Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2020123979> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2020123979 endingPage "331" @default.
- W2020123979 startingPage "291" @default.
- W2020123979 abstract "The global blitzkrieg hypothesis explains differential rates of megafaunal extinction between the world's landmasses in the late Quaternary based on a proposed leap in predation efficiency enjoyed by colonising societies. It is characterised by appealing simplicity. Selective over hunting, facilitated by naiveté to human predation, produced rapid mass extinctions of large animals wherever subsistence societies colonised new landmasses. Taken at face value the circumstantial case for blitzkrieg is compelling and despite a paucity of direct evidence it has gained considerable support. Our review of the model suggests that it overlooks much contradictory data and rests on simplistic interpretations of complex biogeographicat and anthropological phenomena. These interpretations and assumptions do not account for major differences between the biotas, ecologies and human cultures of the landmasses involved. The assertion that responses of remote island species to human predation provide realistic models for those of continental taxa is poorly founded, exaggerating the likely predation efficiency of humans colonising continents. An absence of terrestrial predators over evolutionarily significant periods, together with restricted ranges and small populations, renders island faunas uniquely vulnerable to invaders. The argument, that climate cannot explain these phenomena because previous Glacial Maxima did not cause comparable extinctions, presupposes that their local effects were at least as severe as those of the Last Glacial Maximum. This has yet to be demonstrated and at most it would indirectly support a role for anthropogenic influence, not overkill per se. Overlooked or underplayed are the influences of translocated and other invading species. Similarly, differences in the origins, technologies and traditions of colonising human societies are rarely considered. These factors strongly impact on the predation efficiency, density and range of human populations, critically affecting the outcomes of predator-prey modeling. When a fuller constellation of influences and constraints is considered it is reasonable to posit that rapid mass extinction through selective human predation may largely describe megafaunal extinctions on remote islands, but the argument is not convincing for continents. This is especially so regarding Australia. Because even the largest Australian species were prey to endemic carnivores, their responses to human predation would not have been comparable to those of oceanic island species. No kill-sites or specialized big-game hunting/butchering tools are known and, on the basis of ethnographic and archaeological data, it is probable that predation efficiency, population density and range of the first Australians were insufficient to effect rapid mass extinction. Chronologies of human arrival and the disappearance of megafauna remain poor, but the most recent estimates for human-megafaunal coexistence in Australia range from 10,000 to 43,000 years. Although human predation may have been a contributing factor in megafaunal extinctions, rapid overkill is unlikely to describe the actual mechanism in most instances. The role of human predation and its significance relative to competing factors, human and otherwise, varied considerably between landmasses, as did the speeds with which extinctions occurred. Blitzkrieg and other mono-factorial models are heuristically valuable devices, but a growing body of evidence suggests that extinction can rarely, if ever, be attributed to a single cause." @default.
- W2020123979 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2020123979 creator A5057439371 @default.
- W2020123979 creator A5065476372 @default.
- W2020123979 creator A5076726939 @default.
- W2020123979 creator A5084158192 @default.
- W2020123979 date "2004-01-01" @default.
- W2020123979 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W2020123979 title "Megafaunal extinction in the late Quaternary and the global overkill hypothesis" @default.
- W2020123979 cites W120497085 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1255692035 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W130374590 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1480151315 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1483808055 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1501907839 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1530116901 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1542532100 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1558769412 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1590731603 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1609796929 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1638914699 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1813027956 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1834602081 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1887982552 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1890830868 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1918235962 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1964821643 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1966183073 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1967972900 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1973405265 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1974031613 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1974437146 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1974449202 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1975472370 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1978409311 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1978464139 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1979070457 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1979369713 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1979438949 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1980885201 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1982631046 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1982726131 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1982855130 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1987293320 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1989398607 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1990654116 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1992459639 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1992749112 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1995040688 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1995883875 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1998035453 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1998203271 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W1999165950 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2001220695 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2002841917 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2004510715 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2004573678 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2006060912 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2006473749 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2007467883 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2007860783 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2008090317 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2008660499 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2010279019 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2013012139 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2013047551 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2013642792 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2015165154 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2020558635 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2020901419 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2021396320 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2021842817 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2024649846 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2025411818 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2025869210 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2030064287 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2030584469 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2030717369 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2031172447 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2031292062 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2031446293 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2032471612 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2032764738 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2035698850 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2036382937 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2037069709 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2039208027 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2039309524 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2041022142 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2041617623 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2042041416 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2045177472 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2045663047 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2046584249 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2047352618 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2047403005 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2047920341 @default.
- W2020123979 cites W2049360960 @default.