Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2023169128> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2023169128 endingPage "183" @default.
- W2023169128 startingPage "151" @default.
- W2023169128 abstract "After Contrastive Analysis was called into question because it could not predict areas of difficulty, it was modified into the so‐called moderate version, claiming that similar phenomena are more difficult to acquire than dissimilar phenomena (see Oller & Ziahosseiny, 1970). Eckman (1977) added a very significant modification to further salvage Contrastive Analysis by incorporating markedness. In addition, the prolific work of Flege on similarity,including his Speech Learning Model (1995), has provided us with extensive data on degree of difficulty in second language acquisition. Although the bulk of his and his collaborators' work supports his claim that similar sounds are harder to learn than dissimilar sounds, there are important exceptions (e.g., Bohn & Flege, 1992). Furthermore, other researchers have presented conflicting claims and results. The importance of this chapter is that it ties together similarity and markedness in a claim concerning rate of acquisition, rather than “degree of difficulty”—a vaguely defined term. The Similarity Differential Rate Hypothesis (SDRH) quite simply claims that similar phenomena are acquired at faster rates than dissimilar phenomena and that markedness is a mediating factor that slows rate. In making its claims, it calls into question some widespread time‐honored concepts in L1 and L2 studies that are poorly defined or mean different things to different researchers. Specifically, what criterion level or percent accuracy is needed for a phenomenon to be “acquired”? What does it mean for x to be acquired before y ? If at Stage I, x = 40% accuracy and y = 20% accuracy, we could say x is acquired before y and is less difficult; but if at Stage II, x = 50% and y = 80%, we could say y is acquired before x and is more difficult. In light of this, the SDRH claims that we have been asking the wrong questions, and that rate is the significant factor. In the example above, what is consistent is rate: The rate of acquisition of y is faster than x . In L1 acquisition research, although order of acquisition has been a perennial concern (e.g., Jakobson, 1941, 1968, and current research on the minimal word involving morae), according to David Ingram (personal communication, 1998), rate has not been a major topic in L1 phonology. (Although Ingram himself [1991] has talked about gradual and abrupt rates, he says there is no explanation why these variable patterns exist.) However, because rates have predictive implications (with the caveat that any learner, L1 or L2, may fossilize at any point) and because L1 and L2 phenomena are reflected in a wide range of contexts—for example, historical change, languages in contact, and dialect variation—it follows that the investigation of rate is an important area of research for both L1 and L2 acquisition." @default.
- W2023169128 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2023169128 creator A5024529540 @default.
- W2023169128 creator A5040036114 @default.
- W2023169128 date "1999-01-01" @default.
- W2023169128 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W2023169128 title "The Similarity Differential Rate Hypothesis" @default.
- W2023169128 cites W136008933 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W1491767415 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W1594715170 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W1966670463 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W1982147372 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W1982680659 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2006554790 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2034658764 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2043235557 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2057544714 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2061368037 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2061858523 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2064526374 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2080981630 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2091704101 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2100721477 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2104056381 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2105061347 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2113921308 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2134114503 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2140516903 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2151718928 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2165919472 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2169405831 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2289074721 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2479056805 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W2800866707 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W3082134291 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W3146540230 @default.
- W2023169128 cites W42495856 @default.
- W2023169128 doi "https://doi.org/10.1111/0023-8333.49.s1.5" @default.
- W2023169128 hasPublicationYear "1999" @default.
- W2023169128 type Work @default.
- W2023169128 sameAs 2023169128 @default.
- W2023169128 citedByCount "41" @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282012 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282013 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282014 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282015 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282016 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282017 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282018 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282019 @default.
- W2023169128 countsByYear W20231691282021 @default.
- W2023169128 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2023169128 hasAuthorship W2023169128A5024529540 @default.
- W2023169128 hasAuthorship W2023169128A5040036114 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C103278499 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C115961682 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C127413603 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C146978453 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C2776134746 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C50335755 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConcept C93226319 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C103278499 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C111472728 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C115961682 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C127413603 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C138885662 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C146978453 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C154945302 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C15744967 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C180747234 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C2776134746 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C41008148 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C41895202 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C50335755 @default.
- W2023169128 hasConceptScore W2023169128C93226319 @default.
- W2023169128 hasIssue "s1" @default.
- W2023169128 hasLocation W20231691281 @default.
- W2023169128 hasOpenAccess W2023169128 @default.
- W2023169128 hasPrimaryLocation W20231691281 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2013930075 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2122447715 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2132495287 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2356680465 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2356926490 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2362603658 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2365794051 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W2383214308 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W3160468994 @default.
- W2023169128 hasRelatedWork W4249974089 @default.
- W2023169128 hasVolume "49" @default.
- W2023169128 isParatext "false" @default.