Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2005538184> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2005538184 abstract "Abstract The goal of this paper is to critically evaluate Anthropological Evolutionary Ecology (AEE) as a paradigm by utilizing the method for theory framework developed by Pickett et al. (1994). While AEE can contribute in some ways to our understanding of human behavior through methods and techniques derived from neo-Darwinian theory (as well as current approaches in animal behavior and decision theory), AEE as a paradigm remains theoretically ill-equipped for the study of human ecology. This critique will focus on Anthropological Evolutionary Ecology, however, references will be made to Biological Evolutionary Ecology (BEE) since AEE relies heavily on theoretical components derived from BEE. Introduction A critique of Anthropological Evolutionary Ecology (AEE) as a theoretical paradigm should begin with a definition of paradigm. Following Kuhn (1970), the definition reads: a paradigm is the world view, belief systems, series of assumptions, methods, techniques and exemplars for problem solution held in common by a scientific community. The critique here is meant to apply to AEE as a theoretical paradigm in general, often referred to as evolutionary behavioral ecology and to its submodels and subtheories, in particular optimal foraging theory and life history theory. The critique is divided into seven sections, closely paralleling the structure of Figure 1. This scheme depicts the general components of theory and their degrees of development. Basically, as theory develops, it changes in two major ways: 1) through the addition of theoretical components (see rows in Figure 1); and 2) through the refinement of components (see columns in Figure 1). This scheme shows both increase in the number and refinement of components as theory matures. The column headings from left to right represent increasing development of theory, whereas the rows from top to bottom indicate increasing completeness of theory. Box 1 describes the major components of theory that are referred to in the rows of Figure 1. Box 2 describes the stages of maturation depicted in the columns of Figure 1. During the early stages of theory development, the emphasis is on the addition of components. By the consolidating stage of theory development all of the components are in place. Subsequently, refinement of components is emphasized. Thus, as theory develops, it becomes more and more complete, by the addition and refinement of theoretical notions, constructs, derived constructs, and structure. Increasing richness of components is a hallmark of maturing theory. For AEE, notions, assumptions, facts, and hypotheses developed early, with assumptions being the first to be fully developed. But notions are not yet fully explicit, and confirmed generalizations, models, translation modes, domain and the framework are still in the process of being refined. The stages of maturation depicted in the columns of Fig. 1 can be thought of as an idealized developmental sequence. Theory change is actually often chaotic, reflecting a combination of different empirical pursuits and different subtheories, and in the case of AEE, more complex or highly derived components have not yet accompanied simpler ones. Draw-ing on other theories for components has also resulted in transfer problems, where those components have acquired different meanings and interpretations problematic in their new context. Nonetheless, the key idea is that the jobs a theory is able to do depend upon its stage of maturity (Box 2); that is, the richness of its roster of theoretical components and their refinement. As a theory begins to take shape and to be used it often becomes clear that existing components must be replaced or refined. Theory may emerge from pre-theoretic notions by adding components, without showing much refinement. At the consolidating stage basic conceptual components are refined, empirical content is refined and expanded, derived conceptual components are added and refined, and the theoretical framework and structure begin to take shape. …" @default.
- W2005538184 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2005538184 creator A5029704055 @default.
- W2005538184 date "2000-01-01" @default.
- W2005538184 modified "2023-10-01" @default.
- W2005538184 title "Anthropological Evolutionary Ecology: A Critique" @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1487048118 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1487065577 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1493919779 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1538145493 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1542252128 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1543166800 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1544815196 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1546755579 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1548764418 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1557699102 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1558067753 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1559721966 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1584053331 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1601344902 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1645338881 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1914836431 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1967407793 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1968746699 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1971144413 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1972535167 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1974402527 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1978416749 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1982844551 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1983092075 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1983260349 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1988907789 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1991355578 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W1997637055 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2005738481 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2012850626 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2013662503 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2021413733 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2038385776 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2050960442 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2060112036 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2066261007 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2074397232 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2074477189 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2077930906 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2091123269 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2092036162 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2106533942 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2109931630 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2112097992 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2116199508 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2136284908 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2277951137 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W249333330 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2607861372 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2753533763 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2904256401 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W2139353929 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W3021525072 @default.
- W2005538184 cites W3026239710 @default.
- W2005538184 doi "https://doi.org/10.5038/2162-4593.4.1.1" @default.
- W2005538184 hasPublicationYear "2000" @default.
- W2005538184 type Work @default.
- W2005538184 sameAs 2005538184 @default.
- W2005538184 citedByCount "10" @default.
- W2005538184 countsByYear W20055381842012 @default.
- W2005538184 countsByYear W20055381842013 @default.
- W2005538184 countsByYear W20055381842016 @default.
- W2005538184 countsByYear W20055381842019 @default.
- W2005538184 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2005538184 hasAuthorship W2005538184A5029704055 @default.
- W2005538184 hasBestOaLocation W20055381841 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C126831891 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C135811302 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C149923435 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C165287380 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C196919123 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C2908647359 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C2989147100 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C43540301 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C47318914 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C49539007 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C111472728 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C126831891 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C135811302 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C138885662 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C144024400 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C149923435 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C165287380 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C18903297 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C196919123 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C2908647359 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C2989147100 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C43540301 @default.
- W2005538184 hasConceptScore W2005538184C47318914 @default.