Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2017758363> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2017758363 endingPage "592" @default.
- W2017758363 startingPage "585" @default.
- W2017758363 abstract "When it comes to stuttering, one must be very careful of a priori assumptions they may have formed about the nature of the disorder and its associated behaviors. A broad understanding and thorough familiarity with the evidence are essential to averting misinterpretations, such as those made by Wingate, concerning the bases of terminology (SLD) and category (part-word repetitions) selections. We understand Wingate’s impression regarding the primary role of syllable repetitions, given that typically they are the most common component in the disfluent speech behavior of those who stutter and that in many children they are the dominant disfluency type. Indeed, some children display few monosyllabic whole-word repetitions. Nevertheless, this does not mean that the monosyllabic whole-word repetitions, especially in very young children, are not a valid reflection of stuttering. As we have shown, Wingate’s argument can be contested in several ways. Because some fundamental measures of accuracy, validity, and internal consistency, as well as reliance on published data, are essential for credibility, we believe that his letter represents a harsh violation of these principles. Wingate has offered an opinion, but that is the limit to the nature of his remarks. His points are merely opinions because he has not considered all the evidence and has not acknowledged all the facts regarding the nature of speech and its identification. Wingate frequently makes sweeping statements (e.g., there are …clear-cut differences that exist between monosyllabic word repetitions and stutters [Wingate, 2001, p. 383]) without any substantiation from the research literature and appears to be oblivious to progress in the field. His last paragraph, which completely distorts our record of research, is scientifically dangerous. Although we appreciate his previous contributions to the field, regrettably, as we have stated earlier, his letter fails to meet acceptable scientific standards. We respectfully suggest that Wingate’s call for honestly employed scientific methods in stuttering research be directed at his own writing. Finally, our large longitudinal study on persistency and recovery in stuttering, as reported in the series of publications (e.g., Yairi & Ambrose, 1999), arbitrarily selected by Wingate for attack as a means to expose his opinion about the real thing, has been repeatedly and rigorously reviewed by various panels of the National Institutes of Health, the agency supporting this work, and by the editorial boards of several scientific journals, including JSLHR . Having been found to be of sound quality, our ongoing project has been repeatedly approved, and its findings reported in many peer-reviewed publications. We take this record as an indication that many scholars in the field evaluate our research as meritorious." @default.
- W2017758363 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2017758363 creator A5007650902 @default.
- W2017758363 creator A5040029178 @default.
- W2017758363 creator A5053534812 @default.
- W2017758363 creator A5064787757 @default.
- W2017758363 date "2001-06-01" @default.
- W2017758363 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2017758363 title "What Is Stuttering?" @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1528784932 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1964165811 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1966984472 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1968335983 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1972049603 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1974604504 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1977847897 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1980320163 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1983026830 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1987202889 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W1992372471 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2003343869 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2005275360 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2005453849 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2008477918 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2012414985 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2013652703 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2014528586 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2015588731 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2018715047 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2021090772 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2024690505 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2025358217 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2025548258 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2026553711 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2027978763 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2028759495 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2037664467 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2039423137 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2041665549 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2043504825 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2054499935 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2054899704 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2064137838 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2067950585 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2073335076 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2075038627 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2088148578 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2092648199 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2094492919 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2096944961 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2171461402 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W2997632187 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W3016238932 @default.
- W2017758363 cites W4235138339 @default.
- W2017758363 doi "https://doi.org/10.1044/1092-4388(2001/046)" @default.
- W2017758363 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11407563" @default.
- W2017758363 hasPublicationYear "2001" @default.
- W2017758363 type Work @default.
- W2017758363 sameAs 2017758363 @default.
- W2017758363 citedByCount "23" @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632013 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632014 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632015 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632016 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632017 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632018 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632019 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632021 @default.
- W2017758363 countsByYear W20177583632022 @default.
- W2017758363 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2017758363 hasAuthorship W2017758363A5007650902 @default.
- W2017758363 hasAuthorship W2017758363A5040029178 @default.
- W2017758363 hasAuthorship W2017758363A5053534812 @default.
- W2017758363 hasAuthorship W2017758363A5064787757 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C109089402 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C138496976 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C2781371259 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C547195049 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConcept C98184364 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C109089402 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C126322002 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C138496976 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C138885662 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C15744967 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C180747234 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C2781371259 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C41895202 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C547195049 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C71924100 @default.
- W2017758363 hasConceptScore W2017758363C98184364 @default.
- W2017758363 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W2017758363 hasLocation W20177583631 @default.