Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2009297807> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2009297807 endingPage "37" @default.
- W2009297807 startingPage "29" @default.
- W2009297807 abstract "Several articles have proposed echocardiographic reference values in normal pediatric subjects, but adequate validation is often lacking and has not been reviewed. The aim of this study was to review published reference values in pediatric two-dimensional and M-mode echocardiography with a specific focus on the adequacy of the statistical and mathematical methods used to normalize echocardiographic measurements. All articles proposing reference values for transthoracic pediatric echocardiography were reviewed. The types of measurements, the methods of normalization, the regression models used, and the methods used to detect potential bias in proposed reference values were abstracted. The detection of residual associations, residual heteroscedasticity, and departures from the normal distribution theory predictions were specifically analyzed. Fifty-two studies met the inclusion criteria. Most authors (87%) used parametric normalization to account for body size, but their approaches were very heterogeneous. Linear regression and indexing were the most common models. Heteroscedasticity was often present but was mentioned in only 27% of studies. The absence of residual heteroscedasticity and residual associations between the normalized measurements and the independent variables were mentioned in only 9% and 22% of the studies, respectively. Only 14% of studies documented that the distribution of the residual values was appropriate for Z score calculation or that the proportion of subjects falling outside the reference range was appropriate. Statistical suitability of the proposed reference ranges was often incompletely documented. This review underlines the great need for better standardization in echocardiographic measurement normalization. Several articles have proposed echocardiographic reference values in normal pediatric subjects, but adequate validation is often lacking and has not been reviewed. The aim of this study was to review published reference values in pediatric two-dimensional and M-mode echocardiography with a specific focus on the adequacy of the statistical and mathematical methods used to normalize echocardiographic measurements. All articles proposing reference values for transthoracic pediatric echocardiography were reviewed. The types of measurements, the methods of normalization, the regression models used, and the methods used to detect potential bias in proposed reference values were abstracted. The detection of residual associations, residual heteroscedasticity, and departures from the normal distribution theory predictions were specifically analyzed. Fifty-two studies met the inclusion criteria. Most authors (87%) used parametric normalization to account for body size, but their approaches were very heterogeneous. Linear regression and indexing were the most common models. Heteroscedasticity was often present but was mentioned in only 27% of studies. The absence of residual heteroscedasticity and residual associations between the normalized measurements and the independent variables were mentioned in only 9% and 22% of the studies, respectively. Only 14% of studies documented that the distribution of the residual values was appropriate for Z score calculation or that the proportion of subjects falling outside the reference range was appropriate. Statistical suitability of the proposed reference ranges was often incompletely documented. This review underlines the great need for better standardization in echocardiographic measurement normalization. Current Pediatric Nomograms Are Only One Source of Error for Quantification in Pediatric Echocardiography: What to Expect from Future ResearchJournal of the American Society of EchocardiographyVol. 26Issue 8PreviewI read with interest the article by Mawad et al.1 titled “A Review and Critique of the Statistical Methods Used to Generate Reference Values in Pediatric Echocardiography,” recently published in JASE, which highlights my group's previous observations pertaining to the limitations of current pediatric nomograms.2 There continues to be a need for more robust and accurate pediatric nomograms, with ongoing efforts to establish these at this time.3,4 Valid nomograms are needed to reduce errors in pediatric echocardiographic quantification. Full-Text PDF" @default.
- W2009297807 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2009297807 creator A5004231336 @default.
- W2009297807 creator A5046129550 @default.
- W2009297807 creator A5056599652 @default.
- W2009297807 creator A5087003356 @default.
- W2009297807 date "2013-01-01" @default.
- W2009297807 modified "2023-09-30" @default.
- W2009297807 title "A Review and Critique of the Statistical Methods Used to Generate Reference Values in Pediatric Echocardiography" @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1497679485 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1865123201 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1969165007 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1973228705 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1975847017 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1976085768 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1981047678 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1988720372 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1990307839 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1992141724 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1995652669 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1996604181 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1998411828 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W1999218711 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2005815716 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2013195725 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2014382398 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2018734433 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2020521847 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2020638942 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2021087224 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2021839309 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2022195092 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2022381389 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2029162985 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2032424713 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2038414262 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2042092256 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2044861416 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2050715588 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2051637147 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2056887954 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2059618162 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2060257349 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2060903861 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2061041330 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2062343814 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2063876399 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2068429165 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2068894348 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2070509383 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2071347528 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2072371345 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2076313335 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2080586599 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2084853819 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2099204816 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2116089681 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2118615015 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2119483101 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2119970311 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2121627023 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2130277362 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2131301406 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2136356633 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2139537565 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2142569161 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2147283478 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2148073595 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2160232053 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2160599980 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2171888399 @default.
- W2009297807 cites W2779429269 @default.
- W2009297807 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.echo.2012.09.021" @default.
- W2009297807 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23140845" @default.
- W2009297807 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
- W2009297807 type Work @default.
- W2009297807 sameAs 2009297807 @default.
- W2009297807 citedByCount "72" @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072013 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072014 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072015 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072016 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072017 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072018 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072019 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072020 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072021 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072022 @default.
- W2009297807 countsByYear W20092978072023 @default.
- W2009297807 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2009297807 hasAuthorship W2009297807A5004231336 @default.
- W2009297807 hasAuthorship W2009297807A5046129550 @default.
- W2009297807 hasAuthorship W2009297807A5056599652 @default.
- W2009297807 hasAuthorship W2009297807A5087003356 @default.
- W2009297807 hasConcept C101104100 @default.
- W2009297807 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2009297807 hasConcept C11413529 @default.
- W2009297807 hasConcept C117251300 @default.