Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2015328208> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2015328208 endingPage "179" @default.
- W2015328208 startingPage "169" @default.
- W2015328208 abstract "The success rates reported for secondary structural class prediction with different methods are contradictory. On one side, the problem of recognizing the secondary structural class of a protein knowing only its amino acid composition appears completely solved by simply applying jury decision with an elliptically scaled distance function. Chou and coworkers repeatedly (see Crit. Rev. Biochem. Mol. Biol. 30:275–349, 1995) published prediction accuracies near 100%. On the other hand, traditional secondary structure prediction techniques achieve success rates of about 70% for the secondary structural state per residue and about 75% for structural class only with extensive input information (full sequence of the query protein, its amino acid composition and length, multiple alignments with homologous sequences). In this article, we resolve the paradox and consider (1) the question of the secondary structural class definition, (2) the role of the representativity of the test set of protein tertiary structure for the current state of the Protein Data Bank (PDB); and (3) we estimate the real impact of amino acid composition on secondary structural class. We formulate three objective criteria for a reasonable definition of secondary structural classes and show that only the criterion of Nakashima et al. (J. Biochem. 99:153–162, 1986) complies with all of them. Only this definition matches the distribution of secondary structural content in representative PDB subsets, whereas other criteria leave many proteins (up to 65% of all PDB entries) simply unassigned. We review critically specialized secondary-structural class prediction methods, especially those of Chou and coworkers, which claim almost 100% accuracy using only amino acid composition, and resolve the paradox that these prediction accuracies are better than those from secondary structure predictions from multiple alignments. We show (i) that these techniques rely on a preselection of test sets which removes irregular proteins and other proteins without any class assignment (about 35% of all PDB entries); and (ii) that even for preselected representative test sets, the success rate drops to 60% and lower for a 4-type classification (α, β, α + β, α/β). The prediction accuracies fall to about 50% if the secondary structural class definition of Nakashima et al. is applied and only few irregular proteins are preselected and removed from automatically generated, representative subsets of the PDB. We have applied two new vector decomposition methods for secondary structural content prediction from amino acid composition alone, with and without consideration of amino acid compositional coupling in the learning set of tertiary structures respectively, to the problem of class prediction and achieve about 60% correct assignment among four classes (α, β, mixed, irregular) as well as single sequence-based secondary structure prediction methods like GORIII and COMBI. Our results demonstrate that 60% correctness is the upper limit for a 4-type class prediction from amino acid composition alone for an unknown query protein and that consideration of compositional coupling does not improve the prediction success. The prediction program SSCP offering secondary structural class assignment for query compositions and sequences has been made available as a World Wide Web and E-mail service. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc." @default.
- W2015328208 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2015328208 creator A5007579711 @default.
- W2015328208 creator A5055015179 @default.
- W2015328208 creator A5063489663 @default.
- W2015328208 date "1996-06-01" @default.
- W2015328208 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2015328208 title "Prediction of secondary structural content of proteins from their amino acid composition alone. II. The paradox with secondary structural class" @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1498124562 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1588131283 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1780090776 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1820648369 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1821507858 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1966041739 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1976621816 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1984226817 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1985818354 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1989447327 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W1998723057 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2007569291 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2008708467 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2013136212 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2019949712 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2035066314 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2045157845 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2050991936 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2052981282 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2067305692 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2084404717 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2086279734 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2095222655 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2099302461 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2108432201 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2120026469 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2125864094 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2142114994 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2171901005 @default.
- W2015328208 cites W2027226403 @default.
- W2015328208 doi "https://doi.org/10.1002/(sici)1097-0134(199606)25:2<169::aid-prot3>3.0.co;2-d" @default.
- W2015328208 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8811733" @default.
- W2015328208 hasPublicationYear "1996" @default.
- W2015328208 type Work @default.
- W2015328208 sameAs 2015328208 @default.
- W2015328208 citedByCount "44" @default.
- W2015328208 countsByYear W20153282082013 @default.
- W2015328208 countsByYear W20153282082015 @default.
- W2015328208 countsByYear W20153282082017 @default.
- W2015328208 countsByYear W20153282082018 @default.
- W2015328208 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2015328208 hasAuthorship W2015328208A5007579711 @default.
- W2015328208 hasAuthorship W2015328208A5055015179 @default.
- W2015328208 hasAuthorship W2015328208A5063489663 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C11413529 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C119145174 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C2777212361 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C2779138802 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C2780362125 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C47701112 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C515207424 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C62614982 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C65556437 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C11413529 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C119145174 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C154945302 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C185592680 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C2777212361 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C2779138802 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C2780362125 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C33923547 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C41008148 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C47701112 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C515207424 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C55493867 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C62614982 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C65556437 @default.
- W2015328208 hasConceptScore W2015328208C86803240 @default.
- W2015328208 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W2015328208 hasLocation W20153282081 @default.
- W2015328208 hasLocation W20153282082 @default.
- W2015328208 hasOpenAccess W2015328208 @default.
- W2015328208 hasPrimaryLocation W20153282081 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W2017505838 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W2045062364 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W2121688928 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W2728406523 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W2731937419 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W2732388178 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W2806488847 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W3093468851 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W3126783617 @default.
- W2015328208 hasRelatedWork W4353055924 @default.
- W2015328208 hasVolume "25" @default.