Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2011861834> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2011861834 abstract "“Never Again”: The Ethics of the Neighbor and the Logic of Genocide Robert Meister (bio) Proximity and Ethics Since the fall of communism, there has been a growing literature on the responsibility of the “world community” to “never again” stand by while neighbors commit atrocities against neighbors (Power, “Never Again”).1 This literature has yet to be reformulated as a comprehensive political theory of the recent fin de siècle, but it is already clear that such a theory would base a global politics of human rights on an ethical commitment to view local cruelties, and especially the infliction of physical suffering, as an uncontestable evil, the prevention of which can justify external intervention in ways that earlier forms of imperialism did not. The interstate system still exists, of course, and is supported by a United Nations charter that prohibits unilateral invasions of one state by another. But from the standpoint of the advancing theory of humanitarian intervention this is now merely a practical obstacle, making it advisable (but not essential) for a state intervening in another on purely ethical grounds to claim the support of a multilateral coalition as a proxy for the world community itself. At the level of theory, if not yet of practice, the subject matter of global politics is already focused on humanitarian intervention to stop atrocities committed at the local level. Thus the primacy of the global over the local (which was once the basis of political imperialism) is now ostensibly humanized and offset by the primacy of the ethical over the political: an ethics that concerns the cruelties that groups inflict on others in close proximity, and a politics surrounding the responsibility of third parties to intervene in response to those cruelties. I am not here making the point that such humanitarian interventions can involve violence committed at a distance, though they often do. The intervention to prevent the proximate violence by Kosovar Serbs against their Albanian neighbors consisted largely of the NATO bombing of Serbian cities. Both the ethnic cleansing of neighbors and the aerial bombardment of cities are prima facie violations of modern humanitarian law, and both are the subject of separate trials now underway in The Hague. These trials demonstrate the twentieth-century paradox that bombing is both the quintessential means of intervention to stop barbarity at a local level and the paradigm of barbarity inflicted at a distance (see Lindqvist, A History of Bombing). My topic is not whether the “world community” should have (at least) bombed Auschwitz or Rwanda when the genocides there became known, but rather the conception of ethics and politics that underlies such dilemmas. According to this conception, bombing (like foreign occupation) can be a justifiable form of political intervention by third parties when preceded by gross ethical barbarities occurring among neighbors. The ethical condemnation of atrocity, if not the atrocity itself, must here precede political intervention. Contemporary humanitarian practice requires such a sequence because it is based on the premise that, in theory too, ethics comes before politics. The opposing position—putting politics before ethics—is now commonly derided as the error shared by right and left throughout the twentieth century, an era of revolution and counterrevolution in which individuals were exquisitely sensitive to the suffering of their comrades and insensitive to pain inflicted on their foes (see Glover and Rummel). This is what politics is, Carl Schmitt argues—a selective antidote to humanitarian pathos that makes it ultimately possible to kill (and die) for the sake of countrymen or comrades (Concept of the Political 71). The emergent literature on human rights implicitly shares Schmitt’s “concept of the political,” and for this very reason gives primacy to the ethical as a refusal to withhold one’s empathy selectively on political grounds. The primacy of ethics over politics implicitly presupposes, however, specific limitations on the field of ethics itself. Viewed broadly, the raw material of ethics concerns languages and bodies in the sense that these are what matter from the ethical perspective when considering questions of agency and choice.2 Ethical discussion of languages (and cultural systems that resemble languages) are now commonly expected to focus on the problem of difference, and to prefer..." @default.
- W2011861834 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2011861834 creator A5038182953 @default.
- W2011861834 date "2005-01-01" @default.
- W2011861834 modified "2023-10-02" @default.
- W2011861834 title ""Never Again": The Ethics of the Neighbor and the Logic of Genocide" @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1022946631 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W102441962 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W116801716 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1485184078 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1486145806 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1487798886 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1499151976 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W150111143 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1512597729 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1514519655 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1520254312 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1520329473 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1527913150 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1528006154 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1529533070 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1531069750 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1537640319 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1543777908 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1550002899 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1554006359 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1554426594 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1560705824 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1568342723 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1569434672 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1580191251 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1596116628 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1597183254 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1606294492 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1614549126 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1736309286 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W182294198 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1884641665 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1944150654 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1969878848 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1970106651 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1971091929 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1975833254 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1977743617 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1986174033 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1992373299 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W1996546881 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2005572195 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2007130754 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2010220158 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2024933928 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2026776291 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2029082893 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2030226669 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2034776050 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2037781743 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2042949568 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2052056912 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2056479290 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2059176358 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2060435368 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2060908149 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2069059127 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2080691223 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2080794289 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2082422522 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2084013884 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2091136171 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2093055080 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2093097231 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2093899524 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2108428831 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2108683313 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2109532669 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2111879067 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2135537502 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2163621568 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2224699313 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2593498238 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2795490206 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2795770927 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2798357413 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2799640702 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2800069993 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2980113350 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W3005898555 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W316669991 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W560359246 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W570179614 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W573252223 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W606401630 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W612180681 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W62917520 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W631128470 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W650153838 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W76477130 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2561114930 @default.
- W2011861834 cites W2799214955 @default.
- W2011861834 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/pmc.2005.0010" @default.
- W2011861834 hasPublicationYear "2005" @default.