space exploration, and they will cite the Apollo Moon landing in 1969. Pose the same question to their Russian counterparts and they will recall the flight of Yuri Gagarin in 1961. American historians of spaceflight (or indeed, historians of technology) would be surprised to learn that few beyond the United States remember or care about Apollo, while Russians find it startling that few Americans have even heard of Gagarin. Two nations that have engaged in essentially the same endeavor—to take leave of this planet—have fundamentally dissimilar perspectives on the same..." @default.
- W2003383146 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2003383146 creator A5062757265 @default.
- W2003383146 date "2010-01-01" @default.
- W2003383146 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W2003383146 title "Competing Technologies, National(ist) Narratives, and Universal Claims: Toward a Global History of Space Exploration" @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1488585868 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1493004624 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1516601225 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1522468555 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1541228666 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1543600149 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1594316443 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1963756427 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1969661995 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1972453704 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1973051082 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1979784165 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1982422502 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W1988060314 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2003576384 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2004038836 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2004626461 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2011659094 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2029844676 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2031389708 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2039632611 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2041738594 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2045425725 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2050798723 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2057224176 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2064234353 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2065789644 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2070515461 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2072022436 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2088217843 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2089459573 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2089833493 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2094222027 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2127979804 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2130236754 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2151035621 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2270405047 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2317256473 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2317758263 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2320217246 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2341648690 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2800221395 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2801098865 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W3005759312 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W356901507 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W43418184 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W612934541 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W620084167 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W622416551 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W626367040 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W651501867 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W651623636 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W94102080 @default.
- W2003383146 cites W2343019361 @default.
- W2003383146 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/tech.0.0459" @default.
- W2003383146 hasPublicationYear "2010" @default.
- W2003383146 type Work @default.
- W2003383146 sameAs 2003383146 @default.
- W2003383146 citedByCount "23" @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462012 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462013 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462014 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462015 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462016 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462018 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462019 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462020 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462021 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462022 @default.
- W2003383146 countsByYear W20033831462023 @default.
- W2003383146 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2003383146 hasAuthorship W2003383146A5062757265 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C103284512 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C104060986 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C1276947 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C195244886 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C199033989 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C2778572836 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C2779271020 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C2780876879 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2003383146 hasConcept C95457728 @default.