Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2014703429> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 53 of
53
with 100 items per page.
- W2014703429 endingPage "81" @default.
- W2014703429 startingPage "169" @default.
- W2014703429 abstract "Part One: In Defense of Medicine Chapter XIII. Farewell to Clinical Medicine? My Left Kidney. I recently complained of pain in my left side; it appeared during a urinary infection, and recurred four months later. I examined myself as well as I could, and told my HMO internist that I had palpated the lower pole of my left kidney, that it was tender, and that squeezing the organ reproduced my complaint. I was not really worried, that is, didn't think of a tumor; if the pain were due to a tumor, why should it appear during a urinary infection, or disappear for several months? I rather thought of a cyst, or an impairment of the outflow of urine with, as a result, hydronephrosis, that is, overfilling of the kidney's urine-collecting spaces, distending the organ. I asked the doctor if he would consider examining the kidney with ultrasound. I told him that I duly identified the kidney by its rounded, slightly flattened shape, resiliency, ballottement between the two palpating hands, and typical mobility with respiration. The doctor gave me a long look, as if I were telling him I was seeing ghosts. Then he patiently explained to me that palpation of kidneys was a method of low sensitivity; that what I had felt could have been the colon, or anything else; and that the kidney, being situated outside the peritoneal cavity, could not move with respiration. All these explanations were complete rubbish. When a positive finding is claimed, the sensitivity of the method is not in question. Colon, being felt as an oblong soft wad without palpable lower end, cannot be mistaken for a kidney. The site of organs within or outside of the peritoneal cavity has nothing to do with their respiratory mobility. Organs move with respiration if they are attached to the diaphragm, as is the liver, or if they are loose in their bedding as are the spleen and kidneys, and the movement of the diaphragm pushes them down when the subject is breathing in. It is respiratory mobility that enables us to palpate the kidney. Thus, each of us knew for sure that the other was talking nonsense. Having denied the value of kidney palpation, the doctor nevertheless tried to do it. He told me not to breathe deeply, and several times poked the left side of my belly with the tips of his outstretched fingers. The maneuver could not serve any purpose, either in medical examination or otherwise. It certainly could not be used to palpate a kidney. Finding nothing, the doctor said: No ultrasound is needed, but since you are a physician, and ask for it, I'll order it for you. The ultrasound revealed a hydronephrosis. The ineptitude of my HMO internist in his attempt to examine my kidney is, alas, no exception; it is now the rule. It is the sad consequence of the fact that medical men and women no longer learn the art of medicine from experienced physicians. (102) A master would show them how to position the patient and how to teach the patient diaphragmatic breathing; how to warm up the examining hand and place it flat on the patient's skin; how to exert delicate pressure, avoid eliciting muscular defense, run the hand first cursorily around the abdomen, check the points that give clue to disease of the appendix, of the gall bladder, of the colon; how to slip the hand off to check for peritoneal irritation, and then set about examining each particular organ. He will explain to the student what he feels under his fingers, will verify his findings, confirming that this round shape, moving with respiration, is the distended gallbladder, and the soft touch he's felt, yes, is the spleen. Nowadays, this kind of instruction is rarely given and even less frequently requested. Since I moved to the United States I've had the opportunity to watch more than a dozen American doctors trying to examine the abdomens of their patients. It was a sad picture every time. They exerted rather brutal pressure with one or both hands, here and there, without a slightest chance to identify any of the abdominal organs; determine their size, shape, or tenderness; reproduce the patient's complaint; or check the classical signs of disease. …" @default.
- W2014703429 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2014703429 creator A5045266689 @default.
- W2014703429 date "2009-01-01" @default.
- W2014703429 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W2014703429 title "Other people's lives: reflections on medicine, ethics, and euthanasia." @default.
- W2014703429 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23437677" @default.
- W2014703429 hasPublicationYear "2009" @default.
- W2014703429 type Work @default.
- W2014703429 sameAs 2014703429 @default.
- W2014703429 citedByCount "3" @default.
- W2014703429 countsByYear W20147034292012 @default.
- W2014703429 countsByYear W20147034292014 @default.
- W2014703429 countsByYear W20147034292015 @default.
- W2014703429 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2014703429 hasAuthorship W2014703429A5045266689 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C141071460 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C2780091579 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C2781040948 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C2781167935 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C61434518 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConcept C77411442 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C126322002 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C141071460 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C2780091579 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C2781040948 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C2781167935 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C61434518 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C71924100 @default.
- W2014703429 hasConceptScore W2014703429C77411442 @default.
- W2014703429 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W2014703429 hasLocation W20147034291 @default.
- W2014703429 hasOpenAccess W2014703429 @default.
- W2014703429 hasPrimaryLocation W20147034291 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W145339093 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W1989370953 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W2041226631 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W2093312909 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W2095891485 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W2130041780 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W2305382906 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W2883908590 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W2969705730 @default.
- W2014703429 hasRelatedWork W4371815 @default.
- W2014703429 hasVolume "25" @default.
- W2014703429 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2014703429 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W2014703429 magId "2014703429" @default.
- W2014703429 workType "article" @default.